Agatha Christie

Nemesis

A Miss Marple Mystery

To Dauphne Honeybone

One

OVERTURE

In the afternoons it was the custom of Miss Jane Marple to unfold her second newspaper. Two newspapers were delivered at her house every morning. The first one Miss Marple read while sipping her early morning tea, that is, if it was delivered in time. The boy who delivered the papers was notably erratic in his management of time. Frequently, too, there was either a new boy or a boy who was acting temporarily as a stand-in for the first one. And each one would have ideas of his own as to the geographical route that he should take in delivering. Perhaps it varied monotony for him. But those customers who were used to reading their paper early so that they could snap up the more saucy items in the dayâs news before departing for their bus, train or other means of progress to the dayâs work were annoyed if the papers were late, though the middle-aged and elderly ladies who resided peacefully in St. Mary Mead often preferred to read a newspaper propped up on their breakfast table.

Today, Miss Marple had absorbed the front page and a few other items in the daily paper that she had nicknamed âthe Daily All-Sorts,â this being a slightly satirical allusion to the fact that her paper, the Daily Newsgiver, owing to a change of proprietor, to her own and to other of her friendsâ great annoyance, now provided articles on menâs tailoring, womenâs dress, female heartthrobs, competitions for children, and complaining letters from women and had managed pretty well to shove any real news off any part of it but the front page, or to some obscure corner where it was impossible to find it. Miss Marple, being old-fashioned, preferred her newspapers to be newspapers and give you news.

In the afternoon, having finished her luncheon, treated herself to twenty minutesâ nap in a specially purchased, upright armchair which catered for the demands of her rheumatic back, she had opened The Times, which lent itself still to a more leisurely perusal. Not that The Times was what it used to be. The maddening thing about The Times was that you couldnât find anything anymore. Instead of going through from the front page and knowing where everything else was so that you passed easily to any special articles on subjects in which you were interested, there were now extraordinary interruptions to this time-honoured programme. Two pages were suddenly devoted to travel in Capri with illustrations. Sport appeared with far more prominence than it had ever had in the old days. Court news and obituaries were a little more faithful to routine. The births, marriages and deaths which had at one time occupied Miss Marpleâs attention first of all owing to their prominent position had migrated to a different part of The Times, though of late, Miss Marple noted, they had come almost permanently to rest on the back page.

Miss Marple gave her attention first to the main news on the front page. She did not linger long on that because it was equivalent to what she had already read this morning, though possibly couched in a slightly more dignified manner. She cast her eye down the table of contents. Articles, comments, science, sport; then she pursued her usual plan, turned the paper over and had a quick run down the births, marriages and deaths, after which she proposed to turn to the page given to correspondence, where she nearly always found something to enjoy; from that she passed on to the Court Circular, on which page todayâs news from the Sale Rooms could also be found. A short article on Science was often placed there but she did not propose to read that. It seldom made sense for her.

Having turned the paper over as usual to the births, marriages and deaths, Miss Marple thought to herself, as so often before,

âItâs sad really, but nowadays one is only interested in the deaths!â

People had babies, but the people who had babies were not likely to be even known by name to Miss Marple. If there had been a column dealing with babies labelled as grandchildren, there might have been some chance of a pleasurable recognition. She might have thought to herself,

âReally, Mary Prendergast has had a third granddaughter!,â though even that perhaps might have been a bit remote.

She skimmed down Marriages, also with not a very close survey, because most of her old friendsâ daughters or sons had married some years ago already. She came to the Deaths column, and gave that her more serious attention. Gave it enough, in fact, so as to be sure she would not miss a name. Alloway, Angopastro, Arden, Barton, Bedshaw, Burgoweisserâ(dear me, what a German name, but he seemed to be late of Leeds). Carpenter, Camperdown, Clegg. Clegg? Now was that one of the Cleggs she knew? No, it didnât seem to be. Janet Clegg. Somewhere in Yorkshire. McDonald, McKenzie, Nicholson. Nicholson? No. Again not a Nicholson she knew. Ogg, Ormerodâthat must be one of the aunts, she thought. Yes, probably so. Linda Ormerod. No, she hadnât known her. Quantril? Dear me, that must be Elizabeth Quantril. Eighty-five. Well, really! She had thought Elizabeth Quantril had died some years ago. Fancy her having lived so long! So delicate sheâd always been, too. Nobody had expected her to make old bones. Race, Radley, Rafiel. Rafiel? Something stirred. That name was familiar. Rafiel. Belford Park, Maidstone. Belford Park, Maidstone. No, she couldnât recall that address. No flowers. Jason Rafiel. Oh well, an unusual name. She supposed sheâd just heard it somewhere. Ross-Perkins. Now that might beâno, it wasnât. Ryland? Emily Ryland. No. No, sheâd never known an Emily Ryland. Deeply loved by her husband and children. Well, very nice or very sad. Whichever way you liked to look at it.

Miss Marple laid down her paper, glancing idly through the crossword while she puzzled to remember why the name Rafiel was familiar to her.

âIt will come to me,â said Miss Marple, knowing from long experience the way old peopleâs memories worked.

âItâll come to me, I have no doubt.â

She glanced out of the window towards the garden, withdrew her gaze and tried to put the garden out of her mind. Her garden had been the source of great pleasure and also a great deal of hard work to Miss Marple for many, many years. And now, owing to the fussiness of doctors, working in the garden was forbidden to her. Sheâd once tried to fight this ban, but had come to the conclusion that she had, after all, better do as she was told. She had arranged her chair at such an angle as not to be easy to look out in the garden unless she definitely and clearly wished to see something in particular. She sighed, picked up her knitting bag and took out a small childâs woolly jacket in process of coming to a conclusion. The back was done and the front. Now she would have to get on with the sleeves. Sleeves were always boring. Two sleeves, both alike. Yes, very boring. Pretty coloured pink wool, however. Pink wool. Now wait a minute, where did that fit in? Yesâyesâit fitted in with that name sheâd just read in the paper. Pink wool. A blue sea. A Caribbean sea. A sandy beach. Sunshine. Herself knitting andâwhy, of course, Mr. Rafiel. That trip she had made to the Caribbean. The island of St. HonorÃ©. A treat from her nephew Raymond. And she remembered Joan, her niece-in-law, Raymondâs wife, saying:

âDonât get mixed up in any more murders, Aunt Jane. It isnât good for you.â

Well, she hadnât wished to get mixed up in any murders, but it just happened. That was all. Simply because of an elderly Major with a glass eye who had insisted on telling her some very long and boring stories. Poor Majorânow what was his name? Sheâd forgotten that now. Mr. Rafiel and his secretary, Mrs.âMrs. Walters, yes, Esther Walters, and his masseur-attendant, Jackson. It all came back. Well, well. Poor Mr. Rafiel. So Mr. Rafiel was dead. He had known he was going to die before very long. He had practically told her so. It seemed as though he had lasted longer than the doctors had thought. He was a strong man, an obstinate manâa very rich man.

Miss Marple remained in thought, her knitting needles working regularly, but her mind not really on her knitting. Her mind was on the late Mr. Rafiel, and remembering what she could remember about him. Not an easy man to forget, really. She could conjure his appearance up mentally quite well. Yes, a very definite personality, a difficult man, an irritable man, shockingly rude sometimes. Nobody ever resented his being rude, though. She remembered that also. They didnât resent his being rude because he was so rich. Yes, he had been very rich. He had had his secretary with him and a valet attendant, a qualified masseur. He had not been able to get about very well without help.

Rather a doubtful character that nurse-attendant had been, Miss Marple thought. Mr. Rafiel had been very rude to him sometimes. He had never seemed to mind. And that, again, of course was because Mr. Rafiel was so rich.

âNobody else would pay him half what I do,â Mr. Rafiel had said, âand he knows it. Heâs good at his job, though.â

Miss Marple wondered whether Jackson?âJohnson? had stayed on with Mr. Rafiel. Stayed on for what must have beenâanother year? A year and three or four months. She thought probably not. Mr. Rafiel was one who liked a change. He got tired of people, tired of their ways, tired of their faces, tired of their voices.

Miss Marple understood that. She had felt the same sometimes. That companion of hers, that nice, attentive, maddening woman with her cooing voice.

âAh,â said Miss Marple, âwhat a change for the better sinceââ oh dear, sheâd forgotten her name nowâMissâMiss Bishop?âno, not Miss Bishop. Oh dear, how difficult it was.

Her mind went back to Mr. Rafiel and toâno, it wasnât Johnson, it had been Jackson, Arthur Jackson.

âOh, dear,â said Miss Marple again, âI always get all the names wrong. And of course, it was Miss Knight I was thinking of. Not Miss Bishop. Why do I think of her as Miss Bishop?â The answer came to her. Chess, of course. A chess piece. A knight. A bishop.

âI shall be calling her Miss Castle next time I think of her, I suppose, or Miss Rook. Though, really, sheâs not the sort of person who would ever rook anybody. No, indeed. And now what was the name of that nice secretary that Mr. Rafiel had. Oh yes, Esther Walters. That was right. I wonder what has happened to Esther Walters? Sheâd inherited money? She would probably inherit money now.â

Mr. Rafiel, she remembered, had told her something about that, or she hadâoh, dear, what a muddle things were when you tried to remember with any kind of exactitude. Esther Walters. It had hit her badly, that business in the Caribbean, but she would have got over it. Sheâd been a widow, hadnât she? Miss Marple hoped that Esther Walters had married again, some nice, kindly, reliable man. It seemed faintly unlikely. Esther Walters, she thought, had had rather a genius for liking the wrong kind of men to marry.

Miss Marple went back to thinking about Mr. Rafiel. No flowers, it had said. Not that she herself would have dreamed of sending flowers to Mr. Rafiel. He could buy up all the nurseries in England if heâd wanted to. And anyway, they hadnât been on those terms. They hadnât beenâfriends, or on terms of affection. They had beenâwhat was the word she wanted?âallies. Yes, they had been allies for a very short time. A very exciting time. And he had been an ally worth having. She had known so. Sheâd known it as she had gone running through a dark, tropical night in the Caribbean and had come to him. Yes, she remembered, sheâd been wearing that pink woolâwhat used they to call them when she was young?âa fascinator. That nice pink wool kind of shawl-scarf that sheâd put round her head, and he had looked at her and laughed, and later when she had saidâshe smiled at the remembranceâone word she had used and he had laughed, but he hadnât laughed in the end. No, heâd done what she asked him and thereforeââAh!â Miss Marple sighed, it had been, she had to admit it, all very exciting. And sheâd never told her nephew or dear Joan about it because, after all, it was what theyâd told her not to do, wasnât it? Miss Marple nodded her head. Then she murmured softly,

âPoor Mr. Rafiel, I hope he didnâtâsuffer.â

Probably not. Probably heâd been kept by expensive doctors under sedatives, easing the end. He had suffered a great deal in those weeks in the Caribbean. Heâd nearly always been in pain. A brave man.

A brave man. She was sorry he was dead because she thought that though heâd been elderly and an invalid and ill, the world had lost something through his going. She had no idea what he could have been like in business. Ruthless, she thought, and rude and overmastering and aggressive. A great attacker. Butâbut a good friend, she thought. And somewhere in him a deep kind of kindness that he was very careful never to show on the surface. A man she admired and respected. Well, she was sorry he was gone and she hoped he hadnât minded too much and that his passing had been easy. And now he would be cremated no doubt and put in some large, handsome marble vault. She didnât even know if heâd been married. He had never mentioned a wife, never mentioned children. A lonely man? Or had his life been so full that he hadnât needed to feel lonely? She wondered.

She sat there quite a long time that afternoon, wondering about Mr. Rafiel. She had never expected to see him again after she had returned to England and she never had seen him again. Yet in some queer way she could at any moment have felt she was in touch with him. If he had approached her or had suggested that they meet again, feeling perhaps a bond because of a life that had been saved between them, or of some other bond. A bondâ

âSurely,â said Miss Marple, aghast at an idea that had come into her mind, âthere canât be a bond of ruthlessness between us?â Was she, Jane Marpleâcould she ever beâruthless? âDâyou know,â said Miss Marple to herself, âitâs extraordinary, I never thought about it before. I believe, you know, I could be ruthlessâ¦.â

The door opened and a dark, curly head was popped in. It was Cherry, the welcome successor to Miss BishopâMiss Knight.

âDid you say something?â said Cherry.

âI was speaking to myself,â said Miss Marple, âI just wondered if I could ever be ruthless.â

âWhat, you?â said Cherry. âNever! Youâre kindness itself.â

âAll the same,â said Miss Marple, âI believe I could be ruthless if there was due cause.â

âWhat would you call due cause?â

âIn the cause of justice,â said Miss Marple.

âYou did have it in for little Gary Hopkins I must say,â said Cherry. âWhen you caught him torturing his cat that day. Never knew you had it in you to go for anyone like that! Scared him stiff, you did. Heâs never forgotten it.â

âI hope he hasnât tortured anymore cats.â

âWell, heâs made sure you werenât about if he did,â said Cherry. âIn fact Iâm not at all sure as there isnât other boys as got scared. Seeing you with your wool and the pretty things you knits and all thatâanyone would think you were gentle as a lamb. But thereâs times I could say youâd behave like a lion if you was goaded into it.â

Miss Marple looked a little doubtful. She could not quite see herself in the rÃ´le in which Cherry was now casting her. Had she everâshe paused on the reflection, recalling various momentsâthere had been intense irritation with Miss BishopâKnight. (Really, she must not forget names in this way.) But her irritation had shown itself in more or less ironical remarks. Lions, presumably, did not use irony. There was nothing ironical about a lion. It sprang. It roared. It used its claws, presumably it took large bites at its prey.

âReally,â said Miss Marple, âI donât think I have ever behaved quite like that.â

Walking slowly along her garden that evening with the usual feelings of vexation rising in her, Miss Marple considered the point again. Possibly the sight of a plant of snapdragons recalled it to her mind. Really, she had told old George again and again that she only wanted sulphur-coloured antirrhinums, not that rather ugly purple shade that gardeners always seemed so fond of. âSulphur yellow,â said Miss Marple aloud.

Someone the other side of the railing that abutted on the lane past her house turned her head and spoke.

âI beg your pardon? You said something?â

âI was talking to myself, Iâm afraid,â said Miss Marple, turning to look over the railing.

This was someone she did not know, and she knew most people in St. Mary Mead. Knew them by sight even if not personally. It was a thickset woman in a shabby but tough tweed skirt, and wearing good country shoes. She wore an emerald pullover and a knitted woollen scarf.

âIâm afraid one does at my age,â added Miss Marple.

âNice garden youâve got here,â said the other woman.

âNot particularly nice now,â said Miss Marple. âWhen I could attend to it myselfââ

âOh I know. I understand just what you feel. I suppose youâve got one of thoseâI have a lot of names for them, mostly very rudeâelderly chaps who say they know all about gardening. Sometimes they do, sometimes they donât know a thing about it. They come and have a lot of cups of tea and do a little very mild weeding. Theyâre quite nice, some of them, but all the same it does make oneâs temper rise.â She added, âIâm quite a keen gardener myself.â

âDo you live here?â asked Miss Marple, with some interest.

âWell, Iâm boarding with a Mrs. Hastings. I think Iâve heard her speak of you. Youâre Miss Marple, arenât you?â

âOh yes.â

âIâve come as a sort of companion-gardener. My name is Bartlett, by the way. Miss Bartlett. Thereâs not really much to do there,â said Miss Bartlett. âShe goes in for annuals and all that. Nothing you can really get your teeth into.â She opened her mouth and showed her teeth when making this remark. âOf course I do a few odd jobs as well. Shopping, you know, and things like that. Anyway, if you want any time put in here, I could put in an hour or two for you. Iâd say I might be better than any chap youâve got now.â

âThat would be easy,â said Miss Marple. âI like flowers best. Donât care so much for vegetables.â

âI do vegetables for Mrs. Hastings. Dull but necessary. Well, Iâll be getting along.â Her eyes swept over Miss Marple from head to foot, as though memorizing her, then she nodded cheerfully and tramped off.

Mrs. Hastings? Miss Marple couldnât remember the name of any Mrs. Hastings. Certainly Mrs. Hastings was not an old friend. She had certainly never been a gardening chum. Ah, of course, it was probably those newly built houses at the end of Gibraltar Road. Several families had moved in in the last year. Miss Marple sighed, looked again with annoyance at the antirrhinums, saw several weeds which she yearned to root up, one or two exuberant suckers she would like to attack with her secateurs, and finally, sighing, and manfully resisting temptation, she made a detour round by the lane and returned to her house. Her mind recurred again to Mr. Rafiel. They had been, he and sheâwhat was the title of that book they used to quote so much when she was young? Ships that pass in the night. Rather apt it was really, when she came to think of it. Ships that pass in the night â¦ It was in the night that she had gone to him to askâno, to demandâhelp. To insist, to say no time must be lost. And he had agreed, and put things in train at once! Perhaps she had been rather lionlike on that occasion? No. No, that was quite wrong. It had not been anger she had felt. It had been insistence on something that was absolutely imperative to be put in hand at once. And heâd understood.

Poor Mr. Rafiel. The ship that had passed in the night had been an interesting ship. Once you got used to his being rude, he might have been quite an agreeable man? No! She shook her head. Mr. Rafiel could never have been an agreeable man. Well, she must put Mr. Rafiel out of her head.

Ships that pass in the night, and speak each other in passing;

Only a signal shown and a distant voice in the darkness.

She would probably never think of him again. She would look out perhaps to see if there was an obituary of him in The Times. But she did not think it was very likely. He was not a very well known character, she thought. Not famous. He had just been very rich. Of course, many people did have obituaries in the paper just because they were very rich; but she thought that Mr. Rafielâs richness would possibly not have been of that kind. He had not been prominent in any great industry, he had not been a great financial genius, or a noteworthy banker. He had just all his life made enormous amounts of moneyâ¦.

Two

CODE WORD NEMESIS

I

It was about a week or so after Mr. Rafielâs death that Miss Marple picked up a letter from her breakfast tray, and looked at it for a moment before opening it. The other two letters that had come by this morningâs post were bills, or just possibly receipts for bills. In either case they were not of any particular interest. This letter might be.

A London postmark, typewritten address, a long, good quality envelope. Miss Marple slit it neatly with the paper knife she always kept handy on her tray. It was headed, Messrs. Broadribb and Schuster, Solicitors and Notaries Public, with an address in Bloomsbury. It asked her, in suitable courteous and legal phraseology, to call upon them one day in the following week, at their office, to discuss a proposition that might be to her advantage. Thursday, the 24th was suggested. If that date was not convenient, perhaps she would let them know what date she would be likely to be in London in the near future. They added that they were the solicitors to the late Mr. Rafiel, with whom they understood she had been acquainted.

Miss Marple frowned in some slight puzzlement. She got up rather more slowly than usual, thinking about the letter she had received. She was escorted downstairs by Cherry, who was meticulous in hanging about in the hall so as to make sure that Miss Marple did not come to grief walking by herself down the staircase, which was of the old-fashioned kind which turned a sharp corner in the middle of its run.

âYou take very good care of me, Cherry,â said Miss Marple.

âGot to,â said Cherry, in her usual idiom. âGood people are scarce.â

âWell, thank you for the compliment,â said Miss Marple, arriving safely with her last foot on the ground floor.

âNothing the matter, is there?â asked Cherry. âYou look a bit rattled like, if you know what I mean.â

âNo, nothingâs the matter,â said Miss Marple. âI had rather an unusual letter from a firm of solicitors.â

âNobody is suing you for anything, are they?â said Cherry, who was inclined to regard solicitorsâ letters as invariably associated with disaster of some kind.

âOh no, I donât think so,â said Miss Marple. âNothing of that kind. They just asked me to call upon them next week in London.â

âPerhaps youâve been left a fortune,â said Cherry, hopefully.

âThat, I think, is very unlikely,â said Miss Marple.

âWell, you never know,â said Cherry.

Settling herself in her chair, and taking her knitting out of its embroidered knitting bag, Miss Marple considered the possibility of Mr. Rafiel having left her a fortune. It seemed even more unlikely than when Cherry had suggested it. Mr. Rafiel, she thought, was not that kind of a man.

It was not possible for her to go on the date suggested. She was attending a meeting of the Womenâs Institute to discuss the raising of a sum for building a small additional couple of rooms. But she wrote, naming a day in the following week. In due course her letter was answered and the appointment definitely confirmed. She wondered what Messrs. Broadribb and Schuster were like. The letter had been signed by J. R. Broadribb who was, apparently, the senior partner. It was possible, Miss Marple thought, that Mr. Rafiel might have left her some small memoir or souvenir in his will. Perhaps some book on rare flowers that had been in his library and which he thought would please an old lady who was keen on gardening. Or perhaps a cameo brooch which had belonged to some great-aunt of his. She amused herself by these fancies. They were only fancies, she thought, because in either case it would merely be a case of the Executorsâif these lawyers were the Executorsâforwarding her by post any such object. They would not have wanted an interview.

âOh well,â said Miss Marple, âI shall know next Tuesday.â

II

âWonder what sheâll be like,â said Mr. Broadribb to Mr. Schuster, glancing at the clock as he did so.

âSheâs due in a quarter of an hour,â said Mr. Schuster. âWonder if sheâll be punctual?â

âOh, I should think so. Sheâs elderly, I gather, and much more punctilious than the young scatterbrains of today.â

âFat or thin, I wonder?â said Mr. Schuster.

Mr. Broadribb shook his head.

âDidnât Rafiel ever describe her to you?â asked Mr. Schuster.

âHe was extraordinarily cagey in everything he said about her.â

âThe whole thing seems very odd to me,â said Mr. Schuster. âIf we only knew a bit more about what it all meantâ¦.â

âIt might be,â said Mr. Broadribb thoughtfully, âsomething to do with Michael.â

âWhat? After all these years? Couldnât be. What put that into your head? Did he mentionââ

âNo, he didnât mention anything. Gave me no clue at all as to what was in his mind. Just gave me instructions.â

âThink he was getting a bit eccentric and all that towards the end?â

âNot in the least. Mentally he was a brilliant as ever. His physical ill health never affected his brain, anyway. In the last two months of his life he made an extra two hundred thousand pounds. Just like that.â

âHe had a flair,â said Mr. Schuster with due reverence. âCertainly, he always had a flair.â

âA great financial brain,â said Mr. Broadribb, also in a tone of reverence suitable to the sentiment. âNot many like him, moreâs the pity.â

A buzzer went on the table. Mr. Schuster picked up the receiver. A female voice said,

âMiss Jane Marple is here to see Mr. Broadribb by appointment.â

Mr. Schuster looked at his partner, raising an eyebrow for an affirmative or a negative. Mr. Broadribb nodded.

âShow her up,â said Mr. Schuster. And he added, âNow weâll see.â

Miss Marple entered a room where a middle-aged gentleman with a thin, spare body and a long rather melancholy face rose to greet her. This apparently was Mr. Broadribb, whose appearance somewhat contradicted his name. With him was a rather younger middle-aged gentleman of definitely more ample proportions. He had black hair, small keen eyes and a tendency to a double chin.

âMy partner, Mr. Schuster,â Mr. Broadribb presented.

âI hope you didnât feel the stairs too much,â said Mr. Schuster. âSeventy if she is a dayânearer eighty perhaps,â he was thinking in his own mind.

âI always get a little breathless going upstairs.â

âAn old-fashioned building this,â said Mr. Broadribb apologetically. âNo lift. Ah well, we are a very long established firm and we donât go in for as many of the modern gadgets as perhaps our clients expect of us.â

âThis room has very pleasant proportions,â said Miss Marple, politely.

She accepted the chair that Mr. Broadribb drew forward for her. Mr. Schuster, in an unobtrusive sort of way, left the room.

âI hope that chair is comfortable,â said Mr. Broadribb. âIâll pull that curtain slightly, shall I? You may feel the sun a little too much in your eyes.â

âThank you,â said Miss Marple, gratefully.

She sat there, upright as was her habit. She wore a light tweed suit, a string of pearls and a small velvet toque. To himself Mr. Broadribb was saying, âThe Provincial Lady. A good type. Fluffy old girl. May be scattyâmay not. Quite a shrewd eye. I wonder where Rafiel came across her. Somebodyâs aunt, perhaps, up from the country?â While these thoughts passed through his head, he was making the kind of introductory small talk relating to the weather, the unfortunate effects of late frosts early in the year and such other remarks as he considered suitable.

Miss Marple made the necessary responses and sat placidly awaiting the opening of preliminaries to the meeting.

âYou will be wondering what all this is about,â said Mr. Broadribb, shifting a few papers in front of him and giving her a suitable smile. âYouâve heard, no doubt, of Mr. Rafielâs death, or perhaps you saw it in the paper.â

âI saw it in the paper,â said Miss Marple.

âHe was, I understand, a friend of yours.â

âI met him first just over a year ago,â said Miss Marple. âIn the West Indies,â she added.

âAh. I remember. He went out there, I believe, for his health. It did him some good, perhaps, but he was already a very ill man, badly crippled, as you know.â

âYes,â said Miss Marple.

âYou knew him well?â

âNo,â said Miss Marple, âI would not say that. We were fellow visitors in a hotel. We had occasional conversations. I never saw him again after my return to England. I live very quietly in the country, you see, and I gather that he was completely absorbed in business.â

âHe continued transacting business right upâwell, I could almost say right up to the day of his death,â said Mr. Broadribb. âA very fine financial brain.â

âI am sure that was so,â said Miss Marple. âI realized quite soon that he was aâwell, a very remarkable character altogether.â

âI donât know if you have any ideaâwhether youâve been given any idea at some time by Mr. Rafielâas to what this proposition is that I have been instructed to put up to you?â

âI cannot imagine,â said Miss Marple, âwhat possible kind of proposition Mr. Rafiel might have wanted to put up to me. It seems most unlikely.â

âHe had a very high opinion of you.â

âThat is kind of him, but hardly justified,â said Miss Marple. âI am a very simple person.â

âAs you no doubt realize, he died a very rich man. The provisions of his Will are on the whole fairly simple. He had already made dispositions of his fortune some time before his death. Trusts and other beneficiary arrangements.â

âThat is, I believe, very usual procedure nowadays,â said Miss Marple, âthough I am not at all cognizant of financial matters myself.â

âThe purpose of this appointment,â said Mr. Broadribb, âis that I am instructed to tell you that a sum of money has been laid aside to become yours absolutely at the end of one year, but conditional on your accepting a certain proposition, with which I am to make you acquainted.â

He took from the table in front of him a long envelope. It was sealed. He passed it across the table to her.

âIt would be better, I think, that you should read for yourself of what this consists. There is no hurry. Take your time.â

Miss Marple took her time. She availed herself of a small paper knife which Mr. Broadribb handed to her, slit up the envelope, took out the enclosure, one sheet of typewriting, and read it. She folded it up again, then reread it and looked at Mr. Broadribb.

âThis is hardly very definite. Is there no more definite elucidation of any kind?â

âNot so far as I am concerned. I was to hand you this, and tell you the amount of the legacy. The sum in question is twenty thousand pounds free of legacy duty.â

Miss Marple sat looking at him. Surprise had rendered her speechless. Mr. Broadribb said no more for the moment. He was watching her closely. There was no doubt of her surprise. It was obviously the last thing Miss Marple had expected to hear. Mr. Broadribb wondered what her first words would be. She looked at him with the directness, the severity that one of his own aunts might have done. When she spoke it was almost accusingly.

âThat is a very large sum of money,â said Miss Marple.

âNot quite so large as it used to be,â said Mr. Broadribb (and just restrained himself from saying, âMere chicken feed nowadaysâ).

âI must admit,â said Miss Marple, âthat I am amazed. Frankly, quite amazed.â

She picked up the document and read it carefully through again.

âI gather you know the terms of this?â she said.

âYes. It was dictated to me personally by Mr. Rafiel.â

âDid he not give you any explanation of it?â

âNo, he did not.â

âYou suggested, I suppose, that it might be better if he did,â said Miss Marple. There was a slight acidity in her voice now.

Mr. Broadribb smiled faintly.

âYou are quite right. That is what I did. I said that you might find it difficult toâoh, to understand exactly what he was driving at.â

âVery remarkable,â said Miss Marple.

âThere is no need, of course,â said Mr. Broadribb, âfor you to give me an answer now.â

âNo,â said Miss Marple, âI should have to reflect upon this.â

âIt is, as you have pointed out, quite a substantial sum of money.â

âI am old,â said Miss Marple. âElderly, we say, but old is a better word. Definitely old. It is both possible and indeed probable that I might not live as long as a year to earn this money, in the rather doubtful case that I was able to earn it.â

âMoney is not to be despised at any age,â said Mr. Broadribb.

âI could benefit certain charities in which I have an interest,â said Miss Marple, âand there are always people. People whom one wishes one could do a little something for but oneâs own funds do not admit of it. And then I will not pretend that there are not pleasures and desiresâthings that one has not been able to indulge in or to affordâI think Mr. Rafiel knew quite well that to be able to do so, quite unexpectedly, would give an elderly person a great deal of pleasure.â

âYes, indeed,â said Mr. Broadribb. âA cruise abroad, perhaps? One of these excellent tours as arranged nowadays. Theatres, concertsâthe ability to replenish oneâs cellars.â

âMy tastes would be a little more moderate than that,â said Miss Marple. âPartridges,â she said thoughtfully, âit is very difficult to get partridges nowadays, and theyâre very expensive. I should enjoy a partridgeâa whole partridgeâto myself, very much. A box of marrons glacÃ©s is an expensive taste which I cannot often gratify. Possibly a visit to the opera. It means a car to take one to Covent Garden and back, and the expense of a night in a hotel. But I must not indulge in idle chat,â she said. âI will take this back with me and reflect upon it. Really, what on earth made Mr. Rafielâyou have no idea why he should have suggested this particular proposition, and why he should think that I could be of service to him in any way? He must have known that it was over a year, nearly two years since he had seen me and that I might have got much more feeble than I have, and much more unable to exercise such small talents as I might have. He was taking a risk. There are other people surely much better qualified to undertake an investigation of this nature?â

âFrankly, one would think so,â said Mr. Broadribb, âbut he selected you, Miss Marple. Forgive me if this is idle curiosity but have you hadâoh, how shall I put it?âany connection with crime or the investigation of crime?â

âStrictly speaking I should say no,â said Miss Marple. âNothing professional, that is to say. I have never been a probation officer or indeed sat as a magistrate on a Bench or been connected in any way with a detective agency. To explain to you, Mr. Broadribb, which I think it is only fair for me to do and which I think Mr. Rafiel ought to have done, to explain it in any way all I can say is that during our stay in the West Indies, we both, Mr. Rafiel and myself, had a certain connection with a crime that took place there. A rather unlikely and perplexing murder.â

âAnd you and Mr. Rafiel solved it?â

âI should not put it quite like that,â said Miss Marple. âMr. Rafiel, by the force of his personality, and I, by putting together one or two obvious indications that came to my notice, were successful in preventing a second murder just as it was about to take place. I could not have done it alone, I was physically far too feeble. Mr. Rafiel could not have done it alone, he was a cripple. We acted as allies, however.â

âJust one other question I should like to ask you, Miss Marple. Does the word âNemesisâ mean anything to you?â

âNemesis,â said Miss Marple. It was not a question. A very slow and unexpected smile dawned on her face. âYes,â she said, âit does mean something to me. It meant something to me and it meant something to Mr. Rafiel. I said it to him, and he was much amused by my describing myself by that name.â

Whatever Mr. Broadribb had expected it was not that. He looked at Miss Marple with something of the same astonished surprise that Mr. Rafiel had once felt in a bedroom by the Caribbean sea. A nice and quite intelligent old lady. But reallyâNemesis!

âYou feel the same, I am sure,â said Miss Marple.

She rose to her feet.

âIf you should find or receive any further instructions in this matter, you will perhaps let me know, Mr. Broadribb. It seems to me extraordinary that there should not be something of that kind. This leaves me entirely in the dark really as to what Mr. Rafiel is asking me to do or try to do.â

âYou are not acquainted with his family, his friends, hisââ

âNo. I told you. He was a fellow traveller in a foreign part of the world. We had a certain association as allies in a very mystifying matter. That is all.â As she was about to go to the door she turned suddenly and asked: âHe had a secretary, Mrs. Esther Walters. Would it be infringing etiquette if I asked if Mr. Rafiel left her fifty thousand pounds?â

âHis bequest will appear in the press,â said Mr. Broadribb. âI can answer your question in the affirmative. Mrs. Waltersâ name is now Mrs. Anderson, by the way. She has remarried.â

âI am glad to hear that. She was a widow with one daughter, and she was a very adequate secretary, it appears. She understood Mr. Rafiel very well. A nice woman. I am glad she has benefited.â

That evening, Miss Marple, sitting in her straightbacked chair, her feet stretched out to the fireplace where a small wood fire was burning owing to the sudden cold spell which, as is its habit, can always descend on England at any moment selected by itself, took once more from the long envelope the document delivered to her that morning. Still in a state of partial unbelief she read, murmuring the words here and there below her breath as though to impress them on her mind,

âTo Miss Jane Marple, resident in the village of St. Mary Mead.

This will be delivered to you after my death by the good offices of my solicitor, James Broadribb. He is the man I employ for dealing with such legal matters as fall in the field of my private affairs, not my business activities. He is a sound and trustworthy lawyer. Like the majority of the human race he is susceptible to the sin of curiosity. I have not satisfied his curiosity. In some respects this matter will remain between you and myself. Our code word, my dear lady, is Nemesis. I donât think you will have forgotten in what place and in what circumstances you first spoke that word to me. In the course of my business activities over what is now quite a long life, I have learnt one thing about a man whom I wish to employ. He has to have a flair. A flair for the particular job I want him to do. It is not knowledge, it is not experience. The only word that describes it is flair. A natural gift for doing a certain thing.

You, my dear, if I may call you that, have a natural flair for justice, and that has led to your having a natural flair for crime. I want you to investigate a certain crime. I have ordered a certain sum to be placed so that if you accept this request and as a result of your investigation this crime is properly elucidated, the money will become yours absolutely. I have set aside a year for you to engage on this mission. You are not young, but you are, if I may say so, tough. I think I can trust a reasonable fate to keep you alive for a year at least.

I think the work involved will not be distasteful to you. You have a natural genius, I should say, for investigation. The necessary funds for what I may describe as working capital for making this investigation will be remitted to you during that period, whenever necessary. I offer this to you as an alternative to what may be your life at present.

I envisage you sitting in a chair, a chair that is agreeable and comfortable for whatever kind or form of rheumatism from which you may suffer. All persons of your age, I consider, are likely to suffer from some form of rheumatism. If this ailment affects your knees or your back, it will not be easy for you to get about much and you will spend your time mainly in knitting. I see you, as I saw you once one night as I rose from sleep disturbed by your urgency, in a cloud of pink wool.

I envisage you knitting more jackets, head scarves and a good many other things of which I do not know the name. If you prefer to continue knitting, that is your decision. If you prefer to serve the cause of justice, I hope that you may at least find it interesting.

Let justice roll down like waters.

And righteousness like an everlasting stream.

Amos.â

Three

MISS MARPLE TAKES ACTION

I

Miss Marple read this letter three timesâthen she laid it aside and sat frowning slightly while she considered the letter and its implications.

The first thought that came to her was that she was left with a surprising lack of definite information. Would there be any further information coming to her from Mr. Broadribb? Almost certainly she felt that there would be no such thing. That would not have fitted in with Mr. Rafielâs plan. Yet how on earth could Mr. Rafiel expect her to do anything, to take any course of action in a matter about which she knew nothing? It was intriguing. After a few minutes more for consideration, she decided that Mr. Rafiel had meant it to be intriguing. Her thoughts went back to him, for the brief time that she had known him. His disability, his bad temper, his flashes of brilliance, of occasional humour. Heâd enjoy, she thought, teasing people. He had been enjoying, she felt, and this letter made it almost certain, baffling the natural curiosity of Mr. Broadribb.

There was nothing in the letter he had written her to give her the slightest clue as to what this business was all about. It was no help to her whatsoever. Mr. Rafiel, she thought, had very definitely not meant it to be of any help. He had hadâhow could she put it?âother ideas. All the same, she could not start out into the blue knowing nothing. This could almost be described as a crossword puzzle with no clues given. There would have to be clues. She would have to know what she was wanted to do, where she was wanted to go, whether she was to solve some problem sitting in her armchair and laying aside her knitting needles in order to concentrate better. Or did Mr. Rafiel intend her to take a plane or a boat to the West Indies or to South America or to some other specially directed spot? She would either have to find out for herself what it was she was meant to do, or else she would have to receive definite instructions. He might think she had sufficient ingenuity to guess at things, to ask questions, to find out that way? No, she couldnât quite believe that.

âIf he does think that,â said Miss Marple aloud, âheâs gaga. I mean, he was gaga before he died.â

But she didnât think Mr. Rafiel would have been gaga.

âI shall receive instructions,â said Miss Marple. âBut what instructions and when?â

It was only then that it occurred to her suddenly that without noticing it she had definitely accepted the mandate. She spoke aloud again, addressing the atmosphere.

âI believe in eternal life,â said Miss Marple. âI donât know exactly where you are, Mr. Rafiel, but I have no doubt that you are somewhereâI will do my best to fulfil your wishes.â

II

It was three days later when Miss Marple wrote to Mr. Broadribb. It was a very short letter, keeping strictly to the point.

âDear Mr. Broadribb,

I have considered the suggestion you made to me and I am letting you know that I have decided to accept the proposal made to me by the late Mr. Rafiel. I shall do my best to comply with his wishes, though I am not at all assured of success. Indeed, I hardly see how it is possible for me to be successful. I have been given no direct instructions in his letter and have not beenâI think the term is briefedâin any way. If you have any further communication you are holding for me which sets out definite instructions, I should be glad if you will send it to me, but I imagine that as you have not done so, that is not the case.

I presume that Mr. Rafiel was of sound mind and disposition when he died? I think I am justified in asking if there has been recently in his life any criminal affair in which he might possibly have been interested, either in the course of his business or in his personal relations. Has he ever expressed to you any anger or dissatisfaction with some notable miscarriage of justice about which he felt strongly? If so, I think I should be justified in asking you to let me know about it. Has any relation or connection of his suffered some hardship, lately been the victim of some unjust dealing, or what might be considered as such?

I am sure you will understand my reasons for asking these things. Indeed, Mr. Rafiel himself may have expected me to do so.â

III

Mr. Broadribb showed this to Mr. Schuster, who leaned back in his chair and whistled.

âSheâs going to take it on, is she? Sporting old bean,â he said. Then he added, âI suppose she knows something of what itâs all about, does she?â

âApparently not,â said Mr. Broadribb.

âI wish we did,â said Mr. Schuster. âHe was an odd cuss.â

âA difficult man,â said Mr. Broadribb.

âI havenât got the least idea,â said Mr. Schuster, âhave you?â

âNo, I havenât,â said Mr. Broadribb. He added, âHe didnât want me to have, I suppose.â

âWell, heâs made things a lot more difficult by doing that. I donât see the least chance that some old pussy from the country can interpret a dead manâs brain and know what fantasy was plaguing him. You donât think he was leading her up the garden path? Having her on? Sort of joke, you know. Perhaps he thinks that she thinks sheâs the catâs whiskers at solving village problems, but heâs going to teach her a sharp lessonââ

âNo,â said Mr. Broadribb, âI donât quite think that. Rafiel wasnât that type of man.â

âHe was a mischievous devil sometimes,â said Mr. Schuster.

âYes, but notâI think he was serious over this. Something was worrying him. In fact Iâm quite sure something was worrying him.â

âAnd he didnât tell you what it was or give you the least idea?â

âNo, he didnât.â

âThen how the devil can he expectââ Schuster broke off.

âHe canât really have expected anything to come of this,â said Mr. Broadribb. âI mean, how is she going to set about it?â

âA practical joke, if you ask me.â

âTwenty thousand pounds is a lot of money.â

âYes, but if he knows she canât do it?â

âNo,â said Mr. Broadribb. âHe wouldnât have been as unsporting as all that. He must think sheâs got a chance of doing or finding out whatever it is.â

âAnd what do we do?â

âWait,â said Mr. Broadribb. âWait and see what happens next. After all, there has to be some development.â

âGot some sealed orders somewhere, have you?â

âMy dear Schuster,â said Mr. Broadribb, âMr. Rafiel had implicit trust in my discretion and in my ethical conduct as a lawyer. Those sealed instructions are to be opened only under certain circumstances, none of which has yet arisen.â

âAnd never will,â said Mr. Schuster.

That ended the subject.

IV

Mr. Broadribb and Mr. Schuster were lucky in so much as they had a full professional life to lead. Miss Marple was not so fortunate. She knitted and she reflected and she also went out for walks, occasionally remonstrated with by Cherry for so doing.

âYou know what the doctor said. You werenât to take too much exercise.â

âI walk very slowly,â said Miss Marple, âand I am not doing anything. Digging, I mean, or weeding. I justâwell, I just put one foot in front of the other and wonder about things.â

âWhat things?â asked Cherry, with some interest.

âI wish I knew,â said Miss Marple, and asked Cherry to bring her an extra scarf as there was a chilly wind.

âWhatâs fidgeting her, thatâs what I would like to know,â said Cherry to her husband as she set before him a Chinese plate of rice and a concoction of kidneys. âChinese dinner,â she said.

Her husband nodded approval

âYou get a better cook every day,â he said.

âIâm worried about her,â said Cherry. âIâm worried because sheâs worried a bit. She had a letter and it stirred her all up.â

âWhat she needs is to sit quiet,â said Cherryâs husband. âSit quiet, take it easy, get herself new books from the library, get a friend or two to come and see her.â

âSheâs thinking out something,â said Cherry. âSort of plan. Thinking out how to tackle something, thatâs how I look at it.â

She broke off the conversation at this stage and took in the coffee tray and put it down by Miss Marpleâs side.

âDo you know a woman who lives in a new house somewhere here, sheâs called Mrs. Hastings?â asked Miss Marple. âAnd someone called Miss Bartlett, I think it is, who lives with herââ

âWhatâdo you mean the house thatâs been all done up and repainted at the end of the village? The people there havenât been there very long. I donât know what their names are. Why do you want to know? Theyâre not very interesting. At least I shouldnât say they were.â

âAre they related?â asked Miss Marple.

âNo. Just friends, I think.â

âI wonder whyââ said Miss Marple, and broke off.

âYou wondered why what?â

âNothing,â said Miss Marple. âClear my little hand desk, will you, and give me my pen and the notepaper. Iâm going to write a letter.â

âWho to?â said Cherry, with the natural curiosity of her kind.

âTo a clergymanâs sister,â said Miss Marple. âHis name is Canon Prescott.â

âThatâs the one you met abroad, in the West Indies, isnât it? You showed me his photo in your album.â

âYes.â

âNot feeling bad, are you? Wanting to write to a clergyman and all that?â

âIâm feeling extremely well,â said Miss Marple, âand I am anxious to get busy on something. Itâs just possible Miss Prescott might help.â

âDear Miss Prescott,â wrote Miss Marple, âI hope you have not forgotten me. I met you and your brother in the West Indies, if you remember, at St. HonorÃ©. I hope the dear Canon is well and did not suffer much with his asthma in the cold weather last winter.

I am writing to ask you if you can possibly let me have the address of Mrs. WaltersâEsther Waltersâwhom you may remember from the Caribbean days. She was a secretary to Mr. Rafiel. She did give me her address at the time, but unfortunately I have mislaid it. I was anxious to write to her as I have some horticultural information which she asked me about but which I was not able to tell her at the time. I heard in a roundabout way the other day that she had married again, but I donât think my informant was very certain of these facts. Perhaps you know more about her than I do.

I hope this is not troubling you too much. With kind regards to your brother and best wishes to yourself,

Yours sincerely,

Jane Marple.â

Miss Marple felt better when she had despatched this missive.

âAt least,â she said, âIâve started doing something. Not that I hope much from this, but still it might help.â

Miss Prescott answered the letter almost by return of post. She was a most efficient woman. She wrote a pleasant letter and enclosed the address in question.

âI have not heard anything directly about Esther Walters,â she said, âbut like you I heard from a friend that they had seen a notice of her remarriage. Her name now is, I believe, Mrs. Alderson or Anderson. Her address is Winslow Lodge, near Alton, Hants. My brother sends his best wishes to you. It is sad that we live so far apart. We in the north of England and you south of London. I hope that we may meet on some occasion in the future.

Yours sincerely,

Joan Prescott.â

âWinslow Lodge, Alton,â said Miss Marple, writing it down.

âNot so far away from here, really. No. Not so far away. I couldâI donât know what would be the best methodâpossibly one of Inchâs taxis. Slightly extravagant, but if anything results from it, it could be charged as expenses quite legitimately. Now do I write to her beforehand or do I leave it to chance? I think it would be better really, to leave it to chance. Poor Esther. She could hardly remember me with any affection or kindliness.â

Miss Marple lost herself in a train of thought that arose from her thoughts. It was quite possible that her actions in the Caribbean had saved Esther Walters from being murdered in the not far distant future. At any rate, that was Miss Marpleâs belief, but probably Esther Walters had not believed any such thing. âA nice woman,â said Miss Marple, uttering the words in a soft tone aloud, âa very nice woman. The kind that would so easily marry a bad lot. In fact, the sort of woman that would marry a murderer if she were ever given half a chance. I still consider,â continued Miss Marple thoughtfully, sinking her voice still lower, âthat I probably saved her life. In fact, I am almost sure of it, but I donât think she would agree with that point of view. She probably dislikes me very much. Which makes it more difficult to use her as a source of information. Still, one can but try. Itâs better than sitting here, waiting, waiting, waiting.â

Was Mr. Rafiel perhaps making fun of her when he had written that letter? He was not always a particularly kindly manâhe could be very careless of peopleâs feelings.

âAnyway,â said Miss Marple, glancing at the clock and deciding that she would have an early night in bed, âwhen one thinks of things just before going to sleep, quite often ideas come. It may work out that way.â

V

âSleep well?â asked Cherry, as she put down an early morning tea tray on the table at Miss Marpleâs elbow.

âI had a curious dream,â said Miss Marple.

âNightmare?â

âNo, no, nothing of that kind. I was talking to someone, not anyone I knew very well. Just talking. Then when I looked, I saw it wasnât that person at all I was talking to. It was somebody else. Very odd.â

âBit of a mix up,â said Cherry, helpfully.

âIt just reminded me of something,â said Miss Marple, âor rather of someone I once knew. Order Inch for me, will you? To come here about half past eleven.â

Inch was part of Miss Marpleâs past. Originally the proprietor of a cab, Mr. Inch had died, been succeeded by his son âYoung Inch,â then aged forty-four, who had turned the family business into a garage and acquired two aged cars. On his decease the garage acquired a new owner. There had been since then Pipâs Cars, Jamesâs Taxis and Arthurâs Car Hireâold inhabitants still spoke of Inch.

âNot going to London, are you?â

âNo, Iâm not going to London. I shall have lunch perhaps in Haslemere.â

âNow what are you up to now?â said Cherry, looking at her suspiciously.

âEndeavouring to meet someone by accident and make it seem purely natural,â said Miss Marple. âNot really very easy, but I hope that I can manage it.â

At half past eleven the taxi waited. Miss Marple instructed Cherry.

âRing up this number, will you, Cherry? Ask if Mrs. Anderson is at home. If Mrs. Anderson answers or if she is going to come to the telephone, say a Mr. Broadribb wants to speak to her. You,â said Miss Marple, âare Mr. Broadribbâs secretary. If sheâs out, find out what time she will be in.â

âAnd if she is in and I get her?â

âAsk what day she could arrange to meet Mr. Broadribb at his office in London next week. When she tells you, make a note of it and ring off.â

âThe things you think of! Why all this? Why do you want me to do it?â

âMemory is a curious thing,â said Miss Marple. âSometimes one remembers a voice even if one hasnât heard it for over a year.â

âWell, Mrs. Whatâs-a-name wonât have heard mine at any time, will she?â

âNo,â said Miss Marple. âThat is why you are making the call.â

Cherry fulfilled her instruction. Mrs. Anderson was out shopping, she learned, but would be in for lunch and all the afternoon.

âWell, that makes things easier,â said Miss Marple. âIs Inch here? Ah yes. Good morning, Edward,â she said, to the present driver of Arthurâs taxis whose actual name was George. âNow this is where I want you to go. It ought not to take, I think, more than an hour and a half.â

The expedition set off.

Four

ESTHER WALTERS

Esther Anderson came out of the Supermarket and went towards where she had parked her car. Parking grew more difficult every day, she thought. She collided with somebody, an elderly woman limping a little who was walking towards her. She apologized, and the other woman made an exclamation.

âWhy, indeed, itâsâsurelyâitâs Mrs. Walters, isnât it? Esther Walters? You donât remember me, I expect. Jane Marple. We met in the hotel in St. HonorÃ©, ohâquite a long time ago. A year and a half.â

âMiss Marple? So it is, of course. Fancy seeing you!â

âHow very nice to see you. I am lunching with some friends near here but I have to pass back through Alton later. Will you be at home this afternoon? I should so like to have a nice chat with you. Itâs so nice to see an old friend.â

âYes, of course. Anytime after 3 oâclock.â

The arrangement was ratified.

âOld Jane Marple,â said Esther Anderson, smiling to herself. âFancy her turning up. I thought sheâd died a long time ago.â

Miss Marple rang the bell of Winslow Lodge at 3:30 precisely. Esther opened the door to her and brought her in.

Miss Marple sat down in the chair indicated to her, fluttering a little in the restless manner that she adopted when slightly flustered. Or at any rate, when she was seeming to be slightly flustered. In this case it was misleading, since things had happened exactly as she had hoped they would happen.

âItâs so nice to see you,â she said to Esther. âSo very nice to see you again. You know, I do think things are so very odd in this world. You hope youâll meet people again and youâre quite sure you will. And then time passes and suddenly itâs all such a surprise.â

âAnd then,â said Esther, âone says itâs a small world, doesnât one?â

âYes, indeed, and I think there is something in that. I mean it does seem a very large world and the West Indies are such a very long way away from England. Well, I mean, of course I might have met you anywhere. In London or at Harrods. On a railway station or in a bus. There are so many possibilities.â

âYes, there are a lot of possibilities,â said Esther. âI certainly shouldnât have expected to meet you just here because this isnât really quite your part of the world, is it?â

âNo. No, it isnât. Not that youâre really so very far from St. Mary Mead where I live. Actually, I think itâs only about twenty-five miles. But twenty-five miles in the country, when one hasnât got a carâand of course I couldnât afford a car, and anyway, I mean, I canât drive a carâso it wouldnât be much to the point, so one really only does see oneâs neighbours on the bus route, or else go by a taxi from the village.â

âYouâre looking wonderfully well,â said Esther.

âI was just going to say you were looking wonderfully well, my dear. I had no idea you lived in this part of the world.â

âI have only done so for a short time. Since my marriage, actually.â

âOh, I didnât know. How interesting. I suppose I must have missed it. I always do look down the marriages.â

âIâve been married four or five months,â said Esther. âMy name is Anderson now.â

âMrs. Anderson,â said Miss Marple. âYes. I must try and remember that. And your husband?â

It would be unnatural, she thought, if she did not ask about the husband. Old maids were notoriously inquisitive.

âHe is an engineer,â said Esther. âHe runs the Time and Motion Branch. He is,â she hesitatedââa little younger than I am.â

âMuch better,â said Miss Marple immediately. âOh, much better, my dear. In these days men age so much quicker than women. I know it used not to be said so, but actually itâs true. I mean, they get more things the matter with them. I think, perhaps, they worry and work too much. And then they get high blood pressure or low blood pressure or sometimes a little heart trouble. Theyâre rather prone to gastric ulcers, too. I donât think we worry so much, you know. I think weâre a tougher sex.â

âPerhaps we are,â said Esther.

She smiled now at Miss Marple, and Miss Marple felt reassured. The last time she had seen Esther, Esther had looked as though she hated her and probably she had hated her at that moment. But now, well now, perhaps, she might even feel slightly grateful. She might have realized that she, herself, might even have been under a stone slab in a respectable churchyard, instead of living a presumably happy life with Mr. Anderson.

âYou look very well,â she said, âand very gay.â

âSo do you, Miss Marple.â

âWell, of course, I am rather older now. And one has so many ailments. I mean, not desperate ones, nothing of that kind, but I mean one has always some kind of rheumatism or some kind of ache and pain somewhere. Oneâs feet are not what one would like feet to be. And thereâs usually oneâs back or a shoulder or painful hands. Oh, dear, one shouldnât talk about these things. What a very nice house you have.â

âYes, we havenât been in it very long. We moved in about four months ago.â

Miss Marple looked round. She had rather thought that that was the case. She thought, too, that when they had moved in they had moved in on quite a handsome scale. The furniture was expensive, it was comfortable, comfortable and just this side of luxury. Good curtains, good covers, no particular artistic taste displayed, but then she would not have expected that. She thought she knew the reason for this appearance of prosperity. She thought it had come about on the strength of the late Mr. Rafielâs handsome legacy to Esther. She was glad to think that Mr. Rafiel had not changed his mind.

âI expect you saw the notice of Mr. Rafielâs death,â said Esther, speaking almost as if she knew what was in Miss Marpleâs mind.

âYes. Yes, indeed I did. It was about a month ago now, wasnât it? I was so sorry. Very distressed really, although, well, I suppose one knewâhe almost admitted it himself, didnât he? He hinted several times that it wouldnât be very long. I think he was quite a brave man about it all, donât you?â

âYes, he was a very brave man, and a very kind one really,â said Esther. âHe told me, you know, when I first worked for him, that he was going to give me a very good salary but that I would have to save out of it because I neednât expect to have anything more from him. Well, I certainly didnât expect to have anything more from him. He was very much a man of his word, wasnât he? But apparently he changed his mind.â

âYes,â said Miss Marple. âYes. I am very glad of that. I thought perhapsânot that he, of course, said anythingâbut I wondered.â

âHe left me a very big legacy,â said Esther. âA surprisingly large sum of money. It came as a very great surprise. I could hardly believe it at first.â

âI think he wanted it to be a surprise to you. I think he was perhaps that kind of man,â said Miss Marple. She added: âDid he leave anything toâoh, what was his name?âthe man attendant, the nurse-attendant?â

âOh, you mean Jackson? No, he didnât leave anything to Jackson, but I believe he made him some handsome presents in the last year.â

âHave you ever seen anything more of Jackson?â

âNo. No, I donât think Iâve met him once since the time out in the islands. He didnât stay with Mr. Rafiel after they got back to England. I think he went to Lord somebody who lives in Jersey or Guernsey.â

âI would like to have seen Mr. Rafiel again,â said Miss Marple. âIt seems odd after weâd all been mixed up so. He and you and I and some others. And then, later, when Iâd come home, when six months had passedâit occurred to me one day how closely associated we had been in our time of stress, and yet how little I really knew about Mr. Rafiel. I was thinking it only the other day, after Iâd seen the notice of his death. I wished I could know a little more. Where he was born, you know, and his parents. What they were like. Whether he had any children, or nephews or cousins or any family. I would so like to know.â

Esther Anderson smiled slightly. She looked at Miss Marple and her expression seemed to say âYes, Iâm sure you always want to know everything of that kind about everyone you meet.â But she merely said:

âNo, there was really only one thing that everyone did know about him.â

âThat he was very rich,â said Miss Marple immediately. âThatâs what you mean, isnât it? When you know that someone is very rich, somehow, well, you donât ask anymore. I mean you donât ask to know anymore. You say âHe is very richâ or you say âHe is enormously rich,â and your voice just goes down a little because itâs so impressive, isnât it, when you meet someone who is immensely rich.â

Esther laughed slightly.

âHe wasnât married, was he?â asked Miss Marple. âHe never mentioned a wife.â

âHe lost his wife many years ago. Quite soon after they were married, I believe. I believe she was much younger than he wasâI think she died of cancer. Very sad.â

âHad he children?â

âOh yes, two daughters, and a son. One daughter is married and lives in America. The other daughter died young, I believe. I met the American one once. She wasnât at all like her father. Rather a quiet, depressed looking young woman.â She added, âMr. Rafiel never spoke about the son. I rather think that there had been trouble there. A scandal or something of that kind. I believe he died some years ago. Anywayâhis father never mentioned him.â

âOh dear. That was very sad.â

âI think it happened quite a long time ago. I believe he took off for somewhere or other abroad and never came backâdied out there, wherever it was.â

âWas Mr. Rafiel very upset about it?â

âOne wouldnât know with him,â said Esther. âHe was the kind of man who would always decide to cut his losses. If his son turned out to be unsatisfactory, a burden instead of a blessing, I think he would just shrug the whole thing off. Do what was necessary perhaps in the way of sending him money for support, but never thinking of him again.â

âOne wonders,â said Miss Marple. âHe never spoke of him or said anything?â

âIf you remember, he was a man who never said anything much about personal feelings or his own life.â

âNo. No, of course not. But I thought perhaps, you having beenâwell, his secretary for so many years, that he might have confided any troubles to you.â

âHe was not a man for confiding troubles,â said Esther. âIf he had any, which I rather doubt. He was wedded to his business, one might say. He was father to his business and his business was the only kind of son or daughter that he had that mattered, I think. He enjoyed it all, investment, making money. Business coupsââ

âCall no man happy until he is deadââ murmured Miss Marple, repeating the words in the manner of one pronouncing them as a kind of slogan, which indeed they appeared to be in these days, or so she would have said.

âSo there was nothing especially worrying him, was there, before his death?â

âNo. Why should you think so?â Esther sounded surprised.

âWell, I didnât actually think so,â said Miss Marple, âI just wondered because things do worry people more when they areâI wonât say getting oldâbecause he really wasnât old, but I mean things worry you more when you are laid up and canât do as much as you did and have to take things easy. Then worries just come into your mind and make themselves felt.â

âYes, I know what you mean,â said Esther. âBut I donât think Mr. Rafiel was like that. Anyway,â she added, âI ceased being his secretary some time ago. Two or three months after I met Edmund.â

âAh yes. Your husband. Mr. Rafiel must have been very upset at losing you.â

âOh I donât think so,â said Esther lightly. âHe was not one who would be upset over that sort of thing. Heâd immediately get another secretaryâwhich he did. And then if she didnât suit him heâd just get rid of her with a kindly golden handshake and get somebody else, till he found somebody who suited him. He was an intensely sensible man always.â

âYes. Yes, I can see that. Though he could lose his temper very easily.â

âOh, he enjoyed losing his temper,â said Esther. âIt made a bit of drama for him, I think.â

âDrama,â said Miss Marple thoughtfully. âDo you thinkâI have often wonderedâdo you think that Mr. Rafiel had any particular interest in criminology, the study of it, I mean? Heâwell, I donât knowâ¦.â

âYou mean because of what happened in the Caribbean?â Estherâs voice had gone suddenly hard.

Miss Marple felt doubtful of going on, and yet she must somehow or other try and get a little helpful knowledge.

âWell, no, not because of that, but afterwards, perhaps, he wondered about the psychology of these things. Or he got interested in the cases where justice had not been administered properly orâoh, wellâ¦.â

She sounded more scatty every minute.

âWhy should he take the least interest in anything of that kind? And donât letâs talk about that horrible business in St. HonorÃ©.â

âOh no, I think you are quite right. Iâm sure Iâm very sorry. I was just thinking of some of the things that Mr. Rafiel sometimes said. Queer turns of phrase, sometimes, and I just wondered if he had any theories, you know â¦ about the causes of crime?â

âHis interests were always entirely financial,â said Esther shortly. âA really clever swindle of a criminal kind might have interested him, nothing elseââ

She was looking coldly still at Miss Marple.

âI am sorry,â said Miss Marple apologetically. âIâI shouldnât have talked about distressing matters that are fortunately past. And I must be getting on my way,â she added. âI have got my train to catch and I shall only just have time. Oh dear, what did I do with my bagâoh yes, here it is.â

She collected her bag, umbrella and a few other things, fussing away until the tension had slightly abated. As she went out of the door, she turned to Esther who was urging her to stay and have a cup of tea.

âNo thank you, my dear, Iâm so short of time. Iâm very pleased to have seen you again and I do offer my best congratulations and hopes for a very happy life. I donât suppose you will be taking up any post again now, will you?â

âOh, some people do. They find it interesting, they say. They get bored when they have nothing to do. But I think I shall rather enjoy living a life of leisure. I shall enjoy my legacy, too, that Mr. Rafiel left me. It was very kind of him and I think heâd want meâwell, to enjoy it even if I spent it in what heâd think of perhaps as a rather silly, female way! Expensive clothes and a new hairdo and all that. Heâd have thought that sort of thing very silly.â She added suddenly, âI was fond of him, you know. Yes, I was quite fond of him. I think it was because he was a sort of challenge to me. He was difficult to get on with, and therefore I enjoyed managing it.â

âAnd managing him?â

âWell, not quite managing him, but perhaps a little more than he knew I was.â

Miss Marple trotted away down the road. She looked back once and waved her handâEsther Anderson was still standing on the doorstep, and she waved back cheerfully.

âI thought this might have been something to do with her or something she knew about,â said Miss Marple to herself. âI think Iâm wrong. No. I donât think sheâs concerned in this business, whatever it is, in any way. Oh dear, I feel Mr. Rafiel expected me to be much cleverer than I am being. I think he expected me to put things togetherâbut what things? And what do I do next, I wonder?â She shook her head.

She had to think over things very carefully. This business had been, as it were, left to her. Left to her to refuse, to accept, to understand what it was all about? Or not understand anything, but to go forward and hope that some kind of guidance might be given to her. Occasionally she closed her eyes and tried to picture Mr. Rafielâs face. Sitting in the garden of the hotel in the West Indies, in his tropical suit; his bad-tempered corrugated face, his flashes of occasional humour. What she really wanted to know was what had been in his mind when he worked up this scheme, when he set out to bring it about. To lure her into accepting it, to persuade her to accept it, toâwell, perhaps one should sayâto bully her into accepting it. The third was much the most likely, knowing Mr. Rafiel. And yet, take it that he had wanted something done and he had chosen her, settled upon her to do it. Why? Because she had suddenly come into his mind? But why should she have come into his mind?

She thought back to Mr. Rafiel and the things that had occurred at St. HonorÃ©. Had perhaps the problem he had been considering at the time of his death sent his mind back to that visit to the West Indies? Was it in some way connected with someone who had been out there, who had taken part or been an onlooker there and was that what had put Miss Marple into his mind? Was there some link or some connection? If not, why should he suddenly think of her? What was it about her that could make her useful to him, in any way at all? She was an elderly, rather scatty, quite ordinary person, physically not very strong, mentally not nearly as alert as she used to be. What had been her special qualifications, if any? She couldnât think of any. Could it possibly have been a bit of fun on Mr. Rafielâs part? Even if Mr. Rafiel had been on the point of death he might have wanted to have some kind of joke that suited his peculiar sense of humour.

She could not deny that Mr. Rafiel could quite possibly wish to have a joke, even on his deathbed. Some ironical humour of his might be satisfied.

âI must,â said Miss Marple to herself firmly, âI must have some qualification for something.â After all, since Mr. Rafiel was no longer in this world, he could not enjoy his joke at firsthand. What qualifications had she got? âWhat qualities have I got that could be useful to anyone for anything?â said Miss Marple.

She considered herself with proper humility. She was inquisitive, she asked questions, she was the sort of age and type that could be expected to ask questions. That was one point, a possible point. You could send a private detective round to ask questions, or some psychological investigator, but it was true that you could much more easily send an elderly lady with a habit of snooping and being inquisitive, of talking too much, of wanting to find out about things, and it would seem perfectly natural.

âAn old pussy,â said Miss Marple to herself. âYes, I can see Iâm quite recognizable as an old pussy. There are so many old pussies, and theyâre all so much alike. And, of course, yes, Iâm very ordinary. An ordinary rather scatty old lady. And that of course is very good camouflage. Dear me, I wonder if Iâm thinking on the right lines. I do, sometimes, know what people are like. I mean, I know what people are like, because they remind me of certain other people I have known. So I know some of their faults and some of their virtues. I know what kind of people they are. Thereâs that.â

She thought again of St. HonorÃ© and the Hotel of the Golden Palm. She had made one attempt to enquire into the possibilities of a link, by her visit to Esther Walters. That had been definitely nonproductive, Miss Marple decided. There didnât seem any further link leading from there. Nothing that would tie up with his request that Miss Marple should busy herself with something, the nature of which she still had no idea!

âDear me,â said Miss Marple, âwhat a tiresome man you are, Mr. Rafiel!â She said it aloud and there was definite reproach in her voice.

Later, however, as she climbed into bed and applied her cosy hot water bottle to the most painful portion of her rheumatic back, she spoke againâin what might be taken as a semi-apology.

âIâve done the best I could,â she said.

She spoke aloud with the air of addressing one who might easily be in the room. It is true he might be anywhere, but even then there might be some telepathic or telephonic communication, and if so, she was going to speak definitely and to the point.

âIâve done all I could. The best according to my limitations, and I must now leave it up to you.â

With that she settled herself more comfortably, stretched out a hand, switched off the electric light, and went to sleep.

Five

INSTRUCTIONS FROM BEYOND

I

It was some three or four days later that a communication arrived by the second post. Miss Marple picked up the letter, did what she usually did to letters, turned it over, looked at the stamp, looked at the handwriting, decided that it wasnât a bill and opened it. It was typewritten.

âDear Miss Marple,

By the time you read this I shall be dead and also buried. Not cremated, I am glad to think. It has always seemed to me unlikely that one would manage to rise up from oneâs handsome bronze vase full of ashes and haunt anyone if one wanted so to do! Whereas the idea of rising from oneâs grave and haunting anyone is quite possible. Shall I want to do that? Who knows. I might even want to communicate with you.

By now my solicitors will have communicated with you and will have put a certain proposition before you. I hope you will have accepted it. If you have not accepted it, donât feel in the least remorseful. It will be your choice.

This should reach you, if my solicitors have done what they were told to do, and if the posts have done the duty they are expected to perform, on the 11th of the month. In two days from now you will receive a communication from a travel bureau in London. I hope what it proposes will not be distasteful to you. I neednât say more. I want you to have an open mind. Take care of yourself. I think you will manage to do that. You are a very shrewd person. The best of luck and may your guardian angel be at your side looking after you. You may need one.

Your affectionate friend,

J. B. Rafiel.â

âTwo days!â said Miss Marple.

She found it difficult to pass the time. The Post Office did their duty and so did the Famous Houses and Gardens of Great Britain.

âDear Miss Jane Marple,

Obeying instructions given us by the late Mr. Rafiel we send you particulars of our Tour No. 37 of the Famous Houses and Gardens of Great Britain which starts from London on Thursday nextâthe 17th.

If it should be possible for you to come to our office in London, our Mrs. Sandbourne who is to accompany the tour, will be very glad to give you all particulars and to answer all questions.

Our tours last for a period of two to three weeks. This particular tour, Mr. Rafiel thinks, will be particularly acceptable to you as it will visit a part of England which as far as he knows you have not yet visited, and takes in some really very attractive scenery and gardens. He has arranged for you to have the best accommodation and all the luxury available that we can provide.

Perhaps you will let us know which day would suit you to visit our office in Berkeley Street?â

Miss Marple folded up the letter, put it in her bag, noted the telephone number, thought of a few friends whom she knew, rang up two of them, one of whom had been for tours with the Famous Houses and Gardens, and spoke highly of them, the other one had not been personally on a tour but had friends who had travelled with this particular firm and who said everything was very well done, though rather expensive, and not too exhausting for the elderly. She then rang up the Berkeley Street number and said she would call upon them on the following Tuesday.

The next day she spoke to Cherry on the subject.

âI may be going away, Cherry,â she said. âOn a Tour.â

âA Tour?â said Cherry. âOne of these travel tours? You mean a package tour abroad?â

âNot abroad. In this country,â said Miss Marple. âMainly visiting historic buildings and gardens.â

âDo you think itâs all right to do that at your age? These things can be very tiring, you know. You have to walk miles sometimes.â

âMy health is really very good,â said Miss Marple, âand I have always heard that in these tours they are careful to provide restful intervals for such people who are not particularly strong.â

âWell, be careful of yourself, thatâs all,â said Cherry. âWe donât want you falling down with a heart attack, even if you are looking at a particularly sumptuous fountain or something. Youâre a bit old, you know, to do this sort of thing. Excuse me saying it, it sounds rude, but I donât like to think of you passing out because youâve done too much or anything like that.â

âI can take care of myself,â said Miss Marple, with some dignity.

âAll right, but you just be careful,â said Cherry.

Miss Marple packed a suitcase bag, went to London, booked a room at a modest hotelâ(âAh, Bertramâs Hotel,â she thought in her mind, âwhat a wonderful hotel that was! Oh dear, I must forget all those things, the St. George is quite a pleasant place.â) At the appointed time she was at Berkeley Street and was shown in to the office where a pleasant woman of about thirty-five rose to meet her, explained that her name was Mrs. Sandbourne and that she would be in personal charge of this particular tour.

âAm I to understand,â said Miss Marple, âthat this trip is in my caseââ she hesitated.

Mrs. Sandbourne, sensing slight embarrassment, said:

âOh yes, I ought to have explained perhaps better in the letter we sent you. Mr. Rafiel has paid all expenses.â

âYou do know that he is dead?â said Miss Marple.

âOh yes, but this was arranged before his death. He mentioned that he was in ill health but wanted to provide a treat for a very old friend of his who had not had the opportunity of travelling as much as she could have wished.â

II

Two days later, Miss Marple, carrying her small overnight bag, her new and smart suitcase surrendered to the driver, had boarded a most comfortable and luxurious coach which was taking a north-westerly route out of London; she was studying the passenger list which was attached to the inside of a handsome brochure giving details of the daily itinerary of the coach, and various information as to hotels and meals, places to be seen, and occasional alternatives on some days which, although the fact was not stressed, actually intimated that one choice of itinerary was for the young and active and that the other choice would be peculiarly suitable for the elderly, those whose feet hurt them, who suffered from arthritis or rheumatism and who would prefer to sit about and not walk long distances or up too many hills. It was all very tactful and well arranged.

Miss Marple read the passenger list and surveyed her fellow passengers. There was no difficulty about doing this because the other fellow passengers were doing much the same themselves. They were surveying her, amongst others, but nobody as far as Miss Marple could notice was taking any particular interest in her.

Mrs. Riseley-Porter

Miss Joanna Crawford

Colonel and Mrs. Walker

Mr. and Mrs. H. T. Butler

Miss Elizabeth Temple

Professor Wanstead

Mr. Richard Jameson

Miss Lumley

Miss Bentham

Mr. Casper

Miss Cooke

Miss Barrow

Mr. Emlyn Price

Miss Jane Marple

There were four elderly ladies. Miss Marple took note of them first so, as it were, to clear them out of the way. Two were travelling together. Miss Marple put them down as about seventy. They could roughly be considered as contemporaries of her own. One of them was very definitely the complaining type, one who would want to have seats at the front of the coach or else would make a point of having them at the back of the coach. Would wish to sit on the sunny-side or could only bear to sit on the shady side. Who would want more fresh air, or less fresh air. They had with them travelling rugs and knitted scarves and quite an assortment of guidebooks. They were slightly crippled and often in pain from feet or backs or knees but were nevertheless of those whom age and ailments could not prevent from enjoying life while they still had it. Old pussies, but definitely not stay-at-home old pussies. Miss Marple made an entry in the little book she carried.

Fifteen passengers not including herself, or Mrs. Sandbourne. And since she had been sent on this coach tour, one at least of those fifteen passengers must be of importance in some way. Either as a source of information or someone concerned with the law or a law case, or it might even be a murderer. A murderer who might have already killed or one who might be preparing to kill. Anything was possible, Miss Marple thought, with Mr. Rafiel! Anyway, she must make notes of these people.

On the right-hand page of her notebook, she would note down who might be worthy of attention from Mr. Rafielâs point of view and on the left she would note down or cross off those who could only be of any interest if they could produce some useful information for her. Information, it might be, that they did not even know they possessed. Or rather that even if they possessed it, they did not know it could possibly be useful to her or to Mr. Rafiel or to the law or to Justice with a capital âJ.â At the back of her little book, she might this evening make a note or two as to whether anyone had reminded her of characters she had known in the past at St. Mary Mead and other places. Any similarities might make a useful pointer. It had done so on other occasions.

The other two elderly ladies were apparently separate travellers. Both of them were about sixty. One was a well-preserved, well-dressed woman of obvious social importance in her own mind, but probably in other peopleâs minds as well. Her voice was loud and dictatorial. She appeared to have in tow a niece, a girl of about eighteen or nineteen who addressed her as Aunt Geraldine. The niece, Miss Marple noted, was obviously well accustomed to coping with Aunt Geraldineâs bossiness. She was a competent girl as well as being an attractive one.

Across the aisle from Miss Marple was a big man with square shoulders and a clumsy-looking body, looking as though he had been carelessly assembled by an ambitious child out of chunky bricks. His face looked as though nature had planned it to be round but the face had rebelled at this and decided to achieve a square effect by developing a powerful jaw. He had a thick head of greyish hair and enormous bushy eyebrows which moved up and down to give point to what he was saying. His remarks seemed mainly to come out in a series of barks as though he was a talkative sheepdog. He shared his seat with a tall dark foreigner who moved restlessly in his seat and gesticulated freely. He spoke a most peculiar English, making occasional remarks in French and German. The bulky man seemed quite capable of meeting these onslaughts of foreign language, and shifted obligingly to either French or German. Taking a quick glance at them again, Miss Marple decided that the bushy eyebrows must be Professor Wanstead and the excitable foreigner was Mr. Caspar.

She wondered what it was they were discussing with such animation, but was baffled by the rapidity and force of Mr. Casparâs delivery.

The seat in front of them was occupied by the other woman of about sixty, a tall woman, possibly over sixty, but a woman who would have stood out in a crowd anywhere. She was still a very handsome woman with dark grey hair coiled high on her head, drawn back from a fine forehead. She had a low, clear, incisive voice. A personality, Miss Marple thought. Someone! Yes, she was decidedly someone. âReminds me,â she thought to herself, âof Dame Emily Waldron.â Dame Emily Waldron had been the Principal of an Oxford College and a notable scientist, and Miss Marple, having once met her in her nephewâs company, had never quite forgotten her.

Miss Marple resumed her survey of the passengers. There were two married couples, one American, middle-aged, amiable, a talkative wife and a placidly agreeing husband. They were obviously dedicated travellers and sightseers. There was also an English middle-aged couple whom Miss Marple noted down without hesitation as a retired military man and wife. She ticked them off from the list as Colonel and Mrs. Walker.

In the seat behind her was a tall, thin man of about thirty with a highly technical vocabulary, clearly an architect. There were also two middle-aged ladies travelling together rather further up the coach. They were discussing the brochure and deciding what the tour was going to hold for them in the way of attractions. One was dark and thin and the other was fair and sturdily built and the latterâs face seemed faintly familiar to Miss Marple. She wondered where she had seen or met her before. However, she could not recall the occasion to mind. Possibly someone she had met at a cocktail party or sat opposite to in a train. There was nothing very special about her to remember.

Only one more passenger remained for her to appraise, and this was a young man, possibly of about nineteen or twenty. He wore the appropriate clothes for his age and sex; tight black jeans, a polo-necked purple sweater and his head was an outsize rich mop of non-disciplined black hair. He was looking with an air of interest at the bossy womanâs niece, and the bossy womanâs niece also, Miss Marple thought, was looking with some interest at him. In spite of the preponderance of elderly pussies and middle-aged females there were, at any rate, two young people among the passengers.

They stopped for lunch at a pleasant riverside hotel, and the afternoon sightseeing was given over to Blenheim. Miss Marple had already visited Blenheim twice before, so she saved her feet by limiting the amount of sightseeing indoors and coming fairly soon to the enjoyment of the gardens and the beautiful view.

By the time they arrived at the hotel where they were to stay the night, the passengers were getting to know each other. The efficient Mrs. Sandbourne, still brisk and unwearied by her duties in directing the sightseeing, did her part very well; creating little groups by adding anyone who looked as if they were left out to one or other of them, murmuring, âYou must make Colonel Walker describe his garden to you. Such a wonderful collection of fuchsias he has.â With such little sentences she drew people together.

Miss Marple was now able to attach names to all the passengers. Bushy eyebrows turned out to be Professor Wanstead, as she had thought, and the foreigner was Mr. Caspar. The bossy woman was Mrs. Riseley-Porter and her niece was called Joanna Crawford. The young man with the hair was Emlyn Price and he and Joanna Crawford appeared to be finding out that certain things in life, such as decided opinions, they had in common, on economics, art, general dislikes, politics and such topics.

The two eldest pussies graduated naturally to Miss Marple as a kindred elderly pussy. They discussed happily arthritis, rheumatism, diets, new doctors, remedies both professional, patent, and reminiscences of old wivesâ treatments which had had success where all else failed. They discussed the many tours they had been on to foreign places in Europe; hotels, travel agencies and finally the County of Somerset where Miss Lumley and Miss Bentham lived, and where the difficulties of getting suitable gardeners could hardly be believed.

The two middle-aged ladies travelling together turned out to be Miss Cooke and Miss Barrow. Miss Marple still felt that one of these two, the fair one, Miss Cooke, was faintly familiar to her, but she still could not remember where she had seen her before. Probably it was only her fancy. It might also be just fancy but she could not help feeling that Miss Barrow and Miss Cooke appeared to be avoiding her. They seemed rather anxious to move away if she approached. That, of course, might be entirely her imagination.

Fifteen people, one of whom at least must matter in some way. In casual conversation that evening she introduced the name of Mr. Rafiel, so as to note if anyone reacted in any way. Nobody did.

The handsome woman was identified as Miss Elizabeth Temple, who was the retired Headmistress of a famous girlsâ school. Nobody appeared to Miss Marple likely to be a murderer except possibly Mr. Caspar, and that was probably foreign prejudice. The thin young man was Richard Jameson, an architect.

âPerhaps I shall do better tomorrow,â said Miss Marple to herself.

III

Miss Marple went to bed definitely tired out. Sightseeing was pleasant but exhausting, and trying to study fifteen or sixteen people at once and wondering as you did so which of them could possibly be connected with a murder, was even more exhausting. It had a touch of such unreality about it that one could not, Miss Marple felt, take it seriously. These seemed to be all perfectly nice people, the sort of people who go on cruises and on tours and all the rest of it. However, she took another quick and cursory glance at the passenger list, making a few little entries in her notebook.

Mrs. Riseley-Porter? Not connected with crime. Too social and self-centred.

Niece, Joanna Crawford? The same? But very efficient.

Mrs. Riseley-Porter, however, might have information of some kind which Miss Marple might find had a bearing on matters. She must keep on agreeable terms with Mrs. Riseley-Porter.

Miss Elizabeth Temple? A personality. Interesting. She did not remind Miss Marple of any murderer sheâd ever known. âIn fact,â said Miss Marple to herself, âshe really radiates integrity. If she had committed a murder, it would be a very popular murder. Perhaps for some noble reason or for some reason that she thought noble?â But that wasnât satisfactory either. Miss Temple, she thought, would always know what she was doing and why she was doing it and would not have any silly ideas about nobility when merely evil existed. âAll the same,â said Miss Marple, âsheâs someone and she mightâshe just might be a person Mr. Rafiel wanted me to meet for some reason.â She jotted down these thoughts on the right-hand side of her notebook.

She shifted her point of view. She had been considering a possible murdererâwhat about a prospective victim? Who was a possible victim? No one very likely. Perhaps Mrs. Riseley-Porter might qualifyârichârather disagreeable. The efficient niece might inherit. She and the anarchistic Emlyn Price might combine in the cause of anticapitalism. Not a very credible idea, but no other feasible murder seemed on offer.

Professor Wanstead? An interesting man, she was sure. Kindly, too. Was he a scientist or was he medical? She was not as yet sure, but she put him down on the side of science. She herself knew nothing of science, but it seemed not at all unlikely.

Mr. and Mrs. Butler? She wrote them off. Nice Americans. No connections with anyone in the West Indies or anyone she had known. No, she didnât think that the Butlers could be relevant.

Richard Jameson? That was the thin architect. Miss Marple didnât see how architecture could come into it, though it might, she supposed. A priestâs hole, perhaps? One of the houses they were going to visit might have a priestâs hole which would contain a skeleton. And Mr. Jameson, being an architect, would know just where the priestâs hole was. He might aid her to discover it, or she might aid him to discover it and then they would find a body. âOh really,â said Miss Marple. âWhat nonsense I am talking and thinking.â

Miss Cooke and Miss Barrow? A perfectly ordinary pair. And yet sheâd certainly seen one of them before. At least sheâd seen Miss Cooke before. Oh well, it would come to her, she supposed.

Colonel and Mrs. Walker? Nice people. Retired Army folk. Served abroad mostly. Nice to talk to, but she didnât think thereâd be anything for her there.

Miss Bentham and Miss Lumley? The elderly pussies. Unlikely to be criminals, but, being elderly pussies, they might know plenty of gossip, or have some information, or might make some illuminating remark even if it happened to come about in connection with rheumatism, arthritis or patent medicine.

Mr. Caspar? Possibly a dangerous character. Very excitable. She would keep him on the list for the present.

Emlyn Price? A student presumably. Students were very violent. Would Mr. Rafiel have sent her on the track of a student? Well, it would depend perhaps on what the student had done or wished to do or was going to do. A dedicated anarchist, perhaps.

âOh dear,â said Miss Marple, suddenly exhausted, âI must go to bed.â

Her feet ached, her back ached and her mental reactions were not, she thought, at their best. She slept at once. Her sleep was enlivened by several dreams.

One where Professor Wansteadâs bushy eyebrows fell off because they were not his own eyebrows, but false ones. As she woke again, her first impression was that which so often follows dreams, a belief that the dream in question had solved everything. âOf course,â she thought, âof course!â His eyebrows were false and that solved the whole thing. He was the criminal.

Sadly, it came to her that nothing was solved. Professor Wansteadâs eyebrows coming off was of no help at all.

Unfortunately now, she was no longer sleepy. She sat up in bed with some determination.

She sighed and slipped on her dressing gown, moved from her bed to an upright chair, took a slightly larger notebook from her suitcase and started work.

âThe project I have undertaken,â she wrote, âis connected certainly with crime of some kind. Mr. Rafiel has distinctly stated that in his letter. He said I had a flair for justice and that necessarily included a flair for crime. So crime is involved, and it is presumably not espionage or fraud or robbery, because such things have never come my way and I have no connection with such things, or knowledge of them, or special skills. What Mr. Rafiel knows of me is only what he knew during the period of time when we were both in St. HonorÃ©. We were connected there with a murder. Murders as reported in the press have never claimed my attention. I have never read books on criminology as a subject or really been interested in such a thing. No, it has just happened that I have found myself in the vicinity of murder rather more often than would seem normal. My attention has been directed to murders involving friends or acquaintances. These curious coincidences of connections with special subjects seem to happen to people in life. One of my aunts, I remember, was on five occasions shipwrecked and a friend of mine was what I believe is officially called accident-prone. I know some of her friends refused to ride in a taxi with her. She had been in four taxi accidents and three car accidents and two railway accidents. Things like this seem to happen to certain people for no appreciable reason. I do not like to write it down but it does appear that murders seem to happen, not to me myself, thank goodness, but seem to happen in my vicinity.â

Miss Marple paused, changed her position, put a cushion in her back, and continued:

âI must try to make as logical a survey as I can of this project which I have undertaken. My instructions, or my âbriefingâ as naval friends of mine put it, are so far quite inadequate. Practically nonexistent. So I must ask myself one clear question. What is all this about? Answer! I do not know. Curious and interesting. An odd way for a man like Mr. Rafiel to go about things, especially when he was a successful business and financial operator. He wants me to guess, to employ my instinct, to observe and to obey such directions as are given to me or are hinted to me.

âSo: Point 1. Direction will be given me. Direction from a dead man. Point 2. What is involved in my problem is justice. Either to set right an injustice or to avenge evil by bringing it to justice. This is in accord with the code word Nemesis given to me by Mr. Rafiel.

âAfter explanations of the principle involved, I received my first factual directive. It was arranged by Mr. Rafiel before his death that I was to go on Tour No. 37 of Famous Houses and Gardens. Why? That is what I have to ask myself. Is it for some geographical or territorial reason? A connection or a clue? Some particular famous house? Or something involving some particular garden or landscape connected? This seems unlikely. The more likely explanation lies in the people or one of the people on this particular coach party. None of them is known to me personally, but one of them at least must be connected with the riddle I have to solve. Somebody among our group is connected or concerned with a murder. Somebody has information or a special link with the victim of a crime, or someone personally is himself or herself a murderer. A murderer as yet unsuspected.â

Miss Marple stopped here suddenly. She nodded her head. She was satisfied now with her analysis so far as it went.

And so to bed.

Miss Marple added to her notebook.

âHere endeth the First Day.â

Six

LOVE

The following morning they visited a small Queen Anne Manor House. The drive there had not been very long or tiring. It was a very charming-looking house and had an interesting history as well as a very beautiful and unusually laid out garden.

Richard Jameson, the architect, was full of admiration for the structural beauty of the house and being the kind of young man who is fond of hearing his own voice, he slowed down in nearly every room that they went through, pointing out every special moulding of fireplace, and giving historical dates and references. Some of the group, appreciative at first, began to get slightly restive, as the somewhat monotonous lecturing went on. Some of them began to edge carefully away and fall behind the party. The local caretaker, who was in charge, was not himself too pleased at having his occupation usurped by one of the sightseers. He made a few efforts to get matters back into his own hands but Mr. Jameson was unyielding. The caretaker made a last try.

âIn this room, ladies and gentlemen, the White Parlour, folks call it, is where they found a body. A young man it was, stabbed with a dagger, lying on the hearthrug. Way back in seventeen hundred and something it was. It was said that the Lady Moffat of that day had a lover. He came through a small side door and up a steep staircase to this room through a loose panel there was to the left of the fireplace. Sir Richard Moffat, her husband, you see, was said to be across the seas in the Low Countries. But he come home, and in he came unexpectedly and caught âem there together.â

He paused proudly. He was pleased at the response from his audience, glad of a respite from the architectural details which they had been having forced down their throats.

âWhy, isnât that just too romantic, Henry?â said Mrs. Butler in her resonant transatlantic tones. âWhy, you know, thereâs quite an atmosphere in this room. I feel it. I certainly can feel it.â

âMamie is very sensitive to atmospheres,â said her husband proudly to those around him. âWhy, once when we were in an old house down in Louisianaâ¦.â

The narrative of Mamieâs special sensitivity got into its swing and Miss Marple and one or two others seized their opportunity to edge gently out of the room and down the exquisitely moulded staircase to the ground floor.

âA friend of mine,â said Miss Marple to Miss Cooke and Miss Barrow who were next to her, âhad a most nerve-racking experience only a few years ago. A dead body on their library floor one morning.â

âOne of the family?â asked Miss Barrow. âAn epileptic fit?â

âOh no, it was a murder. A strange girl in evening dress. A blonde. But her hair was dyed. She was really a brunette; andâoh â¦â Miss Marple broke off, her eyes fixed on Miss Cookeâs yellow hair where it escaped from her headscarf.

It had come to her suddenly. She knew why Miss Cookeâs face was familiar and she knew where she had seen her before. But when she had seen her then, Miss Cookeâs hair had been darkâalmost black. And now it was bright yellow.

Mrs. Riseley-Porter, coming down the stairs, spoke decisively as she pushed past them and completed the staircase and turned into the hall.

âI really cannot go up and down anymore of those stairs,â she declared, âand standing around in these rooms is very tiring. I believe the gardens here, although not extensive, are quite celebrated in horticultural circles. I suggest we go there without loss of time. It looks as though it might cloud over before long. I think we shall get rain before morning is out.â

The authority with which Mrs. Riseley-Porter could enforce her remarks had its usual result. All those near at hand or within hearing followed her obediently out through french doors in the dining room into the garden. The gardens had indeed all that Mrs. Riseley-Porter had claimed for them. She herself took possession firmly of Colonel Walker and set off briskly. Some of the others followed them, others took paths in the opposite direction.

Miss Marple herself made a determined beeline for a garden seat which appeared to be of comfortable proportions as well as of artistic merit. She sank down on it with relief, and a sigh matching her own was emitted by Miss Elizabeth Temple as she followed Miss Marple and came to sit beside her on the seat.

âGoing over houses is always tiring,â said Miss Temple. âThe most tiring thing in the world. Especially if you have to listen to an exhaustive lecture in each room.â

âOf course, all that we were told is very interesting,â said Miss Marple, rather doubtfully.

âOh, do you think so?â said Miss Temple. Her head turned slightly and her eyes met those of Miss Marple. Something passed between the two women, a kind of rapportâof understanding tinged with mirth.

âDonât you?â asked Miss Marple.

âNo,â said Miss Temple.

This time the understanding was definitely established between them. They sat there companionably in silence. Presently Elizabeth Temple began to talk about gardens, and this garden in particular. âIt was designed by Holman,â she said, âsomewhere about 1800 or 1798. He died young. A pity. He had great genius.â

âIt is so sad when anyone dies young,â said Miss Marple.

âI wonder,â said Elizabeth Temple.

She said it in a curious, meditative way.

âBut they miss so much,â said Miss Marple. âSo many things.â

âOr escape so much,â said Miss Temple.

âBeing as old as I am now,â said Miss Marple, âI suppose I canât help feeling that early death means missing things.â

âAnd I,â said Elizabeth Temple, âhaving spent nearly all my life amongst the young, look at life as a period in time complete in itself. What did T. S. Eliot say: The moment of the rose and the moment of the yew tree are of equal duration.â

Miss Marple said, âI see what you mean â¦ A life of whatever length is a complete experience. But donât youââ she hesitated, ââever feel that a life could be incomplete because it has been cut unduly short?â

âYes, that is so.â

Miss Marple said, looking at the flowers near her, âHow beautiful peonies are. That long border of themâso proud and yet so beautifully fragile.â

Elizabeth Temple turned her head towards her.

âDid you come on this trip to see the houses or to see gardens?â she asked.

âI suppose really to see the houses,â said Miss Marple. âI shall enjoy the gardens most, though, but the housesâthey will be a new experience for me. Their variety and their history, and the beautiful old furniture and the pictures.â She added: âA kind friend gave me this trip as a gift. I am very grateful. I have not seen very many big and famous houses in my life.â

âA kind thought,â said Miss Temple.

âDo you often go on these sightseeing tours?â asked Miss Marple.

âNo. This is not for me exactly a sightseeing tour.â

Miss Marple looked at her with interest. She half opened her lips to speak but refrained from putting a question. Miss Temple smiled at her.

âYou wonder why I am here, what my motive is, my reason. Well, why donât you make a guess?â

âOh, I wouldnât like to do that,â said Miss Marple.

âYes, do do so.â Elizabeth Temple was urgent. âIt would interest me. Yes, really interest me. Make a guess.â

Miss Marple was silent for quite a few moments. Her eyes looked at Elizabeth Temple steadily, ranging over her thoughtfully in her appraisement. She said,

âThis is not from what I know about you or what I have been told about you. I know that you are quite a famous person and that your school is a very famous one. No. I am only making my guess from what you look like. I shouldâwrite you down as a pilgrim. You have the look of one who is on a pilgrimage.â

There was a silence and then Elizabeth said,

âThat describes it very well. Yes. I am on a pilgrimage.â

Miss Marple said after a moment or two,

âThe friend who sent me on this tour and paid all my expenses, is now dead. He was a Mr. Rafiel, a very rich man. Did you by any chance know him?â

âJason Rafiel? I know him by name, of course. I never knew him personally, or met him. He gave a large endowment once to an educational project in which I was interested. I was very grateful. As you say, he was a very wealthy man. I saw the notice of his death in the papers a few weeks ago. So he was an old friend of yours?â

âNo,â said Miss Marple. âI had met him just over a year ago abroad. In the West Indies. I never knew much about him. His life or his family or any personal friends that he had. He was a great financier but otherwise, or so people always said, he was a man who was very reserved about himself. Did you know his family or anyone â¦?â Miss Marple paused. âI often wondered, but one does not like to ask questions and seem inquisitive.â

Elizabeth was silent for a minuteâthen she said:

âI knew a girl once â¦ A girl who had been a pupil of mine at Fallowfield, my school. She was no actual relation to Mr. Rafiel, but she was at one time engaged to marry Mr. Rafielâs son.â

âBut she didnât marry him?â Miss Marple asked.

âNo.â

âWhy not?â

Miss Temple said,

âOne might hope to sayâlike to sayâbecause she had too much sense. He was not the type of a young man one would want anyone one was fond of to marry. She was a very lovely girl and a very sweet girl. I donât know why she didnât marry him. Nobody has ever told me.â She sighed and then said, âAnyway, she diedâ¦.â

âWhy did she die?â said Miss Marple.

Elizabeth Temple stared at the peonies for some minutes. When she spoke she uttered one word. It echoed like the tone of a deep bellâso much so that it was startling.

âLove!â she said.

Miss Marple queried the word sharply. âLove?â

âOne of the most frightening words there is in the world,â said Elizabeth Temple.

Again her voice was bitter and tragic.

âLoveâ¦.â

Seven

AN INVITATION

I

Miss Marple decided to miss out on the afternoonâs sightseeing. She admitted to being somewhat tired and would perhaps give a miss to an ancient church and its 14th-century glass. She would rest for a while and join them at the tearoom which had been pointed out to her in the main street. Mrs. Sandbourne agreed that she was being very sensible.

Miss Marple, resting on a comfortable bench outside the tearoom, reflected on what she planned to do next and whether it would be wise to do it or not.

When the others joined her at teatime it was easy for her to attach herself unobtrusively to Miss Cooke and Miss Barrow and sit with them at a table for four. The fourth chair was occupied by Mr. Caspar whom Miss Marple considered as not sufficiently conversant with the English language to matter.

Leaning across the table, as she nibbled a slice of Swiss roll, Miss Marple said to Miss Cooke,

âYou know, I am quite sure we have met before. I have been wondering and wondering about itâIâm not as good as I was at remembering faces, but Iâm sure I have met you somewhere.â

Miss Cooke looked kindly but doubtful. Her eyes went to her friend, Miss Barrow. So did Miss Marpleâs. Miss Barrow showed no signs of helping to probe the mystery.

âI donât know if youâve ever stayed in my part of the world,â went on Miss Marple, âI live in St. Mary Mead. Quite a small village, you know. At least, not so small nowadays, there is so much building going on everywhere. Not very far from Much Benham and only twelve miles from the coast at Loomouth.â

âOh,â said Miss Cooke, âlet me see. Well, I know Loomouth quite well and perhapsââ

Suddenly Miss Marple made a pleased exclamation.

âWhy, of course! I was in my garden one day at St. Mary Mead and you spoke to me as you were passing by on the footpath. You said you were staying down there, I remember, with a friendââ

âOf course,â said Miss Cooke. âHow stupid of me. I do remember you now. We spoke of how difficult it was nowadays to get anyoneâto do job gardening, I meanâanyone who was any use.â

âYes. You were not living there, I think? You were staying with someone.â

âYes, I was staying with â¦ with â¦â for a moment Miss Cooke hesitated, with the air of one who hardly knows or remembers a name.

âWith a Mrs. Sutherland, was it?â suggested Miss Marple.

âNo, no, it was â¦ er â¦ Mrs.ââ

âHastings,â said Miss Barrow firmly as she took a piece of chocolate cake.

âOh yes, in one of the new houses,â said Miss Marple.

âHastings,â said Mr. Caspar unexpectedly. He beamed. âI have been to HastingsâI have been to Eastbourne, too.â He beamed again. âVery niceâby the sea.â

âSuch a coincidence,â said Miss Marple, âmeeting again so soonâsuch a small world, isnât it?â

âOh, well, we are all so fond of gardens,â said Miss Cooke vaguely.

âFlowers very pretty,â said Mr. Caspar. âI like very muchââ He beamed again.

âSo many rare and beautiful shrubs,â said Miss Cooke.

Miss Marple went full speed ahead with a gardening conversation of some technicalityâMiss Cooke responded. Miss Barrow put in an occasional remark.

Mr. Caspar relapsed into smiling silence.

Later, as Miss Marple took her usual rest before dinner, she conned over what she had collected. Miss Cooke had admitted being in St. Mary Mead. She had admitted walking past Miss Marpleâs house. Had agreed it was quite a coincidence. Coincidence? thought Miss Marple meditatively, turning the word over in her mouth rather as a child might do to a certain lollipop to decide its flavour. Was it a coincidence? Or had she had some reason to come there? Had she been sent there? Sent thereâfor what reason? Was that a ridiculous thing to imagine?

âAny coincidence,â said Miss Marple to herself, âis always worth noticing. You can throw it away later if it is only a coincidence.â

Miss Cooke and Miss Barrow appeared to be a perfectly normal pair of friends doing the kind of tour which, according to them, they did every year. They had been on an Hellenic cruise last year and a tour of bulbs in Holland the year before, and Northern Ireland the year before that. They seemed perfectly pleasant and ordinary people. But Miss Cooke, she thought, had for a moment looked as though she were about to disclaim her visit to St. Mary Mead. She had looked at her friend, Miss Barrow, rather as though she were seeking instruction as to what to say. Miss Barrow was presumably the senior partnerâ

âOf course, really, I may have been imagining all these things,â thought Miss Marple. âThey may have no significance whatever.â

The word danger came unexpectedly into her mind. Used by Mr. Rafiel in his first letterâand there had been some reference to her needing a guardian angel in his second letter. Was she going into danger in this business?âand why? From whom?

Surely not from Miss Cooke and Miss Barrow. Such an ordinary-looking couple.

All the same Miss Cooke had dyed her hair and altered her style of hairdressing. Disguised her appearance as much as she could, in fact. Which was odd, to say the least of it! She considered once more her fellow travellers.

Mr. Caspar, now, it would have been much easier to imagine that he might be dangerous. Did he understand more English than he pretended to do? She began to wonder about Mr. Caspar.

Miss Marple had never quite succeeded in abandoning her Victorian view of foreigners. One never knew with foreigners. Quite absurd, of course, to feel like thatâshe had many friends from various foreign countries. All the same â¦? Miss Cooke, Miss Barrow, Mr. Caspar, that young man with the wild hairâEmlyn Somethingâa revolutionaryâa practising anarchist? Mr. and Mrs. Butlerâsuch nice Americansâbut perhapsâtoo good to be true?

âReally,â said Miss Marple, âI must pull myself together.â

She turned her attention to the itinerary of their trip. Tomorrow, she thought, was going to be rather strenuous. A morningâs sightseeing drive, starting rather early: a long, rather athletic walk on a coastal path in the afternoon. Certain interesting marine flowering plantsâit would be tiring. A tactful suggestion was appended. Anyone who felt like a rest could stay behind in their hotel, the Golden Boar, which had a very pleasant garden or could do a short excursion which would only take an hour, to a beauty spot nearby. She thought perhaps that she would do that.

But though she did not know it then, her plans were to be suddenly altered.

II

As Miss Marple came down from her room in the Golden Boar the next day after washing her hands before luncheon, a woman in a tweed coat and skirt came forward rather nervously and spoke to her.

âExcuse me, are you Miss MarpleâMiss Jane Marple?â

âYes, that is my name,â said Miss Marple, slightly surprised.

âMy name is Mrs. Glynne. Lavinia Glynne. I and my two sisters live near here andâwell, we heard you were coming, you seeââ

âYou heard I was coming?â said Miss Marple with some slight surprise.

âYes. A very old friend of ours wrote to usâoh, quite some time ago, it must have been three weeks ago, but he asked us to make a note of this date. The date of the Famous Houses and Gardens Tour. He said that a great friend of hisâor a relation, Iâm not quite sure whichâwould be on that tour.â

Miss Marple continued to look surprised.

âIâm speaking of a Mr. Rafiel,â said Mrs. Glynne.

âOh! Mr. Rafiel,â said Miss Marpleââyouâyou know thatââ

âThat he died? Yes. So sad. Just after his letter came. I think it must have been certainly very soon after he wrote to us. But we felt a special urgency to try to do what he had asked. He suggested, you know, that perhaps you would like to come and stay with us for a couple of nights. This part of the tour is rather strenuous. I mean, itâs all right for the young people, but it is very trying for anyone older. It involves several miles of walking and a certain amount of climbing up difficult cliff paths and places. My sisters and I would be so very pleased if you could come and stay in our house here. It is only ten minutesâ walk from the hotel and Iâm sure we could show you many interesting things locally.â

Miss Marple hesitated a minute. She liked the look of Mrs. Glynne, plump, good-natured, and friendly though a little shy. Besidesâhere again must be Mr. Rafielâs instructionsâthe next step for her to take? Yes, it must be so.

She wondered why she felt nervous. Perhaps because she was now at home with the people in the tour, felt part of the group although as yet she had only known them for three days.

She turned to where Mrs. Glynne was standing, looking up at her anxiously.

âThank youâit is most kind of you. I shall be very pleased to come.â

Eight

THE THREE SISTERS

Miss Marple stood looking out of a window. Behind her, on the bed, was her suitcase. She looked out over the garden with unseeing eyes. It was not often that she failed to see a garden she was looking at, in either a mood of admiration or a mood of criticism. In this case it would presumably have been criticism. It was a neglected garden, a garden on which little money had been spent possibly for some years, and on which very little work had been done. The house, too, had been neglected. It was well proportioned, the furniture in it had been good furniture once, but had had little in late years of polishing or attention. It was not a house, she thought, that had been, at any rate of late years, loved in any way. It lived up to its name: The Old Manor House. A house, built with grace and a certain amount of beauty, lived in once, cherished. The daughters and sons had married and left and now it was lived in by Mrs. Glynne who, from a word she had let fall when she showed Miss Marple up to the bedroom appointed to her, had inherited it with her sisters from an uncle and had come here to live with her sisters after her husband had died. They had all grown older, their incomes had dwindled, labour had been more difficult to get.

The other sisters, presumably, had remained unmarried, one older, one younger than Mrs. Glynne, two Miss Bradbury-Scotts.

There was no sign of anything which belonged to a child in the house. No discarded ball, no old perambulator, no little chair or a table. This was just a house with three sisters.

âSounds very Russian,â murmured Miss Marple to herself. She did mean The Three Sisters, didnât she? Chekhov, was it? Or Dostoyevsky? Really, she couldnât remember. Three sisters. But these would certainly not be the kind of three sisters who were yearning to go to Moscow. These three sisters were presumably, she was almost sure they were, content to remain where they were. She had been introduced to the other two who had come, one out of the kitchen and one down a flight of stairs, to welcome her. Their manners were well-bred and gracious. They were what Miss Marple would have called in her youth by the now obsolete term âladiesââand what she once recalled calling âdecayed ladies.â Her father had said to her:

âNo, dear Jane, not decayed. Distressed gentlewomen.â

Gentlewomen nowadays were not so liable to be distressed. They were aided by Government or by Societies or by a rich relation. Or, perhapsâby someone like Mr. Rafiel. Because, after all, that was the whole point, the whole reason for her being here, wasnât it? Mr. Rafiel had arranged all this. He had taken, Miss Marple thought, a good deal of trouble about it. He had known, presumably, some four or five weeks before his death, just when that death was likely to be, give and take a little, since doctors were usually moderately optimistic, knowing from experience that patients who ought to die within a certain period very often took an unexpected lease of life and lingered on, still doomed, but obstinately declining to take the final step. On the other hand, hospital nurses when in charge of patients, had, Miss Marple thought from her experience, always expected the patients to be dead the next day, and were much surprised when they were not. But in voicing their gloomy views to Doctor, when he came, they were apt to receive in reply as the doctor went out of the hall door, a private aside of, âLinger a few weeks yet, I shouldnât wonder.â Very nice of Doctor to be so optimistic, Nurse would think, but surely Doctor was wrong. Doctor very often wasnât wrong. He knew that people who were in pain, helpless, crippled, even unhappy, still liked living and wanting to live. They would take one of Doctorâs pills to help them pass the night, but they had no intention of taking a few more than necessary of Doctorâs pills, just in order to pass the threshold to a world that they did not as yet know anything about!

Mr. Rafiel. That was the person Miss Marple was thinking about as she looked across the garden with unseeing eyes. Mr. Rafiel? She felt now that she was getting a little closer to understanding the task laid upon her, the project suggested to her. Mr. Rafiel was a man who made plans. Made them in the same way that he planned financial deals and takeovers. In the words of her servant, Cherry, he had had a problem. When Cherry had a problem, she often came and consulted Miss Marple about it.

This was a problem that Mr. Rafiel could not deal with himself, which must have annoyed him very much, Miss Marple thought, because he could usually deal with any problem himself and insisted on doing so. But he was bedridden and dying. He could arrange his financial affairs, communicate with his lawyers, with his employees and with such friends and relations as he had, but there was something or someone that he had not arranged for. A problem he had not solved, a problem he still wanted to solve, a project he still wanted to bring about. And apparently it was not one that could be settled by financial aid, by business dealings, by the services of a lawyer.

âSo he thought of me,â said Miss Marple.

It still surprised her very much. Very much indeed. However, in the sense she was now thinking of it, his letter had been quite explicit. He had thought she had certain qualifications for doing something. It had to do, she thought once again, with something in the nature of crime or affected by crime. The only other thing he knew about Miss Marple was that she was devoted to gardens. Well it could hardly be a gardening problem that he wanted her to solve. But he might think of her in connection with crime. Crime in the West Indies and crimes in her own neighbourhood at home.

A crimeâwhere?

Mr. Rafiel had made arrangements. Arrangements, to begin with, with his lawyers. They had done their part. After the right interval of time they had forwarded to her his letter. It had been, she thought, a well considered and well thought out letter. It would have been simpler, certainly, to tell her exactly what he wanted her to do and why he wanted it. She was surprised in a way that he had not, before his death, sent for her, probably in a somewhat peremptory way and more or less lying on what he would have assured her was his deathbed, and would then have bullied her until she consented to do what he was asking her. But no, that would not really have been Mr. Rafielâs way, she thought. He could bully people, none better, but this was not a case for bullying, and he did not wish either, she was sure, to appeal to her, to beg her to do him a favour, to urge her to redress a wrong. No. That again would not have been Mr. Rafielâs way. He wanted, she thought, as he had probably wanted all his life, to pay for what he required. He wanted to pay her and therefore he wanted to interest her enough to enjoy doing certain work. The pay was offered to intrigue her, not really to tempt her. It was to arouse her interest. She did not think that he had said to himself, âOffer enough money and sheâll leap at itâ because, as she knew very well herself, the money sounded very agreeable but she was not in urgent need of money. She had her dear and affectionate nephew who, if she was in straits for money of any kind, if she needed repairs to her house or a visit to a specialist or special treats, dear Raymond would always provide them. No. The sum he offered was to be exciting. It was to be exciting in the same way as it was exciting when you had a ticket for the Irish Sweep. It was a fine big sum of money that you could never achieve by any other means except luck.

But all the same, Miss Marple thought to herself, she would need some luck as well as hard work, she would require a lot of thought and pondering and possibly what she was doing might involve a certain amount of danger. But sheâd got to find out herself what it was all about, he wasnât going to tell her, partly perhaps because he did not want to influence her? It is hard to tell anyone about something without letting slip your own point of view about it. It could be that Mr. Rafiel had thought that his own point of view might be wrong. It was not very like him to think such a thing, but it could be possible. He might suspect that his judgment, impaired by illness, was not quite as good as it used to be. So she, Miss Marple, his agent, his employee, was to make her own guesses, come to her own conclusions. Well, it was time she came to a few conclusions now. In other words, back to the old question, what was all this about?

She had been directed. Let her take that first. She had been directed by a man who was now dead. She had been directed away from St. Mary Mead. Therefore, the task, whatever it must be, could not be attacked from there. It was not a neighbourhood problem, it was not a problem that you could solve just by looking through newspaper cuttings or making enquiries, not, that is, until you found what you had to make enquiries about. She had been directed, first to the lawyerâs office, then to read a letterâtwo lettersâin her home, then to be sent on a pleasant and well run tour round some of the Famous Houses and Gardens of Great Britain. From that she had come to the next stepping stone. The house she was in at this moment. The Old Manor House, Jocelyn St. Mary, where lived Miss Clotilde Bradbury-Scott, Mrs. Glynne and Miss Anthea Bradbury-Scott. Mr. Rafiel had arranged that, arranged it beforehand. Some weeks before he died. Probably it was the next thing he had done after instructing his lawyers and after booking a seat on the tour in her name. Therefore, she was in this house for a purpose. It might be for only two nights, it might be for longer. There might be certain things arranged which would lead her to stay longer or she would be asked to stay longer. That brought her back to where she stood now.

Mrs. Glynne and her two sisters. They must be concerned, implicated in whatever this was. She would have to find out what it was. The time was short. That was the only trouble. Miss Marple had no doubt for one moment that she had the capacity to find out things. She was one of those chatty, fluffy old ladies whom other people expect to talk, to ask questions that were, on the face of it, merely gossipy questions. She would talk about her childhood and that would lead to one of the sisters talking about theirs. Sheâd talk about food she had eaten, servants she had had, daughters and cousins and relations, travel, marriages, births andâyesâdeaths. There must be no show of special interest in her eyes when she heard about a death. Not at all. Almost automatically she was sure she could come up with the right response such as, âOh dear me, how very sad!â She would have to find out relationships, incidents, life stories, see if any suggestive incidents would pop up, so to speak. It might be some incidents in the neighbourhood, not directly concerned with these three people. Something they could know about, talk about, or were pretty sure to talk about. Anyway, there would be something here, some clue, some pointer. The second day from now she would rejoin the tour unless she had by that time some indication that she was not to rejoin the tour. Her mind swept from the house to the coach and the people who had sat in it. It might be that what she was seeking had been there in the coach, and would be there again when she rejoined it. One person, several people, some innocent (some not so innocent), some long past story. She frowned a little, trying to remember something. Something that had flashed in her mind that she had thought: Really I am sureâof what had she been sure?

Her mind went back to the three sisters. She must not be too long up here. She must unpack a few modest needs for two nights, something to change into this evening, night clothes, sponge bag, and then go down and rejoin her hostesses and make pleasant talk. A main point had to be decided. Were the three sisters to be her allies or were the three sisters enemies? They might fall into either category. She must think about that carefully.

There was a tap on the door and Mrs. Glynne entered.

âI do hope you will be quite comfortable here. Can I help you to unpack? We have a very nice woman who comes in but she is only here in the morning. But sheâll help you with anything.â

âOh no, thank you,â said Miss Marple. âI only took out just a few necessities.â

âI thought Iâd show you the way downstairs again. Itâs rather a rambling house, you know. There are two staircases and it does make it a little difficult. Sometimes people lose their way.â

âOh, itâs very kind of you,â said Miss Marple.

âI hope then you will come downstairs and we will have a glass of sherry before lunch.â

Miss Marple accepted gratefully and followed her guide down the stairs. Mrs. Glynne, she judged, was a good many years younger than she herself was. Fifty, perhaps. Not much more. Miss Marple negotiated the stairs carefully, her left knee was always a little uncertain. There was, however, a banister at one side of the stairs. Very beautiful stairs they were, and she remarked on them.

âIt is really a very lovely house,â she said. âBuilt I suppose in the 1700s. Am I right?â

â1780,â said Mrs. Glynne.

She seemed pleased with Miss Marpleâs appreciation. She took Miss Marple into the drawing room. A large graceful room. There were one or two rather beautiful pieces of furniture. A Queen Anne desk and a William and Mary oystershell bureau. There were also some rather cumbrous Victorian settees and cabinets. The curtains were of chintz, faded and somewhat worn, the carpet was, Miss Marple thought, Irish. Possibly a Limerick Aubusson type. The sofa was ponderous and the velvet of it much worn. The other two sisters were already sitting there. They rose as Miss Marple came in and approached her, one with a glass of sherry, the other directing her to a chair.

âI donât know whether you like sitting rather high? So many people do.â

âI do,â said Miss Marple. âItâs so much easier. Oneâs back, you know.â

The sisters appeared to know about the difficulties of backs. The eldest of the sisters was a tall handsome woman, dark with a black coil of hair. The other one might have been a good deal younger. She was thin with grey hair that had once been fair hanging untidily on her shoulders and a faintly wraithlike appearance. She could be cast successfully as a mature Ophelia, Miss Marple thought.

Clotilde, Miss Marple thought, was certainly no Ophelia, but she would have made a magnificent Clytemnestraâshe could have stabbed a husband in his bath with exultation. But since she had never had a husband, that solution wouldnât do. Miss Marple could not see her murdering anyone else but a husbandâand there had been no Agamemnon in this house.

Clotilde Bradbury-Scott, Anthea Bradbury-Scott, Lavinia Glynne. Clotilde was handsome, Lavinia was plain but pleasant-looking, Anthea had one eyelid which twitched from time to time. Her eyes were large and grey and she had an odd way of glancing round to right and then to left, and then suddenly, in a rather strange manner, behind her over her shoulder. It was as though she felt someone was watching her all the time. Odd, thought Miss Marple. She wondered a little about Anthea.

They sat down and conversation ensued. Mrs. Glynne left the room, apparently for the kitchen. She was, it seemed, the active domestic one of the three. The conversation took a usual course. Clotilde Bradbury-Scott explained that the house was a family one. It had belonged to her great-uncle and then to her uncle and when he had died it was left to her and her two sisters who had joined her there.

âHe only had one son, you see,â explained Miss Bradbury-Scott, âand he was killed in the war. We are really the last of the family, except for some very distant cousins.â

âA beautifully proportioned house,â said Miss Marple. âYour sister tells me it was built about 1780.â

âYes, I believe so. One could wish, you know, it was not quite so large and rambling.â

âRepairs too,â said Miss Marple, âcome very heavy nowadays.â

âOh yes, indeed,â Clotilde sighed. âAnd in many ways we have to let a lot of it just fall down. Sad, but there it is. A lot of the outhouses, for instance, and a greenhouse. We had a very beautiful big greenhouse.â

âLovely muscat grapevine in it,â said Anthea. âAnd Cherry Pie used to grow all along the walls inside. Yes, I really regret that very much. Of course, during the war one could not get any gardeners. We had a very young gardener and then he was called up. One does not of course grudge that, but all the same it was impossible to get things repaired and so the whole greenhouse fell down.â

âSo did the little conservatory near the house.â

Both sisters sighed, with the sighing of those who have noted time passing, and times changingâbut not for the better.

There was a melancholy here in this house, thought Miss Marple. It was impregnated somehow with sorrowâa sorrow that could not be dispersed or removed since it had penetrated too deep. It had sunk in â¦ She shivered suddenly.

Nine

POLYGONUM BALDSCHUANICUM

The meal was conventional. A small joint of mutton, roast potatoes, followed by a plum tart with a small jug of cream and rather indifferent pastry. There were a few pictures round the dining room wall, family pictures, Miss Marple presumed, Victorian portraits without any particular merit, the sideboard was large and heavy, a handsome piece of plum-coloured mahogany. The curtains were of dark crimson damask and at the big mahogany table ten people could easily have been seated.

Miss Marple chatted about the incidents of the tour in so far as she had been on it. As this, however, had only been three days, there was not very much to say.

âMr. Rafiel, I suppose, was an old friend of yours?â said the eldest Miss Bradbury-Scott.

âNot really,â said Miss Marple. âI met him first when I was on a cruise to the West Indies. He was out there for his health, I imagine.â

âYes, he had been very crippled for some years,â said Anthea.

âVery sad,â said Miss Marple. âVery sad indeed. I really admired his fortitude. He seemed to manage to do so much work. Every day, you know, he dictated to his secretary and was continually sending off cables. He did not seem to give in at all kindly to being an invalid.â

âOh no, he wouldnât,â said Anthea.

âWe have not seen much of him of late years,â said Mrs. Glynne. âHe was a busy man, of course. He always remembered us at Christmas very kindly.â

âDo you live in London, Miss Marple?â asked Anthea.

âOh no,â said Miss Marple. âI live in the country. A very small place halfway between Loomouth and Market Basing. About twenty-five miles from London. It used to be a very pretty old-world village but of course like everything else, it is becoming what they call developed nowadays.â She added, âMr. Rafiel, I suppose, lived in London? At least I noticed that in the St. HonorÃ© hotel register his address was somewhere in Eaton Square, I think, or was it Belgrave Square?â

âHe had a country house in Kent,â said Clotilde. âHe used to entertain there, I think, sometimes. Business friends, mostly you know, or people from abroad. I donât think any of us ever visited him there. He nearly always entertained us in London on the rare occasions when we happened to meet.â

âIt was very kind of him,â said Miss Marple, âto suggest to you that you should invite me here during the course of this tour. Very thoughtful. One wouldnât really have expected a busy man such as he must have been to have had such kindly thoughts.â

âWe have invited before friends of his who have been on these tours. On the whole they are very considerate the way they arrange these things. It is impossible, of course, to suit everybodyâs taste. The young ones naturally wish to walk, to make long excursions, to ascend hills for a view, and all that sort of thing. And the older ones who are not up to it, remain in the hotels, but hotels round here are not really at all luxurious. I am sure you would have found todayâs trip and the one to St. Bonaventure tomorrow also, very fatiguing. Tomorrow I believe there is a visit to an island, you know, in a boat and sometimes it can be very rough.â

âEven going round houses can be very tiring,â said Mrs. Glynne.

âOh, I know,â said Miss Marple. âSo much walking and standing about. Oneâs feet get very tired. I suppose really I ought not to take these expeditions, but it is such a temptation to see beautiful buildings and fine rooms and furniture. All these things. And of course some splendid pictures.â

âAnd the gardens,â said Anthea. âYou like gardens, donât you?â

âOh yes,â said Miss Marple, âspecially the gardens. From the description in the prospectus I am really looking forward very much to seeing some of the really finely kept gardens of the historic houses we have still to visit.â She beamed round the table.

It was all very pleasant, very natural, and yet she wondered why for some reason she had a feeling of strain. A feeling that there was something unnatural here. But what did she mean by unnatural? The conversation was ordinary enough, consisting mainly of platitudes. She herself was making conventional remarks and so were the three sisters.

The Three Sisters, thought Miss Marple once again considering that phrase. Why did anything thought of in threes somehow seem to suggest a sinister atmosphere? The Three Sisters. The Three Witches of Macbeth. Well, one could hardly compare these three sisters to the three witches. Although Miss Marple had always thought at the back of her mind that the theatrical producers made a mistake in the way in which they produced the three witches. One production which she had seen, indeed, seemed to her quite absurd. The witches had looked more like pantomime creatures with flapping wings and ridiculously spectacular steeple hats. They had danced and slithered about. Miss Marple remembered saying to her nephew, who was standing her this Shakespearean treat, âYou know, Raymond, my dear, if I were ever producing this splendid play I would make the three witches quite different. I would have them three ordinary, normal old women. Old Scottish women. They wouldnât dance or caper. They would look at each other rather slyly and you would feel a sort of menace just behind the ordinariness of them.â

Miss Marple helped herself to the last mouthful of plum tart and looked across the table at Anthea. Ordinary, untidy, very vague-looking, a bit scatty. Why should she feel that Anthea was sinister?

âI am imagining things,â said Miss Marple to herself. âI mustnât do that.â

After luncheon she was taken on a tour of the garden. It was Anthea who was deputed to accompany her. It was, Miss Marple thought, rather a sad progress. Here, there had once been a well kept, though certainly not in any way an outstanding or remarkable, garden. It had had the elements of an ordinary Victorian garden. A shrubbery, a drive of speckled laurels, no doubt there had once been a well kept lawn and paths, a kitchen garden of about an acre and a half, too big evidently for the three sisters who lived here now. Part of it was unplanted and had gone largely to weeds. Ground elder had taken over most of the flower beds and Miss Marpleâs hands could hardly restrain themselves from pulling up the vagrant bindweed asserting its superiority.

Miss Antheaâs long hair flapped in the wind, shedding from time to time a vague hairpin on the path or the grass. She talked rather jerkily.

âYou have a very nice garden, I expect,â she said.

âOh, itâs a very small one,â said Miss Marple.

They had come along a grass path and were pausing in front of a kind of hillock that rested against the wall at the end of it.

âOur greenhouse,â said Miss Anthea, mournfully.

âOh yes, where you had such a delightful grapevine.â

âThree vines,â said Anthea. âA Black Hamburg and one of those small white grapes, very sweet, you know. And a third one of beautiful muscats.â

âAnd a heliotrope, you said.â

âCherry Pie,â said Anthea.

âAh yes, Cherry Pie. Such a lovely smell. Was there any bomb trouble round here? Did thatâerâknock the greenhouse down?â

âOh no, we never suffered from anything of that kind. This neighbourhood was quite free of bombs. No, Iâm afraid it just fell down from decay. We hadnât been here so very long and we had no money to repair it, or to build it up again. And in fact, it wouldnât have been worth it really because we couldnât have kept it up even if we did. Iâm afraid we just let it fall down. There was nothing else we could do. And now you see, itâs all grown over.â

âAh that, completely covered byâwhat is that flowering creeper just coming into bloom?â

âOh yes. Itâs quite a common one,â said Anthea. âIt begins with a P. Now what is the name of it?â she said doubtfully. âPoly something, something like that.â

âOh yes. I think I do know the name. Polygonum Baldschuanicum. Very quick growing, I think, isnât it? Very useful really if one wants to hide any tumbledown building or anything ugly of that kind.â

The mound in front of her was certainly thickly covered with the all-enveloping green and white flowering plant. It was, as Miss Marple well knew, a kind of menace to anything else that wanted to grow. Polygonum covered everything, and covered it in a remarkably short time.

âThe greenhouse must have been quite a big one,â she said.

âOh yesâwe had peaches in it, tooâand nectarines.â Anthea looked miserable.

âIt looks really very pretty now,â said Miss Marple in a consoling tone. âVery pretty little white flowers, arenât they?â

âWe have a very nice magnolia tree down this path to the left,â said Anthea. âOnce I believe there used to be a very fine border hereâa herbaceous border. But that again one cannot keep up. It is too difficult. Everything is too difficult. Nothing is like it used to beâitâs all spoiltâeverywhere.â

She led the way quickly down a path at right angles which ran along a side wall. Her pace had increased. Miss Marple could hardly keep up with her. It was, thought Miss Marple, as though she were deliberately being steered away from the Polygonum mound by her hostess. Steered away as from some ugly or displeasing spot. Was she ashamed perhaps that the past glories no longer remained? The Polygonum certainly was growing with extraordinary abandonment. It was not even being clipped or kept to reasonable proportions. It made a kind of flowery wilderness of that bit of the garden.

She almost looks as though she was running away from it, thought Miss Marple, as she followed her hostess. Presently her attention was diverted to a broken down pigsty which had a few rose tendrils round it.

âMy great-uncle used to keep a few pigs,â explained Anthea, âbut of course one would never dream of doing anything of that kind nowadays, would one? Rather too noisome, I am afraid. We have a few floribunda roses near the house. I really think floribundas are such a great answer to difficulties.â

âOh, I know,â said Miss Marple.

She mentioned the names of a few recent productions in the rose line. All the names, she thought, were entirely strange to Miss Anthea.

âDo you often come on these tours?â

The question came suddenly.

âYou mean the tours of houses and of gardens?â

âYes. Some people do it every year.â

âOh I couldnât hope to do that. Theyâre rather expensive, you see. A friend very kindly gave me a present of this to celebrate my next birthday. So kind.â

âOh. I wondered. I wondered why you came. I meanâitâs bound to be rather tiring, isnât it? Still, if you usually go to the West Indies, and places like thatâ¦.â

âOh, the West Indies was the result of kindness, too. On the part of a nephew, that time. A dear boy. So very thoughtful for his old aunt.â

âOh, I see. Yes, I see.â

âI donât know what one would do without the younger generation,â said Miss Marple. âThey are so kind, are they not?â

âIâI suppose so. I donât really know. Iâwe havenâtâany young relations.â

âDoes your sister, Mrs. Glynne, have any children? She did not mention any. One never likes to ask.â

âNo. She and her husband never had any children. Itâs as well perhaps.â

âAnd what do you mean by that?â Miss Marple wondered as they returned to the house.

Ten

âOH! FOND, OH! FAIR, THE DAYS THAT WEREâ

I

At half past eight the next morning there was a smart tap on the door, and in answer to Miss Marpleâs âCome inâ the door was opened and an elderly woman entered, bearing a tray with a teapot, a cup and a milk jug and a small plate of bread and butter.

âEarly morning tea, maâam,â she said cheerfully. âItâs a nice day, it is. I see youâve got your curtains drawn back already. Youâve slept well then?â

âVery well indeed,â said Miss Marple, laying aside a small devotional book which she had been reading.

âWell, itâs a lovely day, it is. Theyâll have it nice for going to the Bonaventure Rocks. Itâs just as well youâre not doing it. Itâs cruel hard on the legs, it is.â

âIâm really very happy to be here,â said Miss Marple. âSo kind of Miss Bradbury-Scott and Mrs. Glynne to issue this invitation.â

âAh well, itâs nice for them too. It cheers them up to have a bit of company come to the house. Ah, itâs a sad place nowadays, so it is.â

She pulled the curtains at the window rather more fully, pushed back a chair and deposited a can of hot water in the china basin.

âThereâs a bathroom on the next floor,â she said, âbut we think itâs better always for someone elderly to have their hot water here, so they donât have to climb the stairs.â

âItâs very kind of you, Iâm sureâyou know this house well?â

âI was here as a girlâI was the housemaid then. Three servants they hadâa cook, a housemaidâa parlourmaidâkitchen maid too at one time. That was in the old Colonelâs time. Horses he kept too, and a groom. Ah, those were the days. Sad it is when things happen the way they do. He lost his wife young, the Colonel did. His son was killed in the war and his only daughter went away to live on the other side of the world. Married a New Zealander she did. Died having a baby and the baby died too. He was a sad man living alone here, and he let the house goâit wasnât kept up as it should have been. When he died he left the place to his niece Miss Clotilde and her two sisters, and she and Miss Anthea came here to liveâand later Miss Lavinia lost her husband and came to join themââ she sighed and shook her head. âThey never did much to the houseâcouldnât afford itâand they let the garden go as wellââ

âIt all seems a great pity,â said Miss Marple.

âAnd such nice ladies as they all are, tooâMiss Anthea is the scatty one, but Miss Clotilde went to university and is very brainyâshe talks three languagesâand Mrs. Glynne, sheâs a very nice lady indeed. I thought when she came to join them as things might go better. But you never know, do you, what the future holds? I feel sometimes, as though there was a doom on this house.â

Miss Marple looked enquiring.

âFirst one thing and then another. The dreadful plane accidentâin Spain it wasâand everybody killed. Nasty things, aeroplanesâIâd never go in one of them. Miss Clotildeâs friends were both killed, they were husband and wifeâthe daughter was still at school, luckily, and escaped, but Miss Clotilde brought her here to live and did everything for her. Took her abroad for tripsâto Italy and France, treated her like a daughter. She was such a happy girlâand a very sweet nature. Youâd never dream that such an awful thing could happen.â

âAn awful thing. What was it? Did it happen here?â

âNo, not here, thank God. Though in a way you might say it did happen here. It was here that she met him. He was in the neighbourhoodâand the ladies knew his father, who was a very rich man, so he came here to visitâthat was the beginningââ

âThey fell in love?â

âYes, she fell in love with him right away. He was an attractive-looking boy, with a nice way of talking and passing the time of day. Youâd never thinkâyouâd never think for one momentââ she broke off.

âThere was a love affair? And it went wrong? And the girl committed suicide?â

âSuicide?â The old woman stared at Miss Marple with startled eyes.

âWhoever now told you that? Murder it was, barefaced murder. Strangled and her head beaten to pulp. Miss Clotilde had to go and identify herâsheâs never been quite the same since. They found her body a good thirty miles from hereâin the scrub of a disused quarry. And itâs believed that it wasnât the first murder heâd done. There had been other girls. Six months sheâd been missing. And the police searching far and wide. Oh! A wicked devil he wasâa bad lot from the day he was born or so it seems. They say nowadays as there are those as canât help what they doânot right in the head, and they canât be held responsible. I donât believe a word of it! Killers are killers. And they wonât even hang them nowadays. I know as thereâs often madness as runs in old familiesâthere was the Derwents over at Brassingtonâevery second generation one or other of them died in the loony binâand there was old Mrs. Paulett; walked about the lanes in her diamond tiara saying she was Marie Antoinette until they shut her up. But there wasnât anything really wrong with herâjust silly like. But this boy. Yes, he was a devil right enough.â

âWhat did they do to him?â

âTheyâd abolished hanging by thenâor else he was too young. I canât remember it all now. They found him guilty. It may have been Bostol or Broadsandâone of those places beginning with âBâ as they sent him to.â

âWhat was the name of the boy?â

âMichaelâcanât remember his last name. Itâs ten years ago that it happenedâone forgets. Italian sort of nameâlike a picture. Someone who paints picturesâRaffle, thatâs itââ

âMichael Rafiel?â

âThatâs right! There was a rumour as went about that his father being so rich got him wangled out of prison. An escape like the Bank Robbers. But I think as that was just talkââ

So it had not been suicide. It had been murder. âLove!â Elizabeth Temple had named as the cause of a girlâs death. In a way she was right. A young girl had fallen in love with a killerâand for love of him had gone unsuspecting to an ugly death.

Miss Marple gave a little shudder. On her way along the village street yesterday she had passed a newspaper placard:

EPSOM DOWNS MURDER, SECOND GIRLâS BODY DISCOVERED, YOUTH ASKED TO ASSIST POLICE.

So history repeated itself. An old patternâan ugly pattern. Some lines of forgotten verse came haltingly into her brain:

Rose white youth, passionate, pale,

A singing stream in a silent vale,

A fairy prince in a prosy tale,

Oh thereâs nothing in life so finely frail

As Rose White Youth.

Who was there to guard Youth from Pain and Death? Youth who could not, who had never been able to, guard itself. Did they know too little? Or was it that they knew too much? And therefore thought they knew it all.

II

Miss Marple, coming down the stairs that morning, probably rather earlier than she had been expected, found no immediate sign of her hostesses. She let herself out at the front door and wandered once round the garden. It was not because sheâd really enjoyed this particular garden. It was some vague feeling that there was something here that she ought to notice, something that would give her some idea, or that had given her some idea only she had notâwell, frankly, she had not been bright enough to realize just what the bright idea had been. Something she ought to take note of, something that had a bearing.

She was not at the moment anxious to see any of the three sisters. She wanted to turn a few things over in her mind. The new facts that had come to her through Janetâs early tea chat.

A side gate stood open and she went through it to the village street and along a line of small shops to where a steeple poked up announcing the site of the church and its churchyard. She pushed open the lych-gate and wandered about among the graves, some dating from quite a while back, some by the far wall later ones, and one or two beyond the wall in what was obviously a new enclosure. There was nothing of great interest among the older tombs. Certain names recurred as they do in villages. A good many Princes of village origin had been buried. Jasper Prince, deeply regretted. Margery Prince, Edgar and Walter Prince, Melanie Prince, 4 years old. A family record. Hiram BroadâEllen Jane Broad, Eliza Broad, 91 years.

She was turning away from the latter when she observed an elderly man moving in slow motion among the graves, tidying up as he walked. He gave her a salute and a âgood morning.â

âGood morning,â said Miss Marple. âA very pleasant day.â

âItâll turn to rain later,â said the old man.

He spoke with the utmost certainty.

âThere seem to be a lot of Princes and Broads buried here,â said Miss Marple.

âAh yes, thereâve always been Princes here. Used to own quite a bit of land once. There have been Broads a good many years, too.â

âI see a child is buried here. Very sad when one sees a childâs grave.â

âAh, thatâll be little Melanie that was. Mellie, we called her. Yes, it was a sad death. Run over, she was. Ran out into the street, went to get sweets at the sweet shop. Happens a lot nowadays with cars going through at the pace they do.â

âIt is sad to think,â said Miss Marple, âthat there are so many deaths all the time. And one doesnât really notice it until one looks at the inscriptions in the churchyard. Sickness, old age, children run over, sometimes even more dreadful things. Young girls killed. Crimes, I mean.â

âAh, yes, thereâs a lot of that about. Silly girls, I call most of âem. And their mums havenât got time to look after them properly nowadaysâwhat with going out to work so much.â

Miss Marple rather agreed with his criticism, but had no wish to waste time in agreement on the trend of the day.

âStaying at The Old Manor House, arenât you?â the old man asked. âCome here on the coach tour I saw. But it got too much for you, I suppose. Some of those that are gettinâ on canât always take it.â

âI did find it a little exhausting,â confessed Miss Marple, âand a very kind friend of mine, a Mr. Rafiel, wrote to some friends of his here and they invited me to stay for a couple of nights.â

The name, Rafiel, clearly meant nothing to the elderly gardener.

âMrs. Glynne and her two sisters have been very kind,â said Miss Marple. âI suppose theyâve lived here a long time?â

âNot so long as that. Twenty years maybe. Belonged to old Colonel Bradbury-Scott. The Old Manor House did. Close on seventy he was when he died.â

âDid he have any children?â

âA son what was killed in the war. Thatâs why he left the place to his nieces. Nobody else to leave it to.â

He went back to his work amongst the graves.

Miss Marple went into the church. It had felt the hand of a Victorian restorer, and had bright Victorian glass in the windows. One or two brasses and some tablets on the walls were all that was left of the past.

Miss Marple sat down in an uncomfortable pew and wondered about things.

Was she on the right track now? Things were connecting upâbut the connections were far from clear.

A girl had been murderedâ(actually several girls had been murdered)âsuspected young men (or âyouthsâ as they were usually called nowadays) had been rounded up by the police, to âassist them in their enquiries.â A common pattern, but this was all old history, dating back ten or twelve years. There was nothing to find outânow, no problems to solve. A tragedy labelled Finis.

What could be done by her? What could Mr. Rafiel possibly want her to do?

Elizabeth Temple â¦ She must get Elizabeth Temple to tell her more. Elizabeth had spoken of a girl who had been engaged to be married to Michael Rafiel. But was that really so? That did not seem to be known to those in The Old Manor House.

A more familiar version came into Miss Marpleâs mindâthe kind of story that had been reasonably frequent in her own village. Starting as always, âBoy meets girl.â Developing in the usual wayâ

âAnd then the girl finds she is pregnant,â said Miss Marple to herself, âand she tells the boy and she wants him to marry her. But he, perhaps, doesnât want to marry herâhe has never had any idea of marrying her. But things may be made difficult for him in this case. His father, perhaps, wonât hear of such a thing. Her relations will insist that he âdoes the right thing.â And by now he is tired of the girlâheâs got another girl perhaps. And so he takes a quick brutal way outâstrangles her, beats her head to a pulp to avoid identification. It fits with his recordâa brutal sordid crimeâbut forgotten and done with.â

She looked round the church in which she was sitting. It looked so peaceful. The reality of Evil was hard to believe in. A flair for Evilâthat was what Mr. Rafiel had attributed to her. She rose and walked out of the church and stood looking round the churchyard again. Here, amongst the gravestones and their worn inscriptions, no sense of Evil moved in her.

Was it Evil she had sensed yesterday at The Old Manor House? That deep depression of despair, that dark desperate grief. Anthea Bradbury-Scott, her eyes gazing fearfully back over one shoulder, as though fearing some presence that stood thereâalways stood thereâbehind her.

They knew something, those Three Sisters, but what was it that they knew?

Elizabeth Temple, she thought again. She pictured Elizabeth Temple with the rest of the coach party, striding across the downs at this moment, climbing up a steep path and gazing over the cliffs out to sea.

Tomorrow, when she rejoined the tour, she would get Elizabeth Temple to tell her more.

III

Miss Marple retraced her steps to The Old Manor House, walking rather slowly because she was by now tired. She could not really feel that her morning had been productive in any way. So far The Old Manor House had given her no distinctive ideas of any kind, a tale of a past tragedy told by Janet, but there were always past tragedies treasured in the memories of domestic workers and which were remembered quite as clearly as all the happy events such as spectacular weddings, big entertainments and successful operations or accidents from which people had recovered in a miraculous manner.

As she drew near the gate she saw two female figures standing there. One of them detached itself and came to meet her. It was Mrs. Glynne.

âOh, there you are,â she said. âWe wondered, you know. I thought you must have gone out for a walk somewhere and I did so hope you wouldnât overtire yourself. If I had known you had come downstairs and gone out, I would have come with you to show anything there is to show. Not that there is very much.â

âOh, I just wandered around,â said Miss Marple. âThe churchyard, you know, and the church. Iâm always very interested in churches. Sometimes there are very curious epitaphs. Things like that. I make quite a collection of them. I suppose the church here was restored in Victorian times?â

âYes, they did put in some rather ugly pews, I think. You know, good quality wood, and strong and all that, but not very artistic.â

âI hope they didnât take away anything of particular interest.â

âNo, I donât think so. Itâs not really a very old church.â

âThere did not seem to be many tablets or brasses or anything of that kind,â agreed Miss Marple.

âYou are quite interested in ecclesiastical architecture?â

âOh, I donât make a study of it or anything like that, but of course in my own village, St. Mary Mead, things do rather revolve round the church. I mean, they always have. In my young days, that was so. Nowadays of course itâs rather different. Were you brought up in this neighbourhood?â

âOh, not really. We lived not very far away, about thirty miles or so. At Little Herdsley. My father was a retired servicemanâa Major in the Artillery. We came over here occasionally to see my uncleâindeed to see my great-uncle before him. No. Iâve not even been here very much of late years. My other two sisters moved in after my uncleâs death, but at that time I was still abroad with my husband. He only died about four or five years ago.â

âOh, I see.â

âThey were anxious I should come and join them here and really, it seemed the best thing to do. We had lived in India for some years. My husband was still stationed there at the time of his death. It is very difficult nowadays to know where one would wish toâshould I say, put oneâs roots down.â

âYes, indeed. I can quite see that. And you felt, of course, that you had roots here since your family had been here for a long time.â

âYes. Yes, one did feel that. Of course, Iâd always kept up with my sisters, had been to visit them. But things are always very different from what one thinks they will be. I have bought a small cottage near London, near Hampton Court, where I spend a good deal of my time, and I do a little occasional work for one or two charities in London.â

âSo your time is fully occupied. How wise of you.â

âI have felt of late that I should spend more time here, perhaps. Iâve been a little worried about my sisters.â

âTheir health?â suggested Miss Marple. âOne is rather worried nowadays, especially as there is not really anyone competent whom one can employ to look after people as they become rather feebler or have certain ailments. So much rheumatism and arthritis about. One is always so afraid of people falling down in the bath or an accident coming down stairs. Something of that kind.â

âClotilde has always been very strong,â said Mrs. Glynne. âTough, I should describe her. But I am rather worried sometimes about Anthea. She is vague, you know, very vague indeed. And she wanders off sometimesâand doesnât seem to know where she is.â

âYes, it is sad when people worry. There is so much to worry one.â

âI donât really think there is much to worry Anthea.â

âShe worries about income tax, perhaps, money affairs,â suggested Miss Marple.

âNo, no, not that so much butâoh, she worries so much about the garden. She remembers the garden as it used to be, and sheâs very anxious, you know, toâwell, to spend money in putting things right again. Clotilde has had to tell her that really one canât afford that nowadays. But she keeps talking of the hothouses, the peaches that used to be there. The grapesâand all that.â

âAnd the Cherry Pie on the walls?â suggested Miss Marple, remembering a remark.

âFancy your remembering that. Yes. Yes, itâs one of the things one does remember. Such a charming smell, heliotrope. And such a nice name for it, Cherry Pie. One always remembers that. And the grapevine. The little, small, early sweet grapes. Ah well, one must not remember the past too much.â

âAnd the flower borders too, I suppose,â said Miss Marple.

âYes. Yes, Anthea would like to have a big well kept herbaceous border again. Really not feasible now. It is as much as one can do to get local people who will come and mow the lawns every fortnight. Every year one seems to employ a different firm. And Anthea would like pampas grass planted again. And the Mrs. Simpkin pinks. White, you know. All along the stone edge border. And a fig tree that grew just outside the greenhouse. She remembers all these and talks about them.â

âIt must be difficult for you.â

âWell, yes. Arguments, you see, hardly appeal in any way. Clotilde, of course, is very downright about things. She just refuses point-blank and says she doesnât want to hear another word about it.â

âIt is difficult,â said Miss Marple, âto know how to take things. Whether one should be firm. Rather authoritative. Perhaps, even, well, just a littleâa little fierce, you know, or whether one should be sympathetic. Listen to things and perhaps hold out hopes which one knows are not justified. Yes, itâs difficult.â

âBut itâs easier for me because you see I go away again, and then come back now and then to stay. So itâs easy for me to pretend things may be easier soon and that something may be done. But really, the other day when I came home and I found that Anthea had tried to engage a most expensive firm of landscape gardeners to renovate the garden, to build up the greenhouse againâwhich is quite absurd because even if you put vines in they would not bear for another two or three years. Clotilde knew nothing about it and she was extremely angry when she discovered the estimate for this work on Antheaâs desk. She was really quite unkind.â

âSo many things are difficult,â said Miss Marple.

It was a useful phrase which she used often.

âI shall have to go rather early tomorrow morning. I think,â said Miss Marple. âI was making enquiries at the Golden Boar where I understand the coach party assembles tomorrow morning. They are making quite an early start. Nine oâclock, I understand.â

âOh dear. I hope you will not find it too fatiguing.â

âOh, I donât think so. I gather we are going to a place calledânow wait a minute, what was it called?âStirling St. Mary. Something like that. And it does not seem to be very far away. Thereâs an interesting church to see on the way and a castle. In the afternoon there is a quite pleasant garden, not too many acres; but some special flowers. I feel sure that after this very nice rest that I have had here, I shall be quite all right. I understand now that I would have been very tired if I had had these days of climbing up cliffsides and all the rest of it.â

âWell, you must rest this afternoon, so as to be fresh for tomorrow,â said Mrs. Glynne, as they went into the house. âMiss Marple has been to visit the church,â said Mrs. Glynne to Clotilde.

âIâm afraid there is not very much to see,â said Clotilde. âVictorian glass of a most hideous kind, I think myself. No expense spared. Iâm afraid my uncle was partly to blame. He was very pleased with those rather crude reds and blues.â

âVery crude. Very vulgar, I always think,â said Lavinia Glynne.

Miss Marple settled down after lunch to have a nap, and she did not join her hostesses until nearly dinnertime. After dinner a good deal of chat went on until it was bedtime. Miss Marple set the tone in remembrances â¦ Remembrances of her own youth, her early days, places she had visited, travels or tours she had made, occasional people she had known.

She went to bed tired, with a sense of failure. She had learned nothing more, possibly because there was nothing more to learn. A fishing expedition where the fish did not riseâpossibly because there were no fish there. Or it could be that she did not know the right bait to use?

Eleven

ACCIDENT

I

Miss Marpleâs tea was brought at seven thirty the following morning so as to allow her plenty of time to get up and pack her few belongings. She was just closing her small suitcase when there was a rather hurried tap on the door and Clotilde came in, looking upset.

âOh dear, Miss Marple, there is a young man downstairs who has called to see you. Emlyn Price. He is on the tour with you and they sent him here.â

âOf course, I remember him. Yes. Quite young?â

âOh yes. Very modern-looking, and a lot of hair and all that, but he has really come toâwell, to break some bad news to you. There has been, I am sorry to say, an accident.â

âAn accident?â Miss Marple stared. âYou meanâto the coach? There has been an accident on the road? Someone has been hurt?â

âNo. No, it was not the coach. There was no trouble there. It was in the course of the expedition yesterday afternoon. There was a great deal of wind you may remember, though I donât think that had anything to do with it. People strayed about a bit, I think. There is a regular path, but you can also climb up and go across the downs. Both ways lead to the Memorial Tower on the top of Bonaventureâwhere they were all making for. People got separated a bit and I suppose, really, there was no one actually guiding them or looking after them which, perhaps, there ought to have been. People arenât very sure-footed always and the slope overhanging the gorge is very steep. There was a bad fall of stones or rocks which came crashing down the hillside and knocked someone out on the path below.â

âOh dear,â said Miss Marple, âI am sorry. I am most terribly sorry. Who was it who was hurt?â

âA Miss Temple or Tenderdon, I understand.â

âElizabeth Temple,â said Miss Marple. âOh dear, I am sorry. I talked to her a good deal. I sat in the next seat to her on the coach. She is, I believe, a retired schoolmistress, a very well known one.â

âOf course,â said Clotilde, âI know her quite well. She was Headmistress of Fallowfield, quite a famous school. Iâd no idea she was on this tour. She retired as Headmistress, I think a year or two ago, and there is a new, rather young Headmistress there now with rather advanced progressive ideas. But Miss Temple is not very old, really, sheâs about sixty, I should think, and very active, fond of climbing and walking and all the rest of it. This really seems most unfortunate. I hope sheâs not badly hurt. I havenât heard any details yet.â

âThis is quite ready now,â said Miss Marple, snapping down the lid of her suitcase. âI will come down at once and see Mr. Price.â

Clotilde seized the suitcase.

âLet me. I can carry this perfectly. Come down with me, and be careful of the stairs.â

Miss Marple came down. Emlyn Price was waiting for her. His hair was looking even wilder than usual and he was wearing a splendid array of fancy boots and a leather jerkin and brilliant emerald green trousers.

âSuch an unfortunate business,â he said, seizing Miss Marpleâs hand. âI thought Iâd come along myself andâwell, break it to you about the accident. I expect Miss Bradbury-Scott has told you. Itâs Miss Temple. You know. The school dame. I donât know quite what she was doing or what happened, but some stones, or rather boulders, rolled down from above. Itâs rather a precipitous slope and it knocked her out and they had to take her off to hospital with concussion last night. I gather sheâs rather bad. Anyway, the tour for today is cancelled and we are stopping on here tonight.â

âOh dear,â said Miss Marple, âI am sorry. Iâm very sorry.â

âI think theyâve decided not to go on today because they really have to wait and see what the medical report is, so we are proposing to spend one more night here at the Golden Boar and to rearrange the tour a little, so that perhaps we shall miss out altogether going to Grangmering which we were going to do tomorrow, and which is not very interesting really, or so they say. Mrs. Sandbourne has gone off early to the hospital to see how things are this morning. Sheâs going to join us at the Golden Boar for coffee at 11 oâclock. I thought perhaps youâd like to come along and hear the latest news.â

âIâll certainly come along with you,â said Miss Marple. âOf course. At once.â

She turned to say good-bye to Clotilde and Mrs. Glynne who had joined her.

âI must thank you so much,â she said. âYou have been so kind and it has been so delightful to have these two nights here. I feel so rested and everything. Most unfortunate this has occurred.â

âIf you would like to spend another night,â said Mrs. Glynne, âI am sureââ She looked at Clotilde.

It occurred to Miss Marple, who had as sharp a sideways glance as anyone could desire, that Clotilde had a slightly disapproving look. She almost shook her head, though it was such a small movement that it was hardly noticeable. But she was, Miss Marple thought, hushing down the suggestion that Mrs. Glynne was making.

ââ¦ although of course I expect it would be nicer for you to be with the others and toââ

âOh yes, I think it would be better,â said Miss Marple. âI shall know then what the plans are and what to do about things, and perhaps I could be of help in some way. One never knows. So thank you again very much. It will not be difficult, I expect, to get a room at the Golden Boar.â She looked at Emlyn, who said reassuringly, âThatâll be all right. Several rooms have been vacated today, They wonât be full at all. Mrs. Sandbourne, I think, has booked for all the party to stay there tonight, and tomorrow we shall seeâwell, we shall see how this all goes on.â

Good-byes were said again and thanks. Emlyn Price took Miss Marpleâs belongings and started out at a good striding pace.

âItâs really only just round the corner, and then the first street to the left,â he said.

âYes, I passed it yesterday, I think. Poor Miss Temple. I do hope sheâs not badly hurt.â

âI think she is rather,â said Emlyn Price. âOf course, you know what doctors are, and hospital people. They say the same thing always: âas well as can be expected.â Thereâs no local hospitalâthey had to take her to Carristown which is about eight miles away. Anyway, Mrs. Sandbourne will be back with the news by the time weâve fixed you up at the hotel.â

They got there to find the tour assembled in the coffee room and coffee and morning buns and pastries were being served. Mr. and Mrs. Butler were talking at the moment.

âOh, itâs just too, too tragic this happening,â said Mrs. Butler. âJust too upsetting, isnât it? Just when we were all so happy and enjoying everything so much. Poor Miss Temple. And I always thought she was very sure-footed. But there, you know, you never can tell, can you, Henry?â

âNo, indeed,â said Henry. âNo, indeed. I am wondering reallyâyes, our timeâs very short you knowâwhether we hadnât betterâwell, give up this tour at this point here. Not continue with it. It seems to me that thereâs bound to be a bit of difficulty resuming things until we know definitely. If this wasâwellâI mean, if this should be so serious that it could prove fatal, there mightâwellâI mean there might have to be an inquest or something of that kind.â

âOh Henry, donât say dreadful things like that!â

âIâm sure,â said Miss Cooke, âthat you are being a little too pessimistic, Mr. Butler. I am sure that things couldnât be as serious as that.â

In his foreign voice Mr. Caspar said: âBut yes, they are serious. I hear yesterday. When Mrs. Sandbourne talk on telephone to doctor. It is very, very serious. They say she has concussion badâvery bad. A special doctor he is coming to look at her and see if he can operate or if impossible. Yesâit is all very bad.â

âOh dear,â said Miss Lumley. âIf thereâs any doubt, perhaps we ought to go home, Mildred. I must look up the trains, I think.â She turned to Mrs. Butler. âYou see, I have made arrangements about my cats with the neighbours, and if I was delayed a day or two it might make great difficulties for everyone.â

âWell, itâs no good our working ourselves up too much,â said Mrs. Riseley-Porter, in her deep, authoritative voice. âJoanna, put this bun in the wastepaper basket, will you? It is really quite uneatable. Most unpleasant jam. But I donât want to leave it on my plate. It might make for bad feeling.â

Joanna got rid of the bun. She said:

âDo you think it would be all right if Emlyn and I went out for a walk? I mean, just saw something of the town. Itâs not much good our sitting about here, making gloomy remarks, is it? We canât do anything.â

âI think youâd be very wise to go out,â said Miss Cooke.

âYes, you go along,â said Miss Barrow before Mrs. Riseley-Porter could speak.

Miss Cooke and Miss Barrow looked at each other and sighed, shaking their heads.

âThe grass was very slippery,â said Miss Barrow. âI slid once or twice myself, you know, on that very short turf.â

âAnd the stones, too,â said Miss Cooke. âQuite a shower of small stones fell down just as I was turning a corner on the path. Yes, one struck me on the shoulder quite sharply.â

II

Tea, coffee, biscuits and cakes despatched, everyone seemed somewhat dissociated and ill at ease. When a catastrophe has occurred, it is very difficult to know what is the proper way to meet it. Everyone had given their view, had expressed surprise and distress. They were now awaiting news and at the same time had a slight hankering after some form of sightseeing, some interest to carry them through the morning. Lunch would not be served until one oâclock and they really felt that to sit around and repeat their same remarks would be rather a gloomy business.

Miss Cooke and Miss Barrow rose as one woman and explained that it was necessary for them to do a little shopping. One or two things they needed, and they also wished to go to the post office and buy stamps.

âI want to send off one or two postcards. And I want to enquire about postal dues on a letter to China,â said Miss Barrow.

âAnd I want to match some wools,â said Miss Cooke. âAnd also it seemed to me there was rather an interesting building on the other side of the Market Square.â

âI think it would do us all good to get out,â said Miss Barrow.

Colonel and Mrs. Walker also rose, and suggested to Mr. and Mrs. Butler that they too might go out and see what there was to see. Mrs. Butler expressed hopes of an antique shop.

âOnly I donât really mean a real antique shop. More what you would call a junk shop. Sometimes you can pick up some really interesting things there.â

They all trooped out. Emlyn Price had already sidled to the door and disappeared in pursuit of Joanna without troubling to use conversation to explain his departure. Mrs. Riseley-Porter, having made a belated attempt to call her niece back, said she thought that at least the lounge would be rather more pleasant to sit in. Miss Lumley agreedâMr. Caspar escorted the ladies with the air of a foreign equerry.

Professor Wanstead and Miss Marple remained.

âI think myself,â said Professor Wanstead, addressing Miss Marple, âthat it would be pleasant to sit outside the hotel. There is a small terrace giving on the street. If I might persuade you?â

Miss Marple thanked him and rose to her feet. She had hardly exchanged a word so far with Professor Wanstead. He had several learned looking books with him, one of which he was usually perusing. Even in the coach he continued to try and read.

âBut perhaps you too want to shop,â he said. âFor myself, I would prefer to wait somewhere peacefully for the return of Mrs. Sandbourne. It is important, I think, that we should know exactly what we are in for.â

âI quite agree with you, as to that,â said Miss Marple. âI did a certain amount of walking round the town yesterday and I donât feel any necessity to do so again today. Iâd rather wait here in case there is anything I can do to help. Not that I suppose there is, but one never knows.â

They moved together through the hotel door and round the corner to where there was a little square of garden with a raised stone walk close to the wall of the hotel and on which there were various forms of basket chairs. There was no one there at the moment so they sat down. Miss Marple looked thoughtfully at her vis-Ã -vis. At his corrugated and wrinkled face, his bushy brows, his luxuriant head of grey hair. He walked with a slight stoop. He had an interesting face, Miss Marple decided. His voice was dry and caustic, a professional man of some kind, she thought.

âI am not wrong, am I,â said Professor Wanstead. âYou are Miss Jane Marple?â

âYes, I am Jane Marple.â

She was slightly surprised, though for no particular reason. They had not been long enough together for people to be identified by the other travellers. The last two nights she had not been with the rest of the party. It was quite natural.

âI thought so,â said Professor Wanstead, âfrom a description I have had of you.â

âA description of me?â Miss Marple was again slightly surprised.

âYes, I had a description of youââ he paused for a moment. His voice was not exactly lowered, but it lost volume, although she could still hear it quite easily ââfrom Mr. Rafiel.â

âOh,â said Miss Marple, startled. âFrom Mr. Rafiel.â

âYou are surprised?â

âWell, yes, I am rather.â

âI donât know that you should be.â

âI didnât expectââ began Miss Marple and then stopped.

Professor Wanstead did not speak. He was merely sitting, looking at her intently. In a minute or two, thought Miss Marple to herself, he will say to me, âWhat symptoms exactly, dear lady? Any discomfort in swallowing? Any lack of sleep? Digestion in good order?â She was almost sure now that he was a doctor.

âWhen did he describe me to you? That must have beenââ

âYou were going to say some time agoâsome weeks ago. Before his deathâthat is so. He told me that you would be on this tour.â

âAnd he knew that you would be on it tooâthat you were going on it.â

âYou can put it that way,â said Professor Wanstead. âHe said,â he continued, âthat you would be travelling on this tour, that he had in fact arranged for you to be travelling on this tour.â

âIt was very kind of him,â said Miss Marple. âVery kind indeed. I was most surprised when I found heâd booked me. Such a treat. Which I could not have afforded for myself.â

âYes,â said Professor Wanstead. âVery well put.â He nodded his head as one who applauds a good performance by a pupil.

âIt is sad that it has been interrupted in this fashion,â said Miss Marple. âVery sad indeed. When I am sure we were all enjoying ourselves so much.â

âYes,â said Professor Wanstead. âYes, very sad. And unexpected, do you think, or not unexpected?â

âNow what do you mean by that, Professor Wanstead?â

His lips curled in a slight smile as he met her challenging look.

âMr. Rafiel,â he said, âspoke to me about you at some length, Miss Marple. He suggested that I should be on this tour with you. I should in due course almost certainly make your acquaintance, since members in a tour inevitably do make each otherâs acquaintance, though it usually takes a day or two for them to split up, as it were, into possible groupings led by similar tastes or interests. And he further suggested to me that I should, shall we say, keep an eye on you.â

âKeep an eye on me?â said Miss Marple, showing some slight displeasure. âAnd for what reason?â

âI think reasons of protection. He wanted to be quite sure that nothing should happen to you.â

âHappen to me? What should happen to me, I should like to know?â

âPossibly what happened to Miss Elizabeth Temple,â said Professor Wanstead.

Joanna Crawford came round the corner of the hotel. She was carrying a shopping basket. She passed them, nodding a little, she looked towards them with slight curiosity and went on down the street. Professor Wanstead did not speak until she had gone out of sight.

âA nice girl,â he said, âat least I think so. Content at present to be a beast of burden to an autocratic aunt, but I have no doubt will reach the age of rebellion fairly soon.â

âWhat did you mean by what you said just now?â said Miss Marple, uninterested for the moment in Joannaâs possible rebellion.

âThat is a question which, perhaps, owing to what has happened, we shall have to discuss.â

âYou mean because of the accident?â

âYes. If it was an accident.â

âDo you think it wasnât an accident?â

âWell, I think itâs just possible. Thatâs all.â

âI donât of course know anything about it,â said Miss Marple, hesitating.

âNo. You were absent from the scene. You wereâshall I put it this wayâwere you just possibly on duty elsewhere?â

Miss Marple was silent for a moment. She looked at Professor Wanstead once or twice and then she said:

âI donât think I know exactly what you mean.â

âYou are being careful. You are quite right to be careful.â

âI have made it a habit,â said Miss Marple.

âTo be careful?â

âI should not put it exactly like that, but I have made a point of being always ready to disbelieve as well as believe anything that is told to me.â

âYes, and you are quite right too. You donât know anything about me. You know my name from the passenger list of a very agreeable tour visiting castles and historic houses and splendid gardens. Possibly the gardens are what will interest you most.â

âPossibly.â

âThere are other people here too who are interested in gardens.â

âOr profess to be interested in gardens.â

âAh,â said Professor Wanstead. âYou have noticed that.â

He went on. âWell, it was my part, or at any rate to begin with, to observe you, to watch what you were doing, to be near at hand in case there was any possibility ofâwell, we might call it roughlyâdirty work of any kind. But things are slightly altered now. You must make up your mind if I am your enemy or your ally.â

âPerhaps you are right,â said Miss Marple. âYou put it very clearly but you have not given me any information about yourself yet on which to judge. You were a friend, I presume, of the late Mr. Rafiel?â

âNo,â said Professor Wanstead, âI was not a friend of Mr. Rafiel. I had met him once or twice. Once on a committee of a hospital, once at some other public event. I knew about him. He, I gather, also knew about me. If I say to you, Miss Marple, that I am a man of some eminence in my own profession, you may think me a man of bounding conceit.â

âI donât think so,â said Miss Marple. âI should say, if you say that about yourself, that you are probably speaking the truth. You are, perhaps, a medical man.â

âAh. You are perceptive, Miss Marple. Yes, you are quite perceptive. I have a medical degree, but I have a speciality too. I am a pathologist and psychologist. I donât carry credentials about with me. You will probably have to take my word up to a certain point, though I can show you letters addressed to me, and possibly official documents that might convince you. I undertake mainly specialist work in connection with medical jurisprudence. To put it in perfectly plain everyday language, I am interested in the different types of criminal brain. That has been a study of mine for many years. I have written books on the subject, some of them violently disputed, some of them which have attracted adherence to my ideas. I do not do very arduous work nowadays, I spend my time mainly writing up my subject, stressing certain points that have appealed to me. From time to time I come across things that strike me as interesting. Things that I want to study more closely. This I am afraid must seem rather tedious to you.â

âNot at all,â said Miss Marple. âI am hoping perhaps, from what you are saying now, that you will be able to explain to me certain things which Mr. Rafiel did not see fit to explain to me. He asked me to embark upon a certain project but he gave me no useful information on which to work. He left me to accept it and proceed, as it were, completely in the dark. It seemed to me extremely foolish of him to treat the matter in that way.â

âBut you accepted it?â

âI accepted it. I will be quite honest with you. I had a financial incentive.â

âDid that weigh with you?â

Miss Marple was silent for a moment and then she said slowly,

âYou may not believe it, but my answer to that is, âNot really.ââ

âI am not surprised. But your interest was aroused. That is what you are trying to tell me.â

âYes. My interest was aroused. I had known Mr. Rafiel not well, casually, but for a certain period of timeâsome weeks in factâin the West Indies. I see you know about it, more or less.â

âI know that that was where Mr. Rafiel met you and whereâshall I sayâyou two collaborated.â

Miss Marple looked at him rather doubtfully. âOh,â she said, âhe said that, did he?â She shook her head.

âYes, he did,â said Professor Wanstead. âHe said you had a remarkable flair for criminal matters.â

Miss Marple raised her eyebrows as she looked at him.

âAnd I suppose that seems to you most unlikely,â she said. âIt surprises you.â

âI seldom allow myself to be surprised at what happens,â said Professor Wanstead. âMr. Rafiel was a very shrewd and astute man, a good judge of people. He thought that you, too, were a good judge of people.â

âI would not set myself up as a good judge of people,â said Miss Marple. âI would only say that certain people remind me of certain other people that I have known, and that therefore I can presuppose a certain likeness between the way they would act. If you think I know all about what I am supposed to be doing here, you are wrong.â

âBy accident more than design,â said Professor Wanstead, âwe seem to have settled here in a particularly suitable spot for discussion of certain matters. We do not appear to be overlooked, we cannot easily be overheard, we are not near a window or a door and there is no balcony or window overhead. In fact, we can talk.â

âI should appreciate that,â said Miss Marple. âI am stressing the fact that I am myself completely in the dark as to what I am doing or supposed to be doing. I donât know why Mr. Rafiel wanted it that way.â

âI think I can guess that. He wanted you to approach a certain set of facts, of happenings, unbiased by what anyone would tell you first.â

âSo you are not going to tell me anything either?â Miss Marple sounded irritated. âReally!â she said, âthere are limits.â

âYes,â said Professor Wanstead. He smiled suddenly. âI agree with you. We must do away with some of these limits. I am going to tell you certain facts that will make certain things fairly clear to you. You in turn may be able to tell me certain facts.â

âI rather doubt it,â said Miss Marple. âOne or two rather peculiar indications perhaps, but indications are not facts.â

âThereforeââ said Professor Wanstead, and paused.

âFor goodnessâ sake, tell me something,â said Miss Marple.

Twelve

A CONSULTATION

âIâm not going to make a long story of things. Iâll explain quite simply how I came into this matter. I act as confidential adviser from time to time for the Home Office. I am also in touch with certain institutions. There are certain establishments which, in the event of crime, provide board and lodging for certain types of criminal who have been found guilty of certain acts. They remain there at what is termed Her Majestyâs pleasure, sometimes for a definite length of time and in direct association with their age. If they are below a certain age they have to be received in some place of detention specially indicated. You understand that, no doubt.â

âYes, I understand quite well what you mean.â

âUsually I am consulted fairly soon after whatever theâshall we call itâcrime has happened, to judge such matters as treatment, possibilities in the case, prognosis favourable or unfavourable, all the various words. They do not mean much and I will not go into them. But occasionally also I am consulted by a responsible Head of such an institution for a particular reason. In this matter I received a communication from a certain Department which was passed to me through the Home Office. I went to visit the Head of this institution. In fact, the Governor responsible for the prisoners or patients or whatever you like to call them. He was by way of being a friend of mine. A friend of fairly long standing though not one with whom I was on terms of great intimacy. I went down to the institution in question and the Governor laid his troubles before me. They referred to one particular inmate. He was not satisfied about this inmate. He had certain doubts. This was the case of a young man or one who had been a young man, in fact little more than a boy, when he came there. That was now several years ago. As time went on, and after the present Governor had taken up his own residence there (he had not been there at the original arrival of this prisoner), he became worried. Not because he himself was a professional man, but because he was a man of experience of criminal patients and prisoners. To put it quite simply, this had been a boy who from his early youth had been completely unsatisfactory. You can call it by what term you like. A young delinquent, a young thug, a bad lot, a person of diminished responsibility. There are many terms. Some of them fit, some of them donât fit, some of them are merely puzzling. He was a criminal type. That was certain. He had joined gangs, he had beaten up people, he was a thief, he had stolen, he had embezzled, he had taken part in swindles, he had initiated certain frauds. In fact, he was a son who would be any fatherâs despair.â

âOh, I see,â said Miss Marple.

âAnd what do you see, Miss Marple?â

âWell, what I think I see is that you are talking of Mr. Rafielâs son.â

âYou are quite right. I am talking of Mr. Rafielâs son. What do you know about him?â

âNothing,â said Miss Marple. âI only heardâand that was yesterdayâthat Mr. Rafiel had a delinquent, or unsatisfactory, if we like to put it mildly, son. A son with a criminal record. I know very little about him. Was he Mr. Rafielâs only son?â

âYes, he was Mr. Rafielâs only son. But Mr. Rafiel also had two daughters. One of them died when she was fourteen, the elder daughter married quite happily but had no children.â

âVery sad for him.â

âPossibly,â said Professor Wanstead. âOne never knows. His wife died young and I think it possible that her death saddened him very much, though he was never willing to show it. How much he cared for his son and daughters I donât know. He provided for them. He did his best for them. He did his best for his son, but what his feelings were one cannot say. He was not an easy man to read that way. I think his whole life and interest lay in his profession of making money. It was the making of it, like all great financiers, that interested him. Not the actual money which he secured by it. That, as you might say, was sent out like a good servant to earn more money in more interesting and unexpected ways. He enjoyed finance. He loved finance. He thought of very little else.

âI think he did all that was possible for his son. He got him out of scrapes at school, he employed good lawyers to get him released from Court proceedings whenever possible, but the final blow came, perhaps presaged by some early happenings. The boy was taken to Court on a charge of assault against a young girl. It was said to be assault and rape and he suffered a term of imprisonment for it, with some leniency shown because of his youth. But later, a second and really serious charge was brought against him.â

âHe killed a girl,â said Miss Marple. âIs that right? Thatâs what I heard.â

âHe lured a girl away from her home. It was some time before her body was found. She had been strangled. And afterwards her face and head had been disfigured by some heavy stones or rocks, presumably to prevent her identity being made known.â

âNot a very nice business,â said Miss Marple, in her most old-ladylike tone.

Professor Wanstead looked at her for a moment or two.

âYou describe it that way?â

âIt is how it seems to me,â said Miss Marple. âI donât like that sort of thing. I never have. If you expect me to feel sympathy, regret, urge an unhappy childhood, blame bad environment; if you expect me in fact to weep over him, this young murderer of yours, I do not feel inclined so to do. I do not like evil beings who do evil things.â

âI am delighted to hear it,â said Professor Wanstead. âWhat I suffer in the course of my profession from people weeping and gnashing their teeth, and blaming everything on some happening in the past, you would hardly believe. If people knew the bad environments that people have had, the unkindness, the difficulties of their lives and the fact that nevertheless they can come through unscathed, I donât think they would so often take the opposite point of view. The misfits are to be pitied, yes, they are to be pitied if I may say so for the genes with which they are born and over which they have no control themselves. I pity epileptics in the same way. If you know what genes areââ

âI know, more or less,â said Miss Marple. âItâs common knowledge nowadays, though naturally I have no exact chemical or technical knowledge.â

âThe Governor, a man of experience, told me exactly why he was so anxious to have my verdict. He had felt increasingly in his experience of this particular inmate that, in plain words, the boy was not a killer. He didnât think he was the type of a killer, he was like no killer he had ever seen before, he was of the opinion that the boy was the kind of criminal type who would never go straight no matter what treatment was given to him, would never reform himself; and for whom nothing in one sense of the word could be done, but at the same time he felt increasingly certain that the verdict upon him had been a wrong one. He did not believe that the boy had killed a girl, first strangled her and then disfigured her after rolling her body into a ditch. He just couldnât bring himself to believe it. Heâd looked over the facts of the case, which seemed to be fully proved. This boy had known the girl, he had been seen with her on several different occasions before the crime. They had presumably slept together and there were other points. His car had been seen in the neighbourhood. He himself had been recognized and all the rest of it. A perfectly fair case. But my friend was unhappy about it, he said. He was a man who had a very strong feeling for justice. He wanted a different opinion. He wanted, in fact, not the police side which he knew, he wanted a professional medical view. That was my field, he said. My line of country entirely. He wanted me to see this young man and talk with him, visit him, make a professional appraisal of him and give him my opinion.â

âVery interesting,â said Miss Marple. âYes, I call that very interesting. After all, your friendâI mean your Governorâwas a man of experience, a man who loved justice. He was a man whom youâd be willing to listen to. Presumably then, you did listen to him.â

âYes,â said Professor Wanstead, âI was deeply interested. I saw the subject, as I will call him, I approached him from several different attitudes. I talked to him, I discussed various changes likely to occur in the law. I told him it might be possible to bring down a lawyer, a Queenâs Counsel, to see what points there might be in his favour, and other things. I approached him as a friend but also as an enemy so that I could see how he responded to different approaches, and I also made a good many physical tests, such as we use very frequently nowadays. I will not go into those with you because they are wholly technical.â

âThen what did you think in the end?â

âI thought,â said Professor Wanstead, âI thought my friend was likely to be right. I did not think that Michael Rafiel was a murderer.â

âWhat about the earlier case you mentioned?â

âThat told against him, of course. Not in the juryâs mind, because of course they did not hear about that until after the judgeâs summing up, but certainly in the judgeâs mind. It told against him, but I made a few enquiries myself afterwards. He had assaulted a girl. He had conceivably raped her, but he had not attempted to strangle her and in my opinionâI have seen a great many cases which come before the Assizesâit seemed to me highly unlikely that there was a very definite case of rape. Girls, you must remember, are far more ready to be raped nowadays than they used to be. Their mothers insist, very often, that they should call it rape. The girl in question had had several boyfriends who had gone further than friendship. I did not think it counted very greatly as evidence against him. The actual murder caseâyes, that was undoubtedly murderâbut I continued to feel by all tests, physical tests, mental tests, psychological tests, none of them accorded with this particular crime.â

âThen what did you do?â

âI communicated with Mr. Rafiel. I told him that I would like an interview with him on a certain matter concerning his son. I went to him. I told him what I thought, what the Governor thought, that we had no evidence, that there were no grounds of appeal, at present, but that we both believed that a miscarriage of justice had been committed. I said I thought possibly an enquiry might be held, it might be an expensive business, it might bring out certain facts that could be laid before the Home Office, it might be successful, it might not. There might be something there, some evidence if you looked for it. I said it would be expensive to look for it but I presumed that would make no difference to anyone in his position. I had realized by that time that he was a sick man, a very ill man. He told me so himself. He told me that he had been in expectation of an early death, that heâd been warned two years ago that death could not be delayed for what they first thought was about a year, but later they realized that he would last rather longer because of his unusual physical strength. I asked him what he felt about his son.â

âAnd what did he feel about his son?â said Miss Marple.

âAh, you want to know that. So did I. He was, I think, extremely honest with me even ifââ

ââeven if rather ruthless?â said Miss Marple.

âYes, Miss Marple. You are using the right word. He was a ruthless man, but he was a just man and an honest man. He said, âIâve known what my son was like for many years. I have not tried to change him because I donât believe that anyone could change him. He is made a certain way. He is crooked. Heâs a bad lot. Heâll always be in trouble. Heâs dishonest. Nobody, nothing could make him go straight. I am well assured of that. I have in a sense washed my hands of him. Though not legally or outwardly; he has always had money if he required it. Help legal or otherwise if he gets into trouble. I have done always what I could do. Well, let us say if I had a son who was a spastic who was sick, who was epileptic, I would do what I could for him. If you have a son who is sick morally, shall we say, and for whom there is no cure, I have done what I could also. No more and no less. What can I do for him now?â I told him that it depended what he wanted to do. âThereâs no difficulty about that,â he said. âI am handicapped but I can see quite clearly what I want to do. I want to get him vindicated. I want to get him released from confinement. I want to get him free to continue to lead his own life as best he can lead it. If he must lead it in further dishonesties, then he must lead it that way. I will leave provision for him, to do for him everything that can be done. I donât want him suffering, imprisoned, cut off from his life because of a perfectly natural and unfortunate mistake. If somebody else, some other man killed that girl, I want the fact brought to light and recognized. I want justice for Michael. But I am handicapped. I am a very ill man. My time is measured now not in years or months but in weeks.â

âLawyers, I suggestedâI know a firmâHe cut me short. âYour lawyers will be useless. You can employ them but they will be useless. I must arrange what I can arrange in such a limited time.â He offered me a large fee to undertake the search for the truth and to undertake everything possible with no expense spared. âI can do next to nothing myself. Death may come at any moment. I empower you as my chief help, and to assist you at my request I will try to find a certain person.â He wrote down a name for me. Miss Jane Marple. He said âI donât want to give you her address. I want you to meet her in surroundings of my own choosing,â and he then told me of this tour, this charming, harmless, innocent tour of historic houses, castles and gardens. He would provide me with a reservation on it ahead for a certain date. âMiss Jane Marple,â he said, âwill also be on that tour. You will meet her there, you will encounter her casually, and thus it will be seen clearly to be a casual meeting.â

âI was to choose my own time and moment to make myself known to you if I thought that that would be the better way. You have already asked me if I or my friend, the Governor, had any reason to suspect or know of any other person who might have been guilty of the murder. My friend the Governor certainly suggested nothing of the kind, and he had already taken up the matter with the police officer who had been in charge of the case. A most reliable detective-superintendent with very good experience in these matters.â

âNo other man was suggested? No other friend of the girlâs? No other former friend who might have been supplanted?â

âThere was nothing of that kind to find. I asked him to tell me a little about you. He did not however consent to do so. He told me you were elderly. He told me that you were a person who knew about people. He told me one other thing.â He paused.

âWhatâs the other thing?â said Miss Marple. âI have some natural curiosity, you know. I really canât think of any other advantage I conceivably could have. I am slightly deaf. My eyesight is not quite as good as it used to be. I cannot really think that I have any advantages beyond the fact that I may, I suppose, seem rather foolish and simple, and am in fact, what used to be called in rather earlier days an âold pussy.â I am an old pussy. Is that the sort of thing he said?â

âNo,â said Professor Wanstead. âWhat he said was he thought you had a very fine sense of evil.â

âOh,â said Miss Marple. She was taken aback.

Professor Wanstead was watching her.

âWould you say that was true?â he said.

Miss Marple was quiet for quite a long time. At last she said,

âPerhaps it is. Yes, perhaps. I have at several different times in my life been apprehensive, have recognized that there was evil in the neighbourhood, the surroundings, that the environment of someone who was evil was near me, connected with what was happening.â

She looked at him suddenly and smiled.

âItâs rather, you know,â she said, âlike being born with a very keen sense of smell. You can smell a leak of gas when other people canât do so. You can distinguish one perfume from another very easily. I had an aunt once,â continued Miss Marple thoughtfully, âwho said she could smell when people told a lie. She said there was quite a distinctive odour came to her. Their noses twitched, she said, and then the smell came. I donât know if it was true or not, butâwell, on several occasions she was quite remarkable. She said to my uncle once, âDonât, Jack, engage that young man you were talking to this morning. He was telling you lies the whole time he was talking.â That turned out to be quite true.â

âA sense of evil,â said Professor Wanstead. âWell, if you do sense evil, tell me. I shall be glad to know. I donât think I have a particular sense of evil myself. Ill health, yes, but notânot evil up here.â He tapped his forehead.

âIâd better tell you briefly how I came into things now,â said Miss Marple. âMr. Rafiel, as you know, died. His lawyers asked me to come and see them, apprised me of his proposition. I received a letter from him which explained nothing. After that I heard nothing more for some little time. Then I got a letter from the company who run these tours saying that Mr. Rafiel before his death had made a reservation for me knowing that I should enjoy a trip very much, and wanting to give it me as a surprise present. I was very astonished but took it as an indication of the first step that I was to undertake. I was to go on this tour and presumably in the course of the tour some other indication or hint or clue or direction would come to me. I think it did. Yesterday, no, the day before, I was received on my arrival here by three ladies who live at an old manor house here and who very kindly extended an invitation to me. They had heard from Mr. Rafiel, they said, who had written some time before his death, saying that a very old friend of his would be coming on this tour and would they be kind enough to put her up for two or three days as he thought she was not fit to attempt the particular ascent of this rather difficult climb up the headland to where there was a memorial tower which was the principal event of yesterdayâs tour.â

âAnd you took that also as an indication of what you were to do?â

âOf course,â said Miss Marple. âThere can be no other reason for it. He was not a man to shower benefits for nothing, out of compassion for an old lady who wasnât good at walking up hills. No. He wanted me to go there.â

âAnd you went there? And what then?â

âNothing,â said Miss Marple. âThree sisters.â

âThree weird sisters?â

âThey ought to have been,â said Miss Marple, âbut I donât think they were. They didnât seem to be anyway. I donât know yet. I suppose they may have beenâthey may be, I mean. They seem ordinary enough. They didnât belong to this house. It had belonged to an uncle of theirs and theyâd come here to live some years ago. They are in rather poor circumstances, they are amiable, not particularly interesting. All slightly different in type. They do not appear to have been well acquainted with Mr. Rafiel. Any conversation I have had with them appears to yield nothing.â

âSo you learnt nothing during your stay?â

âI learnt the facts of the case youâve just told me. Not from them. From an elderly servant, who started her reminiscences dating back to the time of the uncle. She knew of Mr. Rafiel only as a name. But she was eloquent on the theme of the murder: it had all started with the visit here of a son of Mr. Rafielâs who was a bad lot, of how the girl had fallen in love with him and that heâd strangled the girl, and how sad and tragic and terrible it all was. âWith bells on,â as you might say,â said Miss Marple, using a phrase of her youth. âPlenty of exaggeration, but it was a nasty story, and she seemed to believe that the police view was that this hadnât been his only murderââ

âIt didnât seem to you to connect up with the three weird sisters?â

âNo, only that theyâd been the guardians of the girlâand had loved her dearly. No more than that.â

âThey might know somethingâsomething about another man?â

âYesâthatâs what we want, isnât it? The other manâa man of brutality, who wouldnât hesitate to bash in a girlâs head after heâd killed her. The kind of man who could be driven frantic with jealousy. There are men like that.â

âNo other curious things happened at The Old Manor?â

âNot really. One of the sisters, the youngest I think, kept talking about the garden. She sounded as though she was a very keen gardener, but she couldnât be because she didnât know the names of half the things. I laid a trap or two for her, mentioning special rare shrubs and saying did she know it? and yes, she said, wasnât it a wonderful plant? I said it was not very hardy and she agreed. But she didnât know anything about plants. That reminds meââ

âReminds you of what?â

âWell, youâll think Iâm just silly about gardens and plants, but I mean one does know things about them. I mean, I know a few things about birds and I know some things about gardens.â

âAnd I gather that itâs not birds but gardens that are troubling you.â

âYes. Have you noticed two middle-aged women on this tour? Miss Barrow and Miss Cooke.â

âYes. Iâve noticed them. Pair of middle-aged spinsters travelling together.â

âThatâs right. Well, Iâve found out something odd about Miss Cooke. That is her name, isnât it? I mean itâs her name on the tour.â

âWhyâhas she got another name?â

âI think so. Sheâs the same person who visited meâI wonât say visited me exactly, but she was outside my garden fence in St. Mary Mead, the village where I live. She expressed pleasure at my garden and talked about gardening with me. Told me she was living in the village and working in somebodyâs garden, whoâd moved into a new house there. I rather think,â said Miss Marple, âyes, I rather think that the whole thing was lies. There again, she knew nothing about gardening. She pretended to but it wasnât true.â

âWhy do you think she came there?â

âIâd no idea at the time. She said her name was Bartlettâand the name of the woman she said she was living with began with âH,â though I canât remember it for the moment. Her hair was not only differently done but it was a different colour and her clothes were of a different style. I didnât recognize her at first on this trip. Just wondered why her face was vaguely familiar. And then suddenly it came to me. Because of the dyed hair. I said where I had seen her before. She admitted that sheâd been thereâbut pretended that she, too, hadnât recognized me. All lies.â

âAnd whatâs your opinion about all that?â

âWell, one thing certainlyâMiss Cooke (to give her her present name) came to St. Mary Mead just to have a look at meâso that sheâd be quite sure to be able to recognize me when we met againââ

âAnd why was that felt to be necessary?â

âI donât know. There are two possibilities. Iâm not sure that I like one of them very much.â

âI donât know,â said Professor Wanstead, âthat I like it very much either.â

They were both silent for a minute or two, and then Professor Wanstead saidâ

âI donât like what happened to Elizabeth Temple. Youâve talked to her during this trip?â

âYes, I have. When sheâs better Iâd like to talk to her againâshe could tell meâusâthings about the girl who was murdered. She spoke to me of this girlâwho had been at her school, who had been going to marry Mr. Rafielâs sonâbut didnât marry him. Instead she died. I asked how or why she diedâand she answered with the word âLove.â I took it as meaning a suicideâbut it was murder. Murder through jealousy would fit. Another man. Some other man weâve got to find. Miss Temple may be able to tell us who he was.â

âNo other sinister possibilities?â

âI think, really, it is casual information we need. I see no reason to believe that there is any sinister suggestion in any of the coach passengersâor any sinister suggestion about the people living in The Old Manor House. But one of those three sisters may have known or remembered something that the girl or Michael once said. Clotilde used to take the girl abroad. Therefore, she may know of something that occurred on some foreign trip perhaps. Something that the girl said or mentioned or did on some trip. Some man that the girl met. Something which has nothing to do with The Old Manor House here. It is difficult because only by talking, by casual information, can you get any clue. The second sister, Mrs. Glynne, married fairly early, has spent time, I gather, in India and in Africa. She may have heard of something through her husband, or through her husbandâs relations, through various things that are unconnected with The Old Manor House here although she has visited it from time to time. She knew the murdered girl presumably, but I should think she knew her much less well than the other two. But that does not mean that she may not know some significant facts about the girl. The third sister is more scatty, more localized, does not seem to have known the girl as well. But still, she too may have information about possible loversâor boyfriendsâseen the girl with an unknown man. Thatâs her, by the way, passing the hotel now.â

Miss Marple, however occupied by her tÃªte-Ã -tÃªte, had not relinquished the habits of a lifetime. A public thoroughfare was always to her an observation post. All the passersby, either loitering or hurrying, had been noticed automatically.

âAnthea Bradbury-Scottâthe one with the big parcel. Sheâs going to the post office, I suppose. Itâs just round the corner, isnât it?â

âLooks a bit daft to me,â said Professor Wanstead, âall that floating hairâgrey hair tooâa kind of Ophelia of fifty.â

âI thought of Ophelia too, when I first saw her. Oh dear, I wish I knew what I ought to do next. Stay here at the Golden Boar for a day or two, or go on with the coach tour. Itâs like looking for a needle in a haystack. If you stick your fingers in it long enough, you ought to come up with somethingâeven if one does get pricked in the process.â

Thirteen

BLACK AND RED CHECK

I

Mrs. Sandbourne returned just as the party was sitting down to lunch. Her news was not good. Miss Temple was still unconscious. She certainly could not be moved for several days.

Having given the bulletin, Mrs. Sandbourne turned the conversation to practical matters. She produced suitable timetables of trains for those who wished to return to London and proposed suitable plans for the resumption of the tour on the morrow or the next day. She had a list of suitable short expeditions in the near neighbourhood for this afternoonâsmall groups in hired cars.

Professor Wanstead drew Miss Marple aside as they went out of the dining roomâ

âYou may want to rest this afternoon. If not, I will call for you here in an hourâs time. There is an interesting church you might care to seeâ?â

âThat would be very nice,â said Miss Marple.

II

Miss Marple sat quite still in the car that had come to fetch her. Professor Wanstead had called for her at the time he had said.

âI thought you might enjoy seeing this particular church. And a very pretty village, too,â he explained. âThereâs no reason really why one should not enjoy the local sights when one can.â

âItâs very kind of you, Iâm sure,â Miss Marple had said.

She had looked at him with that slightly fluttery gaze of hers.

âVery kind,â she said. âIt just seemsâwell, I donât want to say it seems heartless, but well, you know what I mean.â

âMy dear lady, Miss Temple is not an old friend of yours or anything like that. Sad as this accident has been.â

âWell,â said Miss Marple again, âthis is very kind of you.â

Professor Wanstead had opened the door of the car and Miss Marple got into it. It was, she presumed, a hired car. A kindly thought to take an elderly lady to see one of the sights of the neighbourhood. He might have taken somebody younger, more interesting and certainly better looking. Miss Marple looked at him thoughtfully once or twice as they drove through the village. He was not looking at her. He was gazing out of his own window.

When they had left the village behind and were on a second class country road twisting round the hillside, he turned his head and said to her,

âWe are not going to a church, I am afraid.â

âNo,â said Miss Marple, âI thought perhaps we werenât.â

âYes, the idea would have come to you.â

âWhere are we going, may I ask?â

âWe are going to a hospital, in Carristown.â

âAh yes, that was where Miss Temple was taken?â

It was a question, though it hardly needed to be one.

âYes,â he said. âMrs. Sandbourne saw her and brought me back a letter from the Hospital Authorities. I have just finished talking to them on the telephone.â

âIs she going on well?â

âNo. Not going on very well.â

âI see. At leastâI hope I donât see,â said Miss Marple.

âHer recovery is very problematical but there is nothing that can be done. She may not recover consciousness again. On the other hand she may have a few lucid intervals.â

âAnd you are taking me there? Why? I am not a friend of hers, you know. I only just met her for the first time on this trip.â

âYes, I realize that. Iâm taking you there because in one of the lucid intervals she has had, she asked for you.â

âI see,â said Miss Marple. âI wonder why she should ask for me, why she should have thought that Iâthat I could be useful in any way to her, or do anything. She is a woman of perception. In her way, you know, a great woman. As Headmistress of Fallowfield she occupied a prominent position in the educational world.â

âThe best girlsâ school there is, I suppose?â

âYes. She was a great personality. She was herself a woman of considerable scholarship. Mathematics were her speciality, but she was an âall roundââwhat I should call an educator. Was interested in education, what girls were fitted for, how to encourage them. Oh, many other things. It is sad and very cruel if she dies,â said Miss Marple. âIt will seem such a waste of a life. Although she had retired from her Headmistresship she still exercised a lot of power. This accidentââ She stopped. âPerhaps you do not want us to discuss the accident?â

âI think it is better that we should do so. A big boulder crashed down the hillside. It has been known to happen before though only at very long divided intervals of time. However, somebody came and spoke to me about it,â said Professor Wanstead.

âCame and spoke to you about the accident? Who was it?â

âThe two young people. Joanna Crawford and Emlyn Price.â

âWhat did they say?â

âJoanna told me that she had the impression there was someone on the hillside. Rather high up. She and Emlyn were climbing up from the lower main path, following a rough track that wound round the curve of the hill. As they turned a corner she definitely saw, outlined against the skyline, a man or a woman who was trying to roll a big boulder forward along the ground. The boulder was rockingâand finally it started to roll, at first slowly and then gathering speed down the hillside. Miss Temple was walking along the main path below, and had come to a point just underneath it when the boulder hit her. If it was done deliberately it might not, of course, have succeeded; it might have missed herâbut it did succeed. If what was being attempted was a deliberate attack on the woman walking below it succeeded only too well.â

âWas it a man or a woman they saw?â asked Miss Marple.

âUnfortunately, Joanna Crawford could not say. Whoever it was, was wearing jeans or trousers, and had on a lurid polo-neck pullover in red and black checks. The figure turned and moved out of sight almost immediately. She is inclined to think it was a man but cannot be certain.â

âAnd she thinks, or you think, that it was a deliberate attempt on Miss Templeâs life?â

âThe more she mulls it over, the more she thinks that that was exactly what it was. The boy agrees.â

âYou have no idea who it might have been?â

âNo idea whatever. No more have they. It might be one of our fellow travellers, someone who went for a stroll that afternoon. It might be someone completely unknown who knew that the coach was making a halt here and chose this place to make an attack on one of the passengers. Some youthful lover of violence for violenceâs sake. Or it might have been an enemy.â

âIt seems very melodramatic if one says âa secret enemy,ââ said Miss Marple.

âYes, it does. Who would want to kill a retired and respected Headmistress? That is a question we want answered. It is possible, faintly possible that Miss Temple herself might be able to tell us. She might have recognized the figure above her or she might more likely have known of someone who bore her ill will for some special reason.â

âIt still seems unlikely.â

âI agree with you,â said Professor Wanstead. âShe seems a totally unlikely person to be a fit victim of attack, but yet when one reflects, a Headmistress knows a great many people. A great many people, shall we put it this way, have passed through her hands.â

âA lot of girls you mean have passed through her hands.â

âYes. Yes, that is what I meant. Girls and their families. A Headmistress must have knowledge of many things. Romances, for instance, that girls might indulge in, unknown to their parents. It happens, you know. It happens very often. Especially in the last ten or twenty years. Girls are said to mature earlier. That is physically true, through in a deeper sense of the word, they mature late. They remain childish longer. Childish in the clothes they like to wear, childish with their floating hair. Even their mini skirts represent a worship of childishness. Their Baby Doll nightdresses, their gymslips and shortsâall childrenâs fashions. They wish not to become adultânot to have to accept our kind of responsibility. And yet like all children, they want to be thought grown up, and free to do what they think are grown up things. And that leads sometimes to tragedy and sometimes to the aftermath of tragedy.â

âAre you thinking of some particular case?â

âNo. No, not really. Iâm only thinkingâwell, shall we say letting possibilities pass through my mind. I cannot believe that Elizabeth Temple had a personal enemy. An enemy ruthless enough to wish to take an opportunity of killing her. What I do thinkââ he looked at Miss Marple, ââwould you like to make a suggestion?â

âOf a possibility? Well, I think I know or guess what you are suggesting. You are suggesting that Miss Temple knew something, knew some fact or had some knowledge that would be inconvenient or even dangerous to somebody if it was known.â

âYes, I do feel exactly that.â

âIn that case,â said Miss Marple, âit seems indicated that there is someone on our coach tour who recognized Miss Temple or knew who she was, but who perhaps after the passage of some years was not remembered or might even not have been recognized by Miss Temple. It seems to throw it back on our passengers, does it not?â She paused. âThat pullover you mentionedâred and black checks, you said?â

âOh yes? The pulloverââ He looked at her curiously. âWhat was it that struck you about that?â

âIt was very noticeable,â said Miss Marple. âThat is what your words led me to infer. It was very mentionable. So much so that the girl Joanna mentioned it specifically.â

âYes. And what does that suggest to you?â

âThe trailing of flags,â said Miss Marple thoughtfully. âSomething that will be seen, remembered, observed, recognized.â

âYes.â Professor Wanstead looked at her with encouragement.

âWhen you describe a person you have seen, seen not close at hand but from a distance, the first thing you will describe will be their clothes. Not their faces, not their walk, not their hands, not their feet. A scarlet tam-oâ-shanter, a purple cloak, a bizarre leather jacket, a pullover of brilliant reds and blacks. Something very recognizable, very noticeable. The object of it being that when that person removes that garment, gets rid of it, sends it by post in a parcel to some address, say, about a hundred miles away, or thrusts it in a rubbish bin in a city or burns it or tears it up or destroys it, she or he will be the one person modestly and rather drably attired who will not be suspected or looked at or thought of. It must have been meant, that scarlet and black check jersey. Meant so that it will be recognized again though actually it will never again be seen on that particular person.â

âA very sound idea,â said Professor Wanstead. âAs I have told you,â continued the Professor, âFallowfield is situated not very far from here. Sixteen miles, I think. So this is Elizabeth Templeâs part of the world, a part she knows well with people in it that she also might know well.â

âYes. It widens the possibilities,â said Miss Marple. âI agree with you,â she said presently, âthat the attacker is more likely to have been a man than a woman. That boulder, if it was done with intent, was sent on its course very accurately. Accuracy is more a male quality than a female one. On the other hand there might easily have been someone on our coach, or possibly in the neighbourhood, who saw Miss Temple in the street, a former pupil of hers in past years. Someone whom she herself might not recognize after a period of time. But the girl or woman would have recognized her, because a Headmaster or Headmistress of over sixty is not unlike the same Headmaster or Headmistress at the age of fifty. She is recognizable. Some woman who recognized her former mistress and also knew that her mistress knew something damaging about her. Someone who might in some way prove a danger to her.â She sighed. âI myself do not know this part of the world at all. Have you any particular knowledge of it?â

âNo,â said Professor Wanstead. âI could not claim a personal knowledge of this part of the country. I know something, however, of various things that have happened in this part of the world entirely because of what you have told me. If it had not been for my acquaintanceship with you and the things you have told me I could have been more at sea than I am.

âWhat are you yourself actually doing here? You do not know. Yet you were sent here. It was deliberately arranged by Rafiel that you should come here, that you should take this coach tour, that you and I should meet. There have been other places where we have stopped or through which we have passed, but special arrangements were made so that you should actually stay for a couple of nights here. You were put up with former friends of his who would not have refused any request he made. Was there a reason for that?â

âSo that I could learn certain facts that I had to know,â said Miss Marple.

âA series of murders that took place a good many years ago?â Professor Wanstead looked doubtful. âThere is nothing unusual in that. You can say the same of many places in England and Wales. These things seem always to go in a series. First a girl found assaulted and murdered. Then another girl not very far away. Then something of the same kind perhaps twenty miles away. The same pattern of death.

âTwo girls were reported missing from Jocelyn St. Mary itself, the one that we have been discussing whose body was found six months later, many miles away and who was last seen in the company of Michael Rafielââ

âAnd the other?â

âA girl called Nora Broad. Not-a âquiet girl with no boyfriends.â Possibly with one boyfriend too many. Her body was never found. It will beâone day. There have been cases when twenty years have passed,â said Wanstead. He slowed down: âWe have arrived. This is Carristown, and here is the Hospital.â

Shepherded by Professor Wanstead, Miss Marple entered. The Professor was obviously expected. He was ushered into a small room where a woman rose from a desk.

âOh yes,â she said, âProfessor Wanstead. Andâerâthis isâerââ She hesitated slightly.

âMiss Jane Marple,â said Professor Wanstead. âI talked to Sister Barker on the telephone.â

âOh yes. Sister Barker said that she would be accompanying you.â

âHow is Miss Temple?â

âMuch the same, I think. I am afraid there is not much improvement to report.â She rose. âI will take you to Sister Barker.â

Sister Barker was a tall, thin woman. She had a low, decisive voice and dark grey eyes that had a habit of looking at you and looking away almost immediately, leaving you with the feeling that you had been inspected in a very short space of time, and judgment pronounced upon you.

âI donât know what arrangements you have in mind,â said Professor Wanstead.

âWell, I had better tell Miss Marple just what we have arranged. First I must make it clear to you that the patient, Miss Temple, is still in a coma with very rare intervals. She appears to come to occasionally, to recognize her surroundings and to be able to say a few words. But there is nothing one can do to stimulate her. It has to be left to the utmost patience. I expect Professor Wanstead has already told you that in one of her intervals of consciousness she uttered quite distinctly the words âMiss Jane Marple.â And then: âI want to speak to her. Miss Jane Marple.â After that she relapsed into unconsciousness. Doctor thought it advisable to get in touch with the other occupants of the coach. Professor Wanstead came to see us and explained various matters and said he would bring you over. I am afraid that all we can ask you to do is to sit in the private ward where Miss Temple is, and perhaps be ready to make a note of any words she should say, if she does regain consciousness. I am afraid the prognosis is not very helpful. To be quite frank, which is better I think, since you are not a near relative and are unlikely to be disturbed by this information, Doctor thinks that she is sinking fast, that she may die without recovering consciousness. There is nothing one can do to relieve the concussion. It is important that someone should hear what she says and Doctor thinks it advisable that she should not see too many people round her if she regains consciousness. If Miss Marple is not worried at the thought of sitting there alone, there will be a nurse in the room, though not obviously so. That is, she will not be noticed from the bed, and will not move unless sheâs asked for. She will sit in a corner of the room shielded by a screen.â She added, âWe have a police official there also, ready to take down anything. The Doctor thinks it advisable that he also should not be noticed by Miss Temple. One person alone, and that possibly a person she expects to see, will not alarm her or make her lose knowledge of what she wants to say to you. I hope this will not be too difficult a thing to ask you?â

âOh no,â said Miss Marple, âIâm quite prepared to do that. I have a small notebook with me and a Biro pen that will not be in evidence. I can remember things by heart for a very short time, so I need not appear to be obviously taking notes of what she says. You can trust my memory and I am not deafânot deaf in the real sense of the word. I donât think my hearing is quite as good as it used to be, but if I am sitting near a bedside, I ought to be able to hear anything she says quite easily even if it is whispered. I am used to sick people. I have had a good deal to do with them in my time.â

Again the lightning glance of Sister Barker went over Miss Marple. This time a faint inclination of the head showed satisfaction.

âIt is kind of you,â she said, âand I am sure that if there is any help you can give, we can rely on you to give it. If Professor Wanstead likes to sit in the waiting room downstairs, we can call him at any moment if it should be necessary. Now, Miss Marple, perhaps you will accompany me.â

Miss Marple followed Sister along a passage and into a small well appointed single room. In the bed there, in a dimly-lighted room since the blinds were half drawn, lay Elizabeth Temple. She lay there like a statue, yet she did not give the impression of being asleep. Her breath came uncertainly in slight gasps. Sister Barker bent to examine her patient, motioned Miss Marple into a chair beside the bed. She then crossed the room to the door again. A young man with a notebook in his hand came from behind the screen there.

âDoctorâs orders, Mr. Reckitt,â said Sister Barker.

A nurse also appeared. She had been sitting in the opposite corner of the room.

âCall me if necessary, Nurse Edmonds,â said Sister Barker, âand get Miss Marple anything she may need.â

Miss Marple loosened her coat. The room was warm. The nurse approached and took it from her. Then she retired to her former position, Miss Marple sat down in the chair. She looked at Elizabeth Temple thinking, as she had thought before when looking at her in the coach, what a fine shaped head she had. Her grey hair drawn back from it, fitted her face in a perfect cap-like effect. A handsome woman, and a woman of personality. Yes, a thousand pities, Miss Marple thought, a thousand pities if the world was going to lose Elizabeth Temple.

Miss Marple eased the cushion at her back, moved the chair a fraction of an inch and sat quietly to wait. Whether to wait in vain or to some point, she had no idea. Time passed. Ten minutes, twenty minutes, half an hour, thirty-five minutes. Then suddenly, quite unexpectedly as it were, a voice came. Low, but distinct, slightly husky. None of the resonance it had once held. âMiss Marple.â

Elizabeth Templeâs eyes were open now. They were looking at Miss Marple. They looked competent, perfectly sensible. She was studying the face of the woman who was sitting by her bed, studying her without any sign of emotion, of surprise. Only, one would say, of scrutiny. Fully conscious scrutiny. And the voice spoke again.

âMiss Marple. You are Jane Marple?â

âThat is right. Yes,â said Miss Marple. âJane Marple.â

âHenry often spoke of you. He said things about you.â

The voice stopped. Miss Marple said with a slight query in her voice,

âHenry?â

âHenry Clithering, an old friend of mineâvery old friend.â

âAn old friend of mine too,â said Miss Marple. âHenry Clithering.â

Her mind went back to the many years she had known him, Sir Henry Clithering, the things he had said to her, the assistance he had asked from her sometimes, and the assistance that she had asked from him. A very old friend.

âI remembered your name. On the passenger list. I thought it must be you. You could help. Thatâs what heâHenry, yesâwould say if he were here. You might be able to help. To find out. Itâs important. Very important althoughâitâs a long time ago nowâaâlongâtimeâago.â

Her voice faltered a little, her eyes half closed. Nurse got up, came across the room, picked up a small glass and held it to Elizabeth Templeâs lips. Miss Temple took a sip, nodded her head dismissively. Nurse put down the glass and went back to her chair.

âIf I can help, I will,â said Miss Marple. She asked no further questions.

Miss Temple said, âGood,â and after a minute or two, again, âGood.â

For two or three minutes she lay with her eyes closed. She might have been asleep or unconscious. Then her eyes opened again suddenly.

âWhich,â she said, âwhich of them? Thatâs what one has got to know. Do you know what I am talking about?â

âI think so. A girl who diedâNora Broad?â A frown came quickly to Elizabeth Templeâs forehead.

âNo, no, no. The other girl. Verity Hunt.â

There was a pause and then, âJane Marple. Youâre oldâolder than when he talked about you. Youâre older, but you can still find out things, canât you?â

Her voice became slightly higher, more insistent.

âYou can, canât you? Say you can. Iâve not much time. I know that. I know it quite well. One of them, but which? Find out. Henry would have said you can. It may be dangerous for youâbut youâll find out, wonât you?â

âWith Godâs help, I will,â said Miss Marple. It was a vow.

âAh.â

The eyes closed, then opened again. Something like a smile seemed to try and twitch the lips.

âThe big stone from above. The Stone of Death.â

âWho rolled that stone down?â

âDonât know. No matterâonlyâVerity. Find out about Verity. Truth. Another name for truth, Verity.â

Miss Marple saw the faint relaxation of the body on the bed. There was a faintly whispered: âGood-bye. Do your bestâ¦.â

Her body relaxed, the eyes closed. The nurse came again to the bedside. This time she took up the pulse, felt it, and beckoned to Miss Marple. Miss Marple rose obediently and followed her out of the room.

âThatâs been a big effort for her,â said the nurse. âShe wonât regain consciousness again for some time. Perhaps not at all. I hope you learnt something?â

âI donât think I did,â said Miss Marple, âbut one never knows, does one.â

âDid you get anything?â asked Professor Wanstead, as they went out to the car.

âA name,â said Miss Marple. âVerity. Was that the girlâs name?â

âYes. Verity Hunt.â

Elizabeth Temple died an hour and a half later. She died without regaining consciousness.

Fourteen

MR. BROADRIBB WONDERS

âSeen The Times this morning?â said Mr. Broadribb to his partner, Mr. Schuster.

Mr. Schuster said he couldnât afford The Times, he took the Telegraph.

âWell, it may be in that too,â said Mr. Broadribb. âIn the deaths, Miss Elizabeth Temple, D.Sc.â

Mr. Schuster looked faintly puzzled.

âHeadmistress of Fallowfield. Youâve heard of Fallowfield, havenât you?â

âOf course,â said Schuster. âGirlsâ school. Been going for fifty years or so. First class, fantastically expensive. So she was the Headmistress of it, was she? I thought the Headmistress had resigned some time ago. Six months at least. Iâm sure I read about it in the paper. That is to say there was a bit about the new Headmistress. Married woman. Youngish. Thirty-five to forty. Modern ideas. Give the girls lessons in cosmetics, let âem wear trouser suits. Something of that kind.â

âHum,â said Mr. Broadribb, making the noise that solicitors of his age are likely to make when they hear something which elicits criticism based on long experience. âDonât think sheâll ever make the name that Elizabeth Temple did. Quite someone, she was. Been there a long time, too.â

âYes,â said Mr. Schuster, somewhat uninterested. He wondered why Broadribb was so interested in defunct schoolmistresses.

Schools were not really of particular interest to either of the two gentlemen. Their own offspring were now more or less disposed of. Mr. Broadribbâs two sons were respectively in the Civil Service and in an oil firm, and Mr. Schusterâs rather younger progeny were at different universities where both of them respectively were making as much trouble for those in authority as they possibly could do. He said,

âWhat about her?â

âShe was on a coach tour,â said Mr. Broadribb.

âThose coaches,â said Mr. Schuster. âI wouldnât let any of my relations go on one of those. One went off a precipice in Switzerland last week and two months ago one had a crash and twenty were killed. Donât know who drives these things nowadays.â

âIt was one of those Country Houses and Gardens and Objects of Interest in Britainâor whatever they call itâtours,â said Mr. Broadribb. âThatâs not quite the right name, but you know what I mean.â

âOh yes, I know. Oh theâerâyes, thatâs the one we sent Miss Whatâs-a-name on. The one old Rafiel booked.â

âMiss Jane Marple was on it.â

âShe didnât get killed too, did she?â asked Mr. Schuster.

âNot so far as I know,â said Mr. Broadribb. âI just wondered a bit, though.â

âWas it a road accident?â

âNo. It was at one of the beauty spot places. They were walking on a path up a hill. It was a stiff walk. Up a rather steep hill with boulders and things on it. Some of the boulders got loose and came rushing down the mountainside. Miss Temple was knocked out and taken to hospital with concussion and diedââ

âBad luck,â said Mr. Schuster, and waited for more.

âI only wondered,â said Mr. Broadribb, âbecause I happened to remember thatâwell, that Fallowfield was the school where the girl was at.â

âWhat girl? I donât really know what youâre talking about, Broadribb.â

âThe girl who was done in by young Michael Rafiel. I was just recalling a few things which might seem to have some slight connection with this curious Jane Marple business that old Rafiel was so keen on. Wish heâd told us more.â

âWhatâs the connection?â said Mr. Schuster.

He looked more interested now. His legal wits were in process of being sharpened, to give a sound opinion on whatever it was that Mr. Broadribb was about to confide to him.

âThat girl. Canât remember her last name now. Christian name was Hope or Faith or something like that. Verity, that was her name. Verity Hunter, I think it was. She was one of that series of murdered girls. Found her body in a ditch about thirty miles away from where sheâd gone missing. Been dead six months. Strangled apparently, and her head and face had been bashed inâto delay recognition, they thought, but she was recognized all right. Clothes, handbag, jewellery nearbyâsome mole or scar. Oh yes, she was identified quite easilyââ

âActually, she was the one the trial was all about, wasnât she?â

âYes. Suspected of having done away with perhaps three other girls during the past year, Michael was. But evidence wasnât so good in the other deathsâso the police went all out on this oneâplenty of evidenceâbad record. Earlier cases of assault and rape. Well, we all know what rape is nowadays. Mum tells the girl sheâs got to accuse the young man of rape even if the young man hasnât had much chance, with the girl at him all the time to come to the house while mumâs away at work or dadâs gone on holiday. Doesnât stop badgering him until sheâs forced him to sleep with her. Then, as I say, mum tells the girl to call it rape. However, thatâs not the point,â said Mr. Broadribb. âI wondered if things mightnât tie up a bit, you know. I thought this Jane Marple business with Rafiel might have something to do with Michael.â

âFound guilty, wasnât he? And given a life sentence?â

âI canât remember nowâitâs so long ago. Or did they get away with a verdict of diminished responsibility?â

âAnd Verity Hunter or Hunt was educated at that school. Miss Templeâs school? She wasnât still a schoolgirl though, was she, when she was killed? Not that I can remember.â

âOh no. She was eighteen or nineteen, living with relations or friends of her parents, or something like that. Nice house, nice people, nice girl by all accounts. The sort of girl whose relations always say âshe was a very quiet girl, rather shy, didnât go about with strange people and had no boyfriends.â Relations never know what boyfriends a girl has. The girls take mighty good care of that. And young Rafiel was said to be very attractive to girls.â

âNever been any doubt that he did it?â asked Mr. Schuster.

âNot a scrap. Told a lot of lies in the witness box, anyway. His Counsel would have done better not to have let him give evidence. A lot of his friends gave him an alibi that didnât stand up, if you know what I mean. All his friends seemed to be fluent liars.â

âWhatâs your feeling about it, Broadribb?â

âOh, I havenât got any feelings,â said Mr. Broadribb, âI was just wondering if this womanâs death might tie up.â

âIn what way?â

âWell, you knowâabout these boulders that fall down cliff sides and drop on top of someone. Itâs not always in the course of nature. Boulders usually stay where they are, in my experience.â

Fifteen

VERITY

I

âVerity,â said Miss Marple.

Elizabeth Margaret Temple had died the evening before. It had been a peaceful death. Miss Marple, sitting once more amidst the faded chintz of the drawing room in The Old Manor House, had laid aside the babyâs pink coat which she had previously been engaged in knitting and had substituted a crocheted purple scarf. This half-mourning touch went with Miss Marpleâs early Victorian ideas of tactfulness in face of tragedy.

An inquest was to be held on the following day. The vicar had been approached and had agreed to hold a brief memorial service in the church as soon as arrangements could be made. Undertakers suitably attired, with proper mourning faces, took general charge of things in liaison with the police. The inquest was to take place on the following morning at 11 oâclock. Members of the coach tour had agreed to attend the inquest. And several of them had chosen to remain on so as to attend the church service also.

Mrs. Glynne had come to the Golden Boar and urged Miss Marple to return to The Old Manor House until she finally returned to the tour.

âYou will get away from all the reporters.â

Miss Marple had thanked all three sisters warmly and had accepted.

The coach tour would be resumed after the memorial service, driving first to South Bedestone, thirty-five miles away, where there was a good class hotel which had been originally chosen for a stopping place. After that the tour would go on as usual.

There were, however, as Miss Marple had considered likely, certain persons who were disengaging themselves and returning home, or were going in other directions and not continuing on the tour. There was something to be said in favour of either decision. To leave what would become a journey of painful memories, or to continue with the sightseeing that had already been paid for and which had been interrupted only by one of those painful accidents that may happen on any sightseeing expedition. A lot would depend, Miss Marple thought, on the outcome of the inquest.

Miss Marple, after exchanging various conventional remarks proper to the occasion with her three hostesses, had devoted herself to her purple wool and had sat considering her next line of investigation. And so it was that with her fingers still busy, she had uttered the one word, âVerity.â Throwing it as one throws a pebble into a stream, solely to observe what the resultâif anyâwould be. Would it mean something to her hostesses? It might or it might not. Otherwise, when she joined the members of the tour at their hotel meal this evening, which had been arranged, she would try the effect of it there. It had been, she thought to herself, the last word or almost the last word that Elizabeth Temple had spoken. So therefore, thought Miss Marple (her fingers still busy because she did not need to look at her crocheting, she could read a book or conduct a conversation while her fingers, though slightly crippled with rheumatism, would proceed correctly through their appointed movements). So therefore, âVerity.â

Like a stone into a pool, causing ripples, a splash, something? Or nothing. Surely there would be a reaction of one sort or another. Yes, she had not been mistaken. Although her face registered nothing, the keen eyes behind her glasses had watched three people in a simultaneous manner as she had trained herself to do for many years now, when wishing to observe her neighbours either in church, mothersâ meetings, or at other public functions in St. Mary Mead when she had been on the track of some interesting piece of news or gossip.

Mrs. Glynne had dropped the book she was holding and had looked across towards Miss Marple with slight surprise. Surprise, it seemed, at the particular word coming from Miss Marple, but not surprised really to hear it.

Clotilde reacted differently. Her head shot up, she leant forward a little, then she looked not at Miss Marple but across the room in the direction of the window. Her hands clenched themselves, she kept very still. Miss Marple, although dropping her head slightly as though she was not looking any more, noted that her eyes were filling with tears. Clotilde sat quite still and let the tears roll down her cheeks. She made no attempt to take out a handkerchief, she uttered no word. Miss Marple was impressed by the aura of grief that came from her.

Antheaâs reaction was different. It was quick, excited, almost pleasurable.

âVerity? Verity, did you say? Did you know her? Iâd no idea. It is Verity Hunt you mean?â

Lavinia Glynne said, âItâs a Christian name?â

âI never knew anyone of that name,â said Miss Marple, âbut I did mean a Christian name. Yes. It is rather unusual, I think. Verity.â She repeated it thoughtfully.

She let her purple wool ball fall and looked round with the slightly apologetic and embarrassed look of one who realizes she has made a serious faux pas, but not sure why.

âIâI am so sorry. Have I said something I shouldnât? It was only becauseâ¦.â

âNo, of course not,â said Mrs. Glynne. âIt was just that it isâit is a name we know, a name with which we haveâassociations.â

âIt just came into my mind,â said Miss Marple, still apologetic, âbecause, you know, it was poor Miss Temple who said it. I went to see her, you know, yesterday afternoon. Professor Wanstead took me. He seemed to think that I might be able toâtoâI donât know if itâs the proper wordâto rouse her, in some way. She was in a coma and they thoughtânot that I was a friend of hers at any time, but we had chatted together on the tour and we often sat beside each other, as you know, on some of the days and we had talked. And he thought perhaps I might be of some use. Iâm afraid I wasnât though. Not at all. I just sat there and waited and then she did say one or two words, but they didnât seem to mean anything. But finally, just when it was time for me to go, she did open her eyes and looked at meâI donât know if she was mistaking me for someoneâbut she did say that word. Verity! And, well of course it stuck in my mind, especially with her passing away yesterday evening. It must have been someone or something that she had in her mind. But of course it might just meanâwell, of course it might just mean Truth. Thatâs what verity means, doesnât it?â

She looked from Clotilde to Lavinia to Anthea.

âIt was the Christian name of a girl we knew,â said Lavinia Glynne. âThat is why it startled us.â

âEspecially because of the awful way she died,â said Anthea.

Clotilde said in her deep voice, âAnthea! thereâs no need to go into these details.â

âBut after all, everyone knows quite well about her,â said Anthea. She looked towards Miss Marple. âI thought perhaps you might have known about her because you knew Mr. Rafiel, didnât you? Well, I mean, he wrote to us about you so you must have known him. And I thought perhapsâwell, heâd mentioned the whole thing to you.â

âIâm so sorry,â said Miss Marple, âIâm afraid I donât quite understand what youâre talking about.â

âThey found her body in a ditch,â said Anthea.

There was never any holding Anthea, Miss Marple thought, not once she got going. But she thought that Antheaâs vociferous talk was putting additional strain on Clotilde. She had taken out a handkerchief now in a quiet, noncommittal way. She brushed tears from her eyes and then sat upright, her back very straight, her eyes deep and tragic.

âVerity,â she said, âwas a girl we cared for very much. She lived here for a while. I was very fond of herââ

âAnd she was very fond of you,â said Lavinia.

âHer parents were friends of mine,â said Clotilde. âThey were killed in a plane accident.â

âShe was at school at Fallowfield,â explained Lavinia. âI suppose that was how Miss Temple came to remember her.â

âOh I see,â said Miss Marple. âWhere Miss Temple was Headmistress, is that it? I have heard of Fallowfield often, of course. Itâs a very fine school, isnât it?â

âYes,â said Clotilde. âVerity was a pupil there. After her parents died she came to stay with us for a time while she could decide what she wanted to do with her future. She was eighteen or nineteen. A very sweet girl and a very affectionate and loving one. She thought perhaps of training for nursing, but she had very good brains and Miss Temple was very insistent that she ought to go to university. So she was studying and having coaching for that whenâwhen this terrible thing happened.â

She turned her face away.

âIâdo you mind if we donât talk about it any more just now?â

âOh, of course not,â said Miss Marple. âIâm so sorry to have impinged on some tragedy. I didnât know. IâI havenât heard â¦ I thoughtâwell I mean â¦â She became more and more incoherent.

II

That evening she heard a little more. Mrs. Glynne came to her bedroom when she was changing her dress to go out and join the others at the hotel.

âI thought I ought to come and explain a little to you,â said Mrs. Glynne, âaboutâabout the girl Verity Hunt. Of course you couldnât know that our sister Clotilde was particularly fond of her and that her really horrible death was a terrible shock. We never mention her if we can help it, butâI think it would be easier if I told you the facts completely and you will understand. Apparently Verity had, without our knowledge, made friends with an undesirableâa more than undesirableâit turned out to be a dangerousâyoung man who already had a criminal record. He came here to visit us when he was passing through once. We knew his father very well.â She paused. âI think Iâd better tell you the whole truth if you donât know, and you donât seem to. He was actually Mr. Rafielâs son, Michaelââ

âOh dear,â said Miss Marple, ânotânotâI canât remember his name but I do remember hearing that there was a sonâand, that he hadnât been very satisfactory.â

âA little more than that,â said Mrs. Glynne. âHeâd always given trouble. Heâd been had up in court once or twice for various things. Once assaulting a teenagerâother things of that type. Of course I consider myself that the magistrates are too lenient with that kind of thing. They donât want to upset a young manâs university career. And so they let them off with aâI forget what they call itâa suspended sentence, something of that kind. If these boys were sent to gaol at once it would perhaps warn them off that type of life. He was a thief, too. He had forged cheques, he pinched things. He was a thoroughly bad lot. We were friends of his motherâs. It was lucky for her, I think, that she died young before she had time to be upset by the way her son was turning out. Mr. Rafiel did all he could, I think. Tried to find suitable jobs for the boy, paid fines for him and things like that. But I think it was a great blow to him, though he pretended to be more or less indifferent and to write it off as one of those things that happen. We had, as probably people here in the village will tell you, we had a bad outbreak of murders and violence in this district. Not only here. They were in different parts of the country, twenty miles away, sometimes fifty miles away. One or two, itâs suspected by the police, were nearly a hundred miles away. But they seemed to centre more or less on this part of the world. Anyway, Verity one day went out to visit a friend andâwell, she didnât come back. We went to the police about it, the police sought for her, searched the whole countryside but they couldnât find any trace of her. We advertised, they advertised, and they suggested that sheâd gone off with a boyfriend. Then word began to get round that she had been seen with Michael Rafiel. By now the police had their eye on Michael as a possibility for certain crimes that had occurred, although they couldnât find any direct evidence. Verity was said to have been seen, described by her clothing and other things, with a young man of Michaelâs appearance and in a car that corresponded to a description of his car. But there was no further evidence until her body was discovered six months later, thirty miles from here in a rather wild part of wooded country, in a ditch covered with stones and piled earth. Clotilde had to go to identify itâit was Verity all right. Sheâd been strangled and her head beaten in. Clotilde has never quite got over the shock. There were certain marks, a mole and an old scar and of course her clothes and the contents of her handbag. Miss Temple was very fond of Verity. She must have thought of her just before she died.â

âIâm sorry,â said Miss Marple. âIâm really very, very sorry. Please tell your sister that I didnât know. I had no idea.â

Sixteen

THE INQUEST

I

Miss Marple walked slowly along the village street on her way towards the market place where the inquest was to take place in the old-fashioned Georgian building which had been known for a hundred years as the Curfew Arms. She glanced at her watch. There was still a good twenty minutes before she need be there. She looked into the shops. She paused before the shop that sold wool and babiesâ jackets, and peered inside for a few moments. A girl in the shop was serving. Small woolly coats were being tried on two children. Further along the counter there was an elderly woman.

Miss Marple went into the shop, went along the counter to a seat opposite the elderly woman, and produced a sample of pink wool. She had run out, she explained, of this particular brand of wool and had a little jacket she needed to finish. The match was soon made, some more samples of wool that Miss Marple had admired were brought out for her to look at, and soon she was in conversation. Starting with the sadness of the accident which had just taken place. Mrs. Merrypit, if her name was identical with that which was written up outside the shop, was full of the importance of the accident, and the general difficulties of getting local governments to do anything about the dangers of footpaths and public rights of way.

âAfter the rain, you see, you get all the soil washed off and then the boulders get loose and then down they comes. I remember one year they had three fallsâthree accidents there was. One boy nearly killed, he was, and then later that year, oh six months later, I think, there was a man got his arm broken, and the third time it was poor old Mrs. Walker. Blind she was and pretty well deaf too. She never heard nothing or she could have got out of the way, they say. Somebody saw it and they called out to her, but they was too far away to reach her or to run to get her. And so she was killed.â

âOh how sad,â said Miss Marple, âhow tragic. The sort of thing thatâs not easily forgotten, is it.â

âNo indeed. I expect the Coronerâll mention it today.â

âI expect he will,â said Miss Marple. âIn a terrible way it seems quite a natural thing to happen, doesnât it, though of course there are accidents sometimes by pushing things about, you know. Just pushing, making stones rock. That sort of thing.â

âAh well, thereâs boys as be up to anything. But I donât think Iâve ever seen them up that way, fooling about.â

Miss Marple went on to the subject of pullovers. Bright coloured pullovers.

âItâs not for myself,â she said, âitâs for one of my great-nephews. You know he wants a polo-necked pullover and very bright colours heâd like.â

âYes, they do like bright colours nowadays, donât they?â agreed Mrs. Merrypit. âNot in jeans. Black jeans they like. Black or dark blue. But they like a bit of brightness up above.â

Miss Marple described a pullover of check design in bright colours. There appeared to be quite a good stock of pullovers and jerseys, but anything in red and black did not seem to be on display, nor even was anything like it mentioned as having been lately in stock. After looking at a few samples Miss Marple prepared to take her departure, chatting first about the former murders she had heard about which had happened in this part of the world.

âThey got the fellow in the end,â said Mrs. Merrypit. âNice looking boy, hardly have thought it of him. Heâd been well brought up, you know. Been to university and all that. Father was very rich, they say. Touched in the head, I suppose. Not that they sent him to Broadway, or whatever the place is. No, they didnât do that, but I think myself he must have been a mental caseâthere was five or six other girls, so they said. The police had one after another of the young men round hereabouts to help them. Geoffrey Grant they had up. They were pretty sure it was him to begin with. He was always a bit queer, ever since he was a boy. Interfered with little girls going to school, you know. He used to offer them sweets and get them to come down the lanes with him and see the primroses, or something like that. Yes, they had very strong suspicions about him. But it wasnât him. And then there was another one. Bert Williams, but heâd been far away on two occasions, at leastâwhat they call an alibi, so it couldnât be him. And then at last it came to thisâwhatâsis-name, I canât remember him now. Luke I think his name wasâno Mike something. Very nice looking, as I say, but he had a bad record. Yes, stealing, forging cheques, all sorts of things like that. And two what-you-call âem paternity cases, no, I donât mean that, but you know what I mean. When a girlâs going to have a baby. You know and they make an order and make the fellow pay. Heâd got two girls in the family way before this.â

âWas this girl in the family way?â

âOh yes, she was. At first we thought when the body was found it might have been Nora Broad. That was Mrs. Broadâs niece, down at the mill shop. Great one for going with the boys, she was. Sheâd gone away missing from home in the same way. Nobody knew where she was. So when this body turned up six months later they thought at first it was her.â

âBut it wasnât?â

âNoâsomeone quite different.â

âDid her body ever turn up?â

âNo. I suppose it might some day, but they think on the whole it was pushed into the river. Ah well, you never know, do you? You never know what you may dig up off a ploughed field or something like that. I was taken once to see all that treasure. Luton Loo was itâsome name like that? Somewhere in the East Counties. Under a ploughed field it was. Beautiful. Gold ships and Viking ships and gold plate, enormous great platters. Well, you never know. Any day you may turn up a dead body or you may turn up a gold platter. And it may be hundreds of years old like that gold plate was, or it may be a three-or four-years-old body, like Mary Lucas whoâd been missing for four years, they say. Somewhere near Reigate she was found. Ah well, all these things! Itâs a sad life. Yes, itâs a very sad life. You never know whatâs coming.â

âThere was another girl whoâd lived here, wasnât there?â said Miss Marple, âwho was killed.â

âYou mean the body they thought was Nora Broadâs but it wasnât? Yes. Iâve forgotten her name now. Hope, it was, I think. Hope or Charity. One of those sort of names, if you know what I mean. Used to be used a lot in Victorian times but you donât hear them so much nowadays. Lived at the Manor House, she did. Sheâd been there for some time after her parents were killed.â

âHer parents died in an accident, didnât they?â

âThatâs right. In a plane going to Spain or Italy, one of those places.â

âAnd you say she came to live here? Were they relations of hers?â

âI donât know if they were relations, but Mrs. Glynne as she is now, was I think a great friend of her motherâs or something that way. Mrs. Glynne, of course, was married and gone abroad but Miss Clotildeâthatâs the eldest one, the dark oneâshe was very fond of the girl. She took her abroad, to Italy and France and all sorts of places, and she had her trained a bit of typewriting and shorthand and that sort of thing, and art classes too. Sheâs very arty, Miss Clotilde is. Oh, she was mighty fond of the girl. Brokenhearted she was when she disappeared. Quite different to Miss Antheaââ

âMiss Anthea is the youngest one, isnât she?â

âYes. Not quite all there, some people say. Scatty like, you know, in her mind. Sometimes you see her walking along, talking to herself, you know, and tossing her head in a very queer way. Children get frightened of her sometimes. They say sheâs a bit queer about things. I donât know. You hear everything in a village, donât you? The great-uncle who lived here before, he was a bit peculiar too. Used to practise revolver shooting in the garden. For no reason at all so far as anyone could see. Proud of his marksmanship, he said he was, whatever marksmanship is.â

âBut Miss Clotilde is not peculiar?â

âOh no, sheâs clever, she is. Knows Latin and Greek, I believe. Would have liked to go to university but she had to look after her mother who was an invalid for a long time. But she was very fond of Missânow, what was her name?âFaith perhaps. She was very fond of her and treated her like a daughter. And then along comes this young whatâs-his-name, Michael I think it wasâand then one day the girl just goes off without saying a word to anyone. I donât know if Miss Clotilde knew as she was in the family way.â

âBut you knew,â said Miss Marple.

âAh well, Iâve got a lot of experience. I usually know when a girlâs that way. Itâs plain enough to the eye. Itâs not only the shape, as you might say, you can tell by the look in their eyes and the way they walk and sit, and the sort of giddy fits they get and sick turns now and again. Oh yes, I thought to myself, hereâs another one of them. Miss Clotilde had to go and identify the body. Nearly broke her up, it did. She was like a different woman for weeks afterwards. Fairly loved that girl, she did.â

âAnd the other oneâMiss Anthea?â

âFunnily enough, you know, I thought she had a kind of pleased look as though she wasâyes, just pleased. Not nice, eh? Farmer Plummerâs daughter used to look like that. Always used to go and see pigs killed. Enjoyed it. Funny things goes on in families.â

Miss Marple said good-bye, saw she had another ten minutes to go and passed on to the post office. The post office and general store of Jocelyn St. Mary was just off the Market Square.

Miss Marple went into the post office, bought some stamps, looked at some of the postcards and then turned her attention to various paperback books. A middle-aged woman with rather a vinegary face presided behind the postal counter. She assisted Miss Marple to free a book from the wire support in which the books were.

âStick a bit sometimes, they do. People donât put them back straight, you see.â

There was by now no one else in the shop. Miss Marple looked with distaste at the jacket of the book, a naked girl with blood-stained markings on her face and a sinister-looking killer bending over her with a blood-stained knife in his hand.

âReally,â she said, âI donât like these horrors nowadays.â

âGone a bit too far with some of their jackets, havenât they,â said Mrs. Vinegar. âNot everyone as likes them. Too fond of violence in every way, Iâd say nowadays.â

Miss Marple detached a second book. âWhatever Happened to Baby Jane,â she read. âOh dear, itâs a sad world one lives in.â

âOh yes, I know. Saw in yesterdayâs paper, I did, some woman left her baby outside a supermarket and then someone else comes along and wheels it away. And all for no reason as far as one can see. The police found her all right. They all seem to say the same things, whether they steal from a supermarket or take away a baby. Donât know what came over them, they say.â

âPerhaps they really donât,â suggested Miss Marple.

Mrs. Vinegar looked even more like vinegar.

âTake me a lot to believe that, it would.â

Miss Marple looked roundâthe post office was still empty. She advanced to the window.

âIf you are not too busy, I wonder if you could answer a question of mine,â said Miss Marple. âI have done something extremely stupid. Of late years I make so many mistakes. This was a parcel addressed to a charity. I send them clothesâpullovers and childrenâs woollies, and I did it up and addressed it and it was sent offâand only this morning it came to me suddenly that Iâd made a mistake and written the wrong address. I donât suppose any list is kept of the address of parcelsâbut I thought someone might have just happened to remember it. The address I meant to put was The Dockyard and Thames Side Welfare Association.â

Mrs. Vinegar was looking quite kindly now, touched by Miss Marpleâs patent incapacity and general state of senility and dither.

âDid you bring it yourself?â

âNo, I didnâtâIâm staying at The Old Manor Houseâand one of them, Mrs. Glynne, I thinkâsaid she or her sister would post it. Very kind of herââ

âLet me see now. It would have been on Tuesday, would it? It wasnât Mrs. Glynne who brought it in, it was the youngest one, Miss Anthea.â

âYes, yes, I think that was the dayââ

âI remember it quite well. In a good sized dress boxâand moderately heavy, I think. But not what you said, Dockyard AssociationâI canât recall anything like that. It was the Reverend MatthewsâThe East Ham Women and Childrenâs Woollen Clothing Appeal.â

âOh yes.â Miss Marple clasped her hands in an ecstasy of relief. âHow clever of youâI see now how I came to do it. At Christmas I did send things to the East Ham Society in answer to a special appeal for knitted things, so I must have copied down the wrong address. Can you just repeat it?â She entered it carefully in a small notebook.

âIâm afraid the parcelâs gone off, thoughââ

âOh yes, but I can write, explaining the mistake and ask them to forward the parcel to the Dockyard Association instead. Thank you so much.â

Miss Marple trotted out.

Mrs. Vinegar produced stamps for her next customer, remarking in an aside to a colleagueââScatty as they make them, poor old creature. Expect sheâs always doing that sort of thing.â

Miss Marple went out of the post office and ran into Emlyn Price and Joanna Crawford.

Joanna, she noticed, was very pale and looked upset.

âIâve got to give evidence,â she said. âI donât knowâwhat will they ask me? Iâm so afraid. IâI donât like it. I told the police sergeant, I told him what I thought we saw.â

âDonât you worry, Joanna,â said Emlyn Price. âThis is just a coronerâs inquest, you know. Heâs a nice man, a doctor, I believe. Heâll just ask you a few questions and youâll say what you saw.â

âYou saw it too,â said Joanna.

âYes, I did,â said Emlyn. âAt least I saw there was someone up there. Near the boulders and things. Now come on, Joanna.â

âThey came and searched our rooms in the hotel,â said Joanna. âThey asked our permission but they had a search warrant. They looked in our rooms and among the things in our luggage.â

âI think they wanted to find that check pullover you described. Anyway, thereâs nothing for you to worry about. If youâd had a black and scarlet pullover yourself you wouldnât have talked about it, would you. It was black and scarlet, wasnât it?â

âI donât know,â said Emlyn Price. âI donât really know the colours of things very well. I think it was a sort of bright colour. Thatâs all I know.â

âThey didnât find one,â said Joanna. âAfter all, none of us have very many things with us. You donât when you go on a coach travel. There wasnât anything like that among anybodyâs things. Iâve never seen anyoneâof our lot, I mean, wearing anything like that. Not so far. Have you?â

âNo, I havenât, but I supposeâI donât know that I should know if I had seen it,â said Emlyn Price. âI donât always know red from green.â

âNo, youâre a bit colour-blind, arenât you,â said Joanna. âI noticed that the other day.â

âWhat do you mean, you noticed it.â

âMy red scarf. I asked if youâd seen it. You said youâd seen a green one somewhere and you brought me the red one. Iâd left it in the dining room. But you didnât really know it was red.â

âWell, donât go about saying Iâm colour-blind. I donât like it. Puts people off in some way.â

âMen are more often colour-blind than women,â said Joanna. âItâs one of those sex-link things,â she added, with an air of erudition. âYou know, it passes through the female and comes out in the male.â

âYou make it sound as though it was measles,â said Emlyn Price. âWell, here we are.â

âYou donât seem to mind,â said Joanna, as they walked up the steps.

âWell, I donât really. Iâve never been to an inquest. Things are rather interesting when you do them for the first time.â

II

Dr. Stokes was a middle-aged man with greying hair and spectacles. Police evidence was given first, then the medical evidence with technical details of the concussion injuries which had caused death. Mrs. Sandbourne gave particulars of the coach tour, the expedition as arranged for that particular afternoon, and particulars of how the fatality had occurred. Miss Temple, she said, although not young, was a very brisk walker. The party were going along a well-known footpath which led around the curve of a hill which slowly mounted to the old Moorland Church originally built in Elizabethan times, though repaired and added to later. On an adjoining crest was what was called the Bonaventure Memorial. It was a fairly steep ascent and people usually climbed it at different paces from each other. The younger ones very often ran or walked ahead and reached their destination much earlier than the others. The elderly ones took it slowly. She herself usually kept at the rear of the party so that she could, if necessary, suggest to people who were tired that they could, if they liked, go back. Miss Temple, she said, had been talking to a Mr. and Mrs. Butler. Miss Temple, though she was over sixty, had been slightly impatient at their slow pace and had outdistanced them, had turned a corner and gone on ahead rather rapidly, which she had done often before. She was inclined to get impatient if waiting for people to catch up for too long, and preferred to make her own pace. They had heard a cry ahead, and she and the others had run on, turned a curve of the pathway and had found Miss Temple lying on the ground. A large boulder detached from the hillside above where there were several others of the same kind, must, they had thought, have rolled down the hillside and struck Miss Temple as she was going along the path below. A most unfortunate and tragic accident.

âYou had no idea there was anything but an accident?â

âNo, indeed. I can hardly see how it could have been anything but an accident.â

âYou saw no one above you on the hillside?â

âNo. This is the main path round the hill but of course people do wander about over the top. I did not see anyone that particular afternoon.â

Then Joanna Crawford was called. After particulars of her name and age Dr. Stokes asked,

âYou were not walking with the remainder of the party?â

âNo, we had left the path. Weâd gone round the hill a little higher up the slope.â

âYou were walking with a companion?â

âYes. With Mr. Emlyn Price.â

âThere was no one else actually walking with you?â

âNo. We were talking and we were looking at one or two of the flowers. They seemed of rather an uncommon kind. Emlynâs interested in botany.â

âWere you out of sight of the rest of the party?â

âNot all the time. They were walking along the main pathâsome way below us, that is.â

âDid you see Miss Temple?â

âI think so. She was walking ahead of the others, and I think I saw her turn a corner of the path ahead of them after which we didnât see her because the contour of the hill hid her.â

âDid you see someone walking above you on the hillside?â

âYes. Up amongst a good many boulders. Thereâs a sort of great patch of boulders on the side of the hill.â

âYes,â said Dr. Stokes, âI know exactly the place you mean. Large granite boulders. People call them the Wethers, or the Grey Wethers sometimes.â

âI suppose they might look like sheep from a distance but we werenât so very far away from them.â

âAnd you saw someone up there?â

âYes. Someone was more or less in the middle of the boulders, leaning over them.â

âPushing them, do you think?â

âYes. I thought so, and wondered why. He seemed to be pushing at one on the outside of the group near the edge. They were so big and so heavy I would have thought it was impossible to push them. But the one he or she was pushing seemed to be balanced like a rocking stone.â

âYou said first he, now you say he or she, Miss Crawford. Which do you think it was?â

âWell, I thoughtâI supposeâI suppose I thought it was a man, but I wasnât actually thinking at the time. It wasâhe or she wasâwearing trousers and a pullover, a sort of manâs pullover with a polo-neck.â

âWhat colour was the pullover?â

âRather a bright red and black in checks. And there was longish hair at the back of a kind of beret, rather like a womanâs hair, but then it might just as well have been a manâs.â

âIt certainly might,â said Dr. Stokes, rather drily. âIdentifying a male or female figure by their hair is certainly not easy these days.â He went on, âWhat happened next?â

âWell, the stone began to roll over. It sort of toppled over the edge and then it began to gain speed. I said to Emlyn, âOh itâs going to go right over down the hill.â Then we heard a sort of crash as it fell. And I think I heard a cry from below but I might have imagined it.â

âAnd then?â

âOh, we ran on up a bit and round the corner of the hill to see what happened to the stone.â

âAnd what did you see?â

âWe saw the boulder below on the path with a body underneath itâand people coming running round the corner.â

âWas it Miss Temple who uttered the cry?â

âI think it must have been. It might have been one of the others who was catching up and turned the corner. Oh! it wasâit was horrible.â

âYes, Iâm sure it was. What had happened to the figure youâd seen above? The man or woman in the red and black pullover? Was that figure still there among the stones?â

âI donât know. I never looked up there. I wasâI was busy looking at the accident, and running down the hill to see if one could do anything. I did just look up, I think, but there wasnât anyone in sight. Only the stones. There were a lot of contours and you could lose anyone quite easily from view.â

âCould it have been one of your party?â

âOh, no. Iâm sure it wasnât one of us. I would have known because, I mean, one would have known by their clothes. Iâm sure nobody was wearing a scarlet and black pullover.â

âThank you, Miss Crawford.â

Emlyn Price was called next. His story was practically a replica of Joannaâs.

There was a little more evidence which did not amount to much.

The Coroner brought in that there was not sufficient evidence to show how Elizabeth Temple had come to her death, and adjourned the inquest for a fortnight.

Seventeen

MISS MARPLE MAKES A VISIT

I

As they walked back from the inquest to the Golden Boar hardly anyone spoke. Professor Wanstead walked beside Miss Marple, and since she was not a very fast walker, they fell slightly behind the others.

âWhat will happen next?â Miss Marple asked at last.

âDo you mean legally or to us?â

âI suppose both,â said Miss Marple, âbecause one will surely affect the other.â

âIt will be presumably a case of the police making further enquiries, arising out of the evidence given by those two young people.â

âYes.â

âFurther enquiry will be necessary. The inquest was bound to be adjourned. One can hardly expect the Coroner to give a verdict of accidental death.â

âNo, I understand that.â She said, âWhat did you think of their evidence?â

Professor Wanstead directed a sharp glance from under his beetling eyebrows.

âHave you any ideas on the subject, Miss Marple?â His voice was suggestive. âOf course,â said Professor Wanstead, âwe knew beforehand what they were going to say.â

âYes.â

âWhat you mean is that you are asking what I thought about them themselves, their feelings about it.â

âIt was interesting,â said Miss Marple. âVery interesting. The red and black check pullover. Rather important, I think, donât you? Rather striking?â

âYes, exactly that.â

He shot again that look at her under his eyebrows. âWhat does it suggest to you exactly?â

âI think,â said Miss Marple, âI think the description of that might give us a valuable clue.â

They came to the Golden Boar. It was only about half past twelve and Mrs. Sandbourne suggested a little refreshment before going in to luncheon. As sherry and tomato juice and other liquors were being consumed, Mrs. Sandbourne proceeded to make certain announcements.

âI have taken advice,â she said, âboth from the Coroner and Inspector Douglas. Since the medical evidence has been taken fully, there will be at the church a funeral memorial service tomorrow at eleven oâclock. Iâm going to make arrangements with Mr. Courtney, the local vicar, about it. On the following day it will be best, I think, to resume our tour. The programme will be slightly altered, since we have lost three days, but I think it can be reorganized on rather simpler lines. I have heard from one or two members of our party that they would prefer to return to London, presumably by rail. I can quite understand the feelings lying behind this, and would not like to try and influence you in any way. This death has been a very sad occurrence. I still cannot help but believe that Miss Templeâs death was the result of an accident. Such a thing has happened before on that particular pathway, though there do not appear in this case to have been any geological or atmospherical conditions causing it. I think a good deal more investigation will have to be made. Of course, some hiker on a walking tourâthat kind of thingâmay have been pushing about boulders quite innocently, not realizing that there was a danger for someone walking below in what he or she was doing. If so, if that person comes forward, the whole thing may be cleared up quite quickly, but I agree one cannot take that for granted at present. It seems unlikely that the late Miss Temple could have had an enemy, or anyone who wished her harm of any kind. What I should suggest is, that we do not discuss the accident any further. Investigations will be made by the local authorities whose business it is. I think we will probably all like to attend the memorial service in the church tomorrow. And after that, on continuing the tour, I hope that it may distract our minds from the shock we have had. There are still some very interesting and famous houses to see and some very beautiful scenery also.â

Luncheon being announced shortly after that, the subject was not discussed any further. That is to say, not openly. After lunch, as they took coffee in the lounge, people were prone to get together in little groups, discussing their further arrangements.

âAre you continuing on the tour?â asked Professor Wanstead of Miss Marple.

âNo,â said Miss Marple. She spoke thoughtfully. âNo. I thinkâI think that what has happened inclines me to remain here a little longer.â

âAt the Golden Boar or at The Old Manor House?â

âThat rather depends as to whether I receive any further invitation to go back to The Old Manor House. I would not like to suggest it myself because my original invitation was for the two nights that the tour was to have stayed here originally. I think possibly it would be better for me to remain at the Golden Boar.â

âYou donât feel like returning to St. Mary Mead?â

âNot yet,â said Miss Marple. âThere are one or two things I could do here, I think. One thing I have done already.â She met his enquiring gaze. âIf you are going on,â she said, âwith the rest of the party, I will tell you what I have put in hand, and suggest a small sideline of enquiry that might be helpful. The other reason that I wish to stay here I will tell you later. There are certain enquiriesâlocal enquiriesâthat I want to make. They may not lead anywhere so I think it as well not to mention them now. And you?â

âI should like to return to London. I have work there waiting to be done. Unless, that is, I can be helpful to you here?â

âNo,â said Miss Marple, âI do not think so at present. I expect you have various enquiries of your own that you wish to put in hand.â

âI came on the tour to meet you, Miss Marple.â

âAnd now you have met me and know what I know, or practically all that I know, you have other enquiries to put in hand. I understand that. But before you leave here, I think there are one or two thingsâwell, that might be helpful, might give a result.â

âI see. You have ideas.â

âI am remembering what you said.â

âYou have perhaps pinned down the smell of evil?â

âIt is difficult,â said Miss Marple, âto know exactly what something wrong in the atmosphere really means.â

âBut you do feel that there is something wrong in the atmosphere?â

âOh yes. Very clearly.â

âAnd especially since Miss Templeâs death which, of course, was not an accident, no matter what Mrs. Sandbourne hopes.â

âNo,â said Miss Marple, âit was not an accident. What I donât think I have told you is that Miss Temple said to me once that she was on a pilgrimage.â

âInteresting,â said the Professor. âYes, interesting. She didnât tell you what the pilgrimage was, to where or to whom?â

âNo,â said Miss Marple, âif sheâd lived just a little longer and not been so weak, she might have told me. But unfortunately, death came a little too soon.â

âSo that you have not any further ideas on that subject.â

âNo. Only a feeling of assurance that her pilgrimage was put an end to by malign design. Someone wanted to stop her going wherever she was going, or stop her going to whomever she was going to. One can only hope that chance or Providence may throw light on that.â

âThatâs why youâre staying here?â

âNot only that,â said Miss Marple. âI want to find out something more about a girl called Nora Broad.â

âNora Broad.â He looked faintly puzzled.

âThe other girl who disappeared about the same time as Verity Hunt did. You remember you mentioned her to me. A girl who had boyfriends and was, I understand, very ready to have boyfriends. A foolish girl, but attractive apparently to the male sex. I think,â said Miss Marple, âthat to learn a little more about her might help me in my enquiries.â

âHave it your own way, Detective-Inspector Marple,â said Professor Wanstead.

II

The service took place on the following morning. All the members of the tour were there. Miss Marple looked round the church. Several of the locals were there also. Mrs. Glynne was there and her sister Clotilde. The youngest one, Anthea, did not attend. There were one or two people from the village also, she thought. Probably not acquainted with Miss Temple but there out of a rather morbid curiosity in regard to what was now spoken of by the term âfoul play.â There was, too, an elderly clergyman; in gaiters, well over seventy, Miss Marple thought, a broad-shouldered old man with a noble mane of white hair. He was slightly crippled and found it difficult both to kneel and to stand. It was a fine face, Miss Marple thought, and she wondered who he was. Some old friend of Elizabeth Temple, she presumed, who might perhaps have come from quite a long distance to attend the service?

As they came out of the church Miss Marple exchanged a few words with her fellow travellers. She knew now pretty well who was doing what. The Butlers were returning to London.

âI told Henry I just couldnât go on with it,â said Mrs. Butler. âYou knowâI feel all the time that any minute just as we might be walking round a corner, someone, you know, might shoot us or throw a stone at us. Someone who has got a down on the Famous Houses of England.â

âNow then, Mamie, now then,â said Mr. Butler, âdonât you let your imagination go as far as that!â

âWell, you just donât know nowadays. What with hijackers about and kidnapping and all the rest of it, I donât feel really protected anywhere.â

Old Miss Lumley and Miss Bentham were continuing with the tour, their anxieties allayed.

âWeâve paid very highly for this tour and it seems a pity to miss anything just because this very sad accident has happened. We rang up a very good neighbour of ours last night, and they are going to see to the cats, so we donât need to worry.â

It was going to remain an accident for Miss Lumley and Miss Bentham. They had decided it was more comfortable that way.

Mrs. Riseley-Porter was also continuing on the tour. Colonel and Mrs. Walker were resolved that nothing would make them miss seeing a particularly rare collection of fuchsias in the garden due to be visited the day after tomorrow. The architect, Jameson, was also guided by his wish to see various buildings of special interest for him. Mr. Caspar, however, was departing by rail, he said. Miss Cooke and Miss Barrow seemed undecided.

âPretty good walks round here,â said Miss Cooke. âI think weâll stay at the Golden Boar for a little. Thatâs what youâre going to do, isnât it, Miss Marple?â

âI really think so,â said Miss Marple. âI donât feel quite equal to going on travelling and all that. I think a day or twoâs rest would be helpful to me after whatâs happened.â

As the little crowd dispersed, Miss Marple took an unostentatious route of her own. From her handbag she took out a leaf torn from her notebook on which she had entered two addresses. The first, a Mrs. Blackett, lived in a neat little house and garden just by the end of the road where it sloped down towards the valley. A small neat woman opened the door.

âMrs. Blackett?â

âYes, yes, maâam, thatâs my name.â

âI wonder if I might just come in and speak to you for a minute or two. I have just been to the service and I am feeling a little giddy. If I could just sit down for a minute or two?â

âDear me, now, dear me. Oh, Iâm sorry for that. Come right in, maâam, come right in. Thatâs right. You sit down here. Now Iâll get you a glass of waterâor maybe youâd like a pot of tea?â

âNo, thank you,â said Miss Marple, âa glass of water would put me right.â

Mrs. Blackett returned with a glass of water and a pleasurable prospect of talking about ailments and giddiness and other things.

âYou know, Iâve got a nephew like that. He oughtnât to be at his age, heâs not much over fifty but now and then heâll come over giddy all of a sudden and unless he sits down at onceâwhy you donât know, sometimes heâll pass out right on the floor. Terrible, it is. Terrible. And doctors, they donât seem able to do anything about it. Hereâs your glass of water.â

âAh,â said Miss Marple, sipping, âI feel much better.â

âBeen to the service, have you, for the poor lady as got done in, as some say, or accident as others. Iâd say itâs accident every time. But these inquests and coroners, they always want to make things look criminal, they do.â

âOh yes,â said Miss Marple. âIâve been so sorry to hear of a lot of things like that in the past. I was hearing a great deal about a girl called Nora. Nora Broad, I think.â

âAh, Nora, yes. Well, she was my cousinâs daughter. Yes. A long while ago, that was. Went off and never come back. These girls, thereâs no holding them. I said often, I did, to Nancy Broadâthatâs my cousinâI said to her, âYouâre out working all dayâ and I said âWhatâs Nora doing? You know sheâs the kind that likes the boys. Well,â I said, âthereâll be trouble. You see if there isnât.â And sure enough, I was quite right.â

âYou meanâ?â

âAh, the usual trouble. Yes, in the family way. Mind you, I donât think as my cousin Nancy knew about it yet. But of course, Iâm sixty-five and I know whatâs what and I know the way a girl looks and I think I know who it was, but Iâm not sure. I might have been wrong because he went on living in the place and he was real cut up when Nora was missing.â

âShe went off, did she?â

âWell, she accepted a lift from someoneâa stranger. Thatâs the last time she was seen. I forget the make of the car now. Some funny name it had. An Audit or something like that. Anyway, sheâd been seen once or twice in that car. And off she went in it. And it was said it was that same car that the poor girl what got herself murdered used to go riding in. But I donât think as that happened to Nora. If Noraâd been murdered, the body would have come to light by now. Donât you think so?â

âIt certainly seems likely,â said Miss Marple. âWas she a girl who did well at school and all that?â

âAh no, she wasnât. She was idle and she wasnât too clever at her books either. No. She was all for the boys from the time she was twelve-years-old onwards. I think in the end she must have gone off with someone or other for good. But she never let anyone know. She never sent as much as a postcard. Went off, I think, with someone as promised her things. You know. Another girl I knewâbut that was when I was youngâwent off with one of them Africans. He told her as his father was a Shake. Funny sort of word, but a shake I think it was. Anyway it was somewhere in Africa or in Algiers. Yes, in Algiers it was. Somewhere there. And she was going to have all sorts of wonderful things. He had six camels, the boyâs father, she said and a whole troop of horses and she was going to live in a wonderful house, she was, with carpets hanging up all over the walls, which seems a funny place to put carpets. And off she went. She come back again three years later. Yes. Terrible time, sheâd had. Terrible. They lived in a nasty little house made of earth. Yes, it was. And nothing much to eat except what they call cos-cos which I always thought was lettuce, but it seems it isnât. Something more like semolina pudding. Oh terrible it was. And in the end he said she was no good to him and heâd divorce her. He said heâd only got to say âI divorce youâ three times, and he did and walked out and somehow or other, some kind of Society out there took charge of her and paid her fare home to England. And there she was. Ah, but that was about thirty to forty years ago, that was. Now Nora, that was only about seven or eight years ago. But I expect sheâll be back one of these days, having learnt her lesson and finding out that all these fine promises didnât come to much.â

âHad she anyone to go to here except herâher motherâyour cousin, I mean? Anyone whoââ

âWell, thereâs many as was kind to her. There was the people at The Old Manor House, you know. Mrs. Glynne wasnât there then, but Miss Clotilde, she was always one to be good to the girls from school. Yes, many a nice present sheâs given Nora. She gave her a very nice scarf and a pretty dress once. Very nice, it was. A summer frock, a sort of foulard silk. Ah, she was very kind, Miss Clotilde was. Tried to make Nora take more interest in her schooling. Lots of things like that. Advised her against the way she was going on because, you seeâwell, I wouldnât like to say it, not when sheâs my cousinâs child though, mark you, my cousin is only one who married my boy cousin, that is to sayâbut I mean it was something terrible the way she went on with all the boys. Anyone could pick her up. Real sad it is. Iâd say sheâll go on the streets in the end. I donât believe she has any future but that. I donât like to say these things, but there it is. Anyway, perhaps itâs better than getting herself murdered like Miss Hunt did, what lived at The Old Manor House. Cruel, that was. They thought sheâd gone off with someone and the police, they was busy. Always asking questions and having the young men whoâd been with the girl up to help them with their enquiries and all that. Geoffrey Grant there was, Billy Thompson, and the Landfordsâ Harry. All unemployedâwith plenty of jobs going if theyâd wanted to take them. Things usednât to be like that when I was young. Girls behaved proper. And the boys knew theyâd got to work if they wanted to get anywhere.â

Miss Marple talked a little more, said that she was now quite restored, thanked Mrs. Blackett, and went out.

Her next visit was to a girl who was planting out lettuces.

âNora Broad? Oh, she hasnât been in the village for years. Went off with someone, she did. She was a great one for boys. I always wondered where sheâd end up. Did you want to see her for any particular reason?â

âI had a letter from a friend abroad,â said Miss Marple, untruthfully. âA very nice family and they were thinking of engaging a Miss Nora Broad. Sheâd been in some trouble, I think. Married someone who was rather a bad lot and had left her and gone off with another woman, and she wanted to get a job looking after children. My friend knew nothing about her, but I gathered she came from this village. So I wondered if there was anyone here who couldâwell, tell me something about her. You went to school with her, I understand?â

âOh yes, we were in the same class, we were. Mind you, I didnât approve of all Noraâs goings-on. She was boy mad, she was. Well, I had a nice boyfriend myself that I was going steady with at the time, and I told her sheâd do herself no good going off with every Tom, Dick and Harry that offered her a lift in a car or took her along to a pub where she told lies about her age, as likely as not. She was a good mature girl as looked a lot older than she was.â

âDark or fair?â

âOh, she had dark hair. Pretty hair it was. Always loose like, you know, as girls do.â

âWere the police worried about her when she disappeared?â

âYes. You see, she didnât leave no word behind. She just went out one night and didnât come back. She was seen getting into a car and nobody saw the car again and nobody saw her. Just at that time thereâd been a good many murders, you know. Not specially round here, but all over the country. The police, they were rounding up a lot of young men and boys. Thought as Nora might be a body at the time we did. But not she. She was all right. Iâd say as likely as not sheâs making a bit of money still in London or one of these big towns doing a striptease, something of that kind. Thatâs the kind she was.â

âI donât think,â said Miss Marple, âthat if itâs the same person, that sheâd be very suitable for my friend.â

âSheâd have to change a bit if she was to be suitable,â said the girl.

Eighteen

ARCHDEACON BRABAZON

When Miss Marple, slightly out of breath and rather tired, got back to the Golden Boar, the receptionist came out from her pen and across to greet her.

âOh, Miss Marple, there is someone here who wants to speak to you. Archdeacon Brabazon.â

âArchdeacon Brabazon?â Miss Marple looked puzzled.

âYes. Heâs been trying to find you. He had heard you were with this tour and he wanted to talk to you before you might have left or gone to London. I told him that some of them were going back to London by the later train this afternoon, but he is very, very anxious to speak to you before you go. I have put him in the television lounge. It is quieter there. The other is very noisy just at this moment.â

Slightly surprised, Miss Marple went to the room indicated. Archdeacon Brabazon turned out to be the elderly cleric whom she had noticed at the memorial service. He rose and came towards her.

âMiss Marple. Miss Jane Marple?â

âYes, that is my name. You wantedââ

âI am Archdeacon Brabazon. I came here this morning to attend the service for a very old friend of mine, Miss Elizabeth Temple.â

âOh yes?â said Miss Marple. âDo sit down.â

âThank you, I will, I am not quite as strong as I was.â He lowered himself carefully into a chair.

âAnd youââ

Miss Marple sat down beside him.

âYes,â she said, âyou wanted to see me?â

âWell, I must explain how that comes about. Iâm quite aware that I am a complete stranger to you. As a matter of fact I made a short visit to the hospital at Carristown, talking to the matron before going on to the church here. It was she who told me that before she died Elizabeth had asked to see a fellow member of the tour. Miss Jane Marple. And that Miss Jane Marple had visited her and sat with her just a very, very short time before Elizabeth died.â

He looked at her anxiously.

âYes,â said Miss Marple, âthat is so. It surprised me to be sent for.â

âYou are an old friend of hers?â

âNo,â said Miss Marple. âI only met her on this tour. Thatâs why I was surprised. We had expressed ideas to each other, occasionally sat next to each other in the coach, and had struck up quite an acquaintanceship. But I was surprised that she should have expressed a wish to see me when she was so ill.â

âYes. Yes, I can quite imagine that. She was, as I have said, a very old friend of mine. In fact, she was coming to see me, to visit me. I live in Fillminster, which is where your coach tour will be stopping the day after tomorrow. And by arrangement she was coming to visit me there, she wanted to talk to me about various matters about which she thought I could help her.â

âI see,â said Miss Marple. âMay I ask you a question? I hope it is not too intimate a question.â

âOf course, Miss Marple. Ask me anything you like.â

âOne of the things Miss Temple said to me was that her presence on the tour was not merely because she wished to visit historic homes and gardens. She described it by a rather unusual word to use, as a pilgrimage.â

âDid she,â said Archdeacon Brabazon. âDid she indeed now? Yes, thatâs interesting. Interesting and perhaps significant.â

âSo what I am asking you is, do you think that the pilgrimage she spoke of was her visit to you?â

âI think it must have been,â said the Archdeacon. âYes, I think so.â

âWe had been talking,â said Miss Marple, âabout a young girl. A girl called Verity.â

âAh yes. Verity Hunt.â

âI did not know her surname. Miss Temple, I think, mentioned her only as Verity.â

âVerity Hunt is dead,â said the Archdeacon. âShe died quite a number of years ago. Did you know that?â

âYes,â said Miss Marple. âI knew it. Miss Temple and I were talking about her. Miss Temple told me something that I did not know. She said she had been engaged to be married to the son of a Mr. Rafiel. Mr. Rafiel is, or again I must say was, a friend of mine. Mr. Rafiel has paid the expenses of this tour out of his kindness. I think, though, that possibly he wantedâindeed, intendedâme to meet Miss Temple on this tour. I think he thought she could give me certain information.â

âCertain information about Verity?â

âYes.â

âThat is why she was coming to me. She wanted to know certain facts.â

âShe wanted to know,â said Miss Marple, âwhy Verity broke off her engagement to marry Mr. Rafielâs son.â

âVerity,â said Archdeacon Brabazon, âdid not break off her engagement. I am certain of that. As certain as one can be of anything.â

âMiss Temple did not know that, did she?â

âNo. I think she was puzzled and unhappy about what happened and was coming to me to ask me why the marriage did not take place.â

âAnd why did it not take place?â asked Miss Marple. âPlease do not think that I am unduly curious. Itâs not idle curiosity that is driving me. I too am onânot a pilgrimageâbut what I should call a mission. I too want to know why Michael Rafiel and Verity Hunt did not marry.â

The Archdeacon studied her for a moment or two.

âYou are involved in some way,â he said. âI see that.â

âI am involved,â said Miss Marple, âby the dying wishes of Michael Rafielâs father. He asked me to do this for him.â

âI have no reason not to tell you all I know,â said the Archdeacon slowly. âYou are asking me what Elizabeth Temple would have been asking me, you are asking me something I do not know myself. Those two young people, Miss Marple, intended to marry. They had made arrangements to marry. I was going to marry them. It was a marriage, I gather, which was being kept a secret. I knew both these young people, I knew that dear child Verity from a long way back. I prepared her for confirmation, I used to hold services in Lent, for Easter, on other occasions, in Elizabeth Templeâs school. A very fine school it was, too. A very fine woman she was. A wonderful teacher with a great sense of each girlâs capabilitiesâfor what she was best fitted for in studies. She urged careers on girls she thought would relish careers, and did not force girls that she felt were not really suited to them. She was a great woman and a very dear friend. Verity was one of the most beautiful childrenâgirls, ratherâthat I have come across. Beautiful in mind, in heart, as well as in appearance. She had the great misfortune to lose her parents before she was truly adult. They were both killed in a charter plane going on a holiday to Italy. Verity went to live when she left school with a Miss Clotilde Bradbury-Scott whom you know, probably, as living here. She had been a close friend of Verityâs mother. There are three sisters, though the second one was married and living abroad, so there were only two of them living here. Clotilde, the eldest one, became extremely attached to Verity. She did everything possible to give her a happy life. She took her abroad once or twice, gave her art lessons in Italy and loved and cared for her dearly in every way. Verity, too, came to love her probably as much as she could have loved her own mother. She depended on Clotilde. Clotilde herself was an intellectual and well educated woman. She did not urge a university career on Verity, but this I gather was really because Verity did not really yearn after one. She preferred to study art and music and such subjects. She lived here at The Old Manor House and had, I think, a very happy life. She always seemed to be happy. Naturally, I did not see her after she came here since Fillminster, where I was in the cathedral, is nearly sixty miles from here. I wrote to her at Christmas and other festivals, and she remembered me always with a Christmas card. But I saw nothing of her until the day came when she suddenly turned up, a very beautiful and fully grown young woman by then, with an attractive young man whom I also happened to know slightly, Mr. Rafielâs son, Michael. They came to me because they were in love with each other and wanted to get married.â

âAnd you agreed to marry them?â

âYes, I did. Perhaps, Miss Marple, you may think that I should not have done so. They had come to me in secret, it was obvious. Clotilde Bradbury-Scott, I should imagine, had tried to discourage the romance between them. She was well within her rights in doing so. Michael Rafiel, I will tell you frankly, was not the kind of husband you would want for any daughter or relation of yours. She was too young really, to make up her mind, and Michael had been a source of trouble ever since his very young days. He had been had up before junior courts, he had had unsuitable friends, he had been drawn into various gangster activities, heâd sabotaged buildings and telephone boxes. He had been on intimate terms with various girls, had maintenance claims which he had had to meet. Yes, he was a bad lot with the girls as well as in other ways, yet he was extremely attractive and they fell for him and behaved in an extremely silly fashion. He had served two short jail sentences. Frankly, he had a criminal record. I was acquainted with his father, though I did not know him well, and I think that his father did all that he couldâall that a man of his character couldâto help his son. He came to his rescue, he got him jobs in which he might have succeeded. He paid up his debts, paid out damages. He did all this. I donât knowââ

âBut he could have done more, you think?â

âNo,â said the Archdeacon, âIâve come to an age now when I know that one must accept oneâs fellow human beings as being the kind of people and having the kind of, shall we say in modern terms, genetic makeup which gives them the characters they have. I donât think that Mr. Rafiel had affection for his son, a great affection at any time. To say he was reasonably fond of him would be the most you could say. He gave him no love. Whether it would have been better for Michael if he had had love from his father, I do not know. Perhaps it would have made no difference. As it was, it was sad. The boy was not stupid. He had a certain amount of intellect and talent. He could have done well if he had wished to do well, and had taken the trouble. But he was by natureâlet us admit it franklyâa delinquent. He had certain qualities one appreciated. He had a sense of humour, he was in various ways generous and kindly. He would stand by a friend, help a friend out of a scrape. He treated his girlfriends badly, got them into trouble as the local saying is, and then more or less abandoned them and took up with somebody else. So there I was faced with those two andâyesâI agreed to marry them. I told Verity, I told her quite frankly, the kind of boy she wanted to marry. I found that he had not tried to deceive her in any way. Heâd told her that heâd always been in trouble both with the police, and in every other way. He told her that he was going, when he married her, to turn over a new leaf. Everything would be changed. I warned her that that would not happen, he would not change. People do not change. He might mean to change. Verity, I think, knew that almost as well as I did. She admitted that she knew it. She said, âI know what Mike is like. I know heâll probably always be like it, but I love him. I may be able to help him and I may not. But Iâll take that risk.â And I will tell you this, Miss Marple. I knowânone better, I have done a lot with young people, I have married a lot of young people and I have seen them come to grief, I have seen them unexpectedly turn out wellâbut I know this and recognize it. I know when a couple are really in love with each other. And by that I do not mean just sexually attracted. There is too much talk about sex, too much attention is paid to it. I do not mean that anything about sex is wrong. That is nonsense. But sex cannot take the place of love, it goes with love but it cannot succeed by itself. To love means the words of the marriage service. For better, for worse, for richer for poorer, in sickness and in health. That is what you take on if you love and wish to marry. Those two loved each other. To love and to cherish until death do us part. And that,â said the Archdeacon, âis where my story ends. I cannot go on because I do not know what happened. I only know that I agreed to do as they asked, that I made the necessary arrangements; we settled a day, an hour, a time, a place. I think perhaps that I was to blame for agreeing to the secrecy.â

âThey didnât want anyone to know?â said Miss Marple.

âNo. Verity did not want anyone to know, and I should say most certainly Mike did not want anyone to know. They were afraid of being stopped. To Verity, I think, besides love, there was also a feeling of escape. Natural, I think, owing to the circumstances of her life. She had lost her real guardians, her parents, she had entered on her new life after their death, at an age when a school girl arrives at having a âcrushâ on someone. An attractive mistress. Anything from the games mistress to the mathematics mistress, or a prefect or an older girl. A state that does not last for very long, is merely a natural part of life. Then from that you go on to the next stage when you realize that what you want in your life is what complements yourself. A relationship between a man and a woman. You start then to look about you for a mate. The mate you want in life. And if you are wise, you take your time, you have friends, but you are looking, as the old nurses used to say to children, for Mr. Right to come along. Clotilde Bradbury-Scott was exceptionally good to Verity, and Verity, I think, gave her what I should call hero worship. She was a personality as a woman. Handsome, accomplished, interesting. I think Verity adored her in an almost romantic way and I think Clotilde came to love Verity as though she were her own daughter. And so Verity grew to maturity in an atmosphere of adoration, lived an interesting life with interesting subjects to stimulate her intellect. It was a happy life, but I think little by little she was consciousâconscious without knowing she was conscious, shall we sayâof a wish to escape. Escape from being loved. To escape, she didnât know into what or where. But she did know after she met Michael. She wanted to escape to a life where male and female come together to create the next stage of living in this world. But she knew that it was impossible to make Clotilde understand how she felt. She knew that Clotilde would be bitterly opposed to her taking her love for Michael seriously. And Clotilde, I fear, was right in her belief â¦ I know that now. He was not a husband that Verity ought to have taken or had. The road that she started out on led not to life, not to increased living and happiness. It led to shock, pain, death. You see, Miss Marple, that I have a grave feeling of guilt. My motives were good, but I didnât know what I ought to have known. I knew Verity, but I didnât know Michael. I understood Verityâs wish for secrecy because I knew what a strong personality Clotilde Bradbury-Scott had. She might have had a strong enough influence over Verity to persuade her to give up the marriage.â

âYou think then that that was what she did do? You think Clotilde told her enough about Michael to persuade her to give up the idea of marrying him?â

âNo, I do not believe that. I still do not. Verity would have told me if so. She would have got word to me.â

âWhat did actually happen on that day?â

âI havenât told you that yet. The day was fixed. The time, the hour and the place, and I waited. Waited for a bride and bridegroom who didnât come, who sent no word, no excuse, nothing. I didnât know why! I never have known why. It still seems to me unbelievable. Unbelievable, I mean, not that they did not come, that could be explicable easily enough, but that they sent no word. Some scrawled line of writing. And that is why I wondered and hoped that Elizabeth Temple, before she died, might have told you something. Given you some message perhaps for me. If she knew or had any idea that she was dying, she might have wanted to get a message to me.â

âShe wanted information from you,â said Miss Marple. âThat, I am sure, was the reason she was coming to you.â

âYes. Yes, that is probably true. It seemed to me, you see, that Verity would have said nothing to the people who could have stopped her. Clotilde and Anthea Bradbury-Scott, but because she had always been very devoted to Elizabeth Templeâand Elizabeth Temple had had great influence over herâit seems to me that she would have written and given her information of some kind.â

âI think she did,â said Miss Marple.

âInformation, you think?â

âThe information she gave to Elizabeth Temple,â said Miss Marple, âwas this. That she was going to marry Michael Rafiel. Miss Temple knew that. It was one of the things she said to me. She said: âI knew a girl called Verity who was going to marry Michael Rafielâ and the only person who could have told her that was Verity herself. Verity must have written to her or sent some word to her. And then when I said âWhy didnât she marry him?â she said: âShe died.ââ

âThen we come to a full stop,â said Archdeacon Brabazon. He sighed. âElizabeth and I know no more than those two facts. Elizabeth, that Verity was going to marry Michael. And I that those two were going to marry, that they had arranged it and that they were coming on a settled day and time. And I waited for them, but there was no marriage. No bride, no bridegroom, no word.â

âAnd you have no idea what happened?â said Miss Marple.

âI do not for one minute believe that Verity or Michael definitely parted, broke off.â

âBut something must have happened between them? Something that opened Verityâs eyes perhaps, to certain aspects of Michaelâs character and personality, that she had not realized or known before.â

âThat is not a satisfying answer because still she would have let me know. She would not have left me waiting to join them together in holy matrimony. To put the most ridiculous side of it, she was a girl with beautiful manners, well brought up. She would have sent word. No. Iâm afraid that only one thing could have happened.â

âDeath?â said Miss Marple. She was remembering that one word that Elizabeth Temple had said which had sounded like the deep tone of a bell.

âYes.â Archdeacon Brabazon sighed. âDeath.â

âLove,â said Miss Marple thoughtfully.

âBy that you meanââ he hesitated.

âItâs what Miss Temple said to me. I said âWhat killed her?â and she said âLoveâ and that love was the most frightening word in the world. The most frightening word.â

âI see,â said the Archdeacon. âI seeâor I think I see.â

âWhat is your solution?â

âSplit personality,â he sighed. âSomething that is not apparent to other people unless they are technically qualified to observe it. Jekyll and Hyde are real, you know. They were not Stevensonâs invention as such. Michael Rafiel was aâmust have been schizophrenic. He had a dual personality. I have no medical knowledge, no psychoanalytic experience. But there must have been in him the two parts of two identities. One, a well-meaning, almost lovable boy, a boy perhaps whose principal attraction was his wish for happiness. But there was also a second personality, someone who was forced by some mental deformation perhapsâsomething we as yet are not sure ofâto killânot an enemy, but the person he loved, and so he killed Verity. Not knowing perhaps why he had to or what it meant. There are very frightening things in this world of ours, mental quirks, mental disease or deformity of a brain. One of my parishioners was a very sad case in point. Two elderly women living together, pensioned. They had been friends in service together somewhere. They appeared to be a happy couple. And yet one day one of them killed the other. She sent for an old friend of hers, the vicar of her parish, and said: âI have killed Louisa. It is very sad,â she said, âbut I saw the devil looking out of her eyes and I knew I was being commanded to kill her.â Things like that make one sometimes despair of living. One says why? and how? and yet one day knowledge will come. Doctors will find out or learn just some small deformity of a chromosome or gene. Some gland that overworks or leaves off working.â

âSo you think thatâs what happened?â said Miss Marple.

âIt did happen. The body was not found, I know, for some time afterwards. Verity just disappeared. She went away from home and was not seen againâ¦.â

âBut it must have happened thenâthat very dayââ

âBut surely at the trialââ

âYou mean after the body was found, when the police finally arrested Michael?â

âHe had been one of the first, you know, to be asked to come and give assistance to the police. He had been seen about with the girl, she had been noticed in his car. They were sure all along that he was the man they wanted. He was their first suspect, and they never stopped suspecting him. The other young men who had known Verity were questioned, and one and all had alibis or lack of evidence. They continued to suspect Michael, and finally the body was found. Strangled and the head and face disfigured with heavy blows. A mad frenzied attack. He wasnât sane when he struck those blows. Mr. Hyde, let us say, had taken over.â

Miss Marple shivered.

The Archdeacon went on, his voice low and sad. âAnd yet, even now sometimes, I hope and feel that it was some other young man who killed her. Someone who was definitely mentally deranged, though no one had any idea of it. Some stranger, perhaps, whom she had met in the neighborhood. Someone who she had met by chance, who had given her a lift in a car, and thenââ He shook his head.

âI suppose that could have been true,â said Miss Marple.

âMike made a bad impression in court,â said the Archdeacon. âTold foolish and senseless lies. Lied as to where his car had been. Got his friends to give him impossible alibis. He was frightened. He said nothing of his plan to marry. I believe his Counsel was of the opinion that that would tell against himâthat she might have been forcing him to marry her and that he didnât want to. Itâs so long ago now, I remember no details. But the evidence was dead against him. He was guiltyâand he looked guilty.

âSo you see, do you not, Miss Marple, that Iâm a very sad and unhappy man. I made the wrong judgment, I encouraged a very sweet and lovely girl to go to her death, because I did not know enough of human nature. I was ignorant of the danger she was running. I believed that if she had had any fear of him, any sudden knowledge of something evil in him, she would have broken her pledge to marry him and have come to me and told me of her fear, of her knowledge of him. But nothing of that ever happened. Why did he kill her? Did he kill her because perhaps he knew she was going to have a child? Because by now he had formed a tie with some other girl and did not want to be forced to marry Verity? I canât believe it. Or was it some entirely different reason. Because she had suddenly felt a fear of him, a knowledge of danger from him, and had broken off her association with him? Did that rouse his anger, his fury, and did that lead him to violence and to killing her? One does not know.â

âYou do not know?â said Miss Marple, âbut you do still know and believe one thing, donât you?â

âWhat do you mean exactly by âbelieve?â Are you talking from the religious point of view?â

âOh no,â said Miss Marple, âI didnât mean that. I mean, there seems to be in you, or so I feel it, a very strong belief that those two loved each other, that they meant to marry, but that something happened that prevented it. Something that ended in her death, but you still really believe that they were coming to you to get married that day?â

âYou are quite right, my dear. Yes, I cannot help still believing in two lovers who wished to get married, who were ready to take each other on for better, for worse, for richer or poorer, in sickness and in health. She loved him and she would have taken him for better or for worse. As far as she had gone, she took him for worse. It brought about her death.â

âYou must go on believing as you do,â said Miss Marple. âI think, you know, that I believe it too.â

âBut then what?â

âI donât know yet,â said Miss Marple. âIâm not sure, but I think Elizabeth Temple did know or was beginning to know what happened. A frightening word, she said. Love. I thought when she spoke that what she meant was that because of a love affair Verity committed suicide. Because she found out something about Michael, or because something about Michael suddenly upset her and revolted her. But it couldnât have been suicide.â

âNo,â said the Archdeacon, âthat couldnât be so. The injuries were described very fully at the trial. You donât commit suicide by beating in your own head.â

âHorrible!â said Miss Marple. âHorrible! And you couldnât do that to anyone you loved even if you had to kill âfor love,â could you? If heâd killed her, he couldnât have done it that way. Stranglingâperhaps, but you wouldnât beat in the face and the head that you loved.â She murmured, âLove, loveâa frightening word.â

Nineteen

GOOD-BYES ARE SAID

The coach was drawn up in front of the Golden Boar on the following morning. Miss Marple had come down and was saying good-bye to various friends. She found Mrs. Riseley-Porter in a state of high indignation.

âReally, girls nowadays,â she said. âNo vigour. No stamina.â

Miss Marple looked at her enquiringly.

âJoanna, I mean. My niece.â

âOh dear. Is she not well?â

âWell, she says not. I canât see anything much the matter with her. She says sheâs got a sore throat, she feels she might have a temperature coming on. All nonsense, I think.â

âOh, Iâm very sorry,â said Miss Marple. âIs there anything I can do? Look after her?â

âI should leave her alone, if I were you,â said Mrs. Riseley-Porter. âIf you ask me, itâs all an excuse.â

Miss Marple looked enquiringly at her once more.

âGirls are so silly. Always falling in love.â

âEmlyn Price?â said Miss Marple.

âOh, so youâve noticed it too. Yes, theyâre really getting to a stage of spooning about together. I donât much care for him anyway. One of these long-haired students, you know. Always going on demos or something like that. Why canât they say demonstration properly? I hate abbreviations. And how am I going to get along? Nobody to look after me, collect my luggage, take it in, take it out. Really. Iâm paying for this complete trip and everything.â

âI thought she seemed so attentive to you,â said Miss Marple.

âWell, not the last day or two. Girls donât understand that people have to have a little assistance when they get to middle age. They seem to have some absurd ideaâshe and the Price boyâof going to visit some mountain or some landmark. About a seven or eight mile walk there and back.â

âBut surely if she has a sore throat and a temperatureâ¦.â

âYouâll see, as soon as the coach is gone the sore throat will get better and the temperature will go down,â said Mrs. Riseley-Porter. âOh dear, weâve got to get on board now. Oh, good-bye, Miss Marple, itâs nice to have met you. Iâm sorry youâre not coming with us.â

âIâm very sorry myself,â said Miss Marple, âbut really you know, Iâm not so young and vigorous as you are, Mrs. Riseley-Porter, and I really feel after all theâwell, shock and everything else the last few days, I really must have a complete twenty-four hoursâ rest.â

âWell, hope to see you somewhere in the future.â

They shook hands. Mrs. Riseley-Porter climbed into the coach.

A voice behind Miss Marpleâs shoulder said:

âBon Voyage and Good Riddance.â

She turned to see Emlyn Price. He was grinning.

âWas that addressed to Mrs. Riseley-Porter?â

âYes. Who else.â

âIâm sorry to hear that Joanna is under the weather this morning.â

Emlyn Price grinned at Miss Marple again.

âSheâll be all right,â he said, âas soon as that coach is gone.â

âOh really!â said Miss Marple, âdo you meanâ?â

âYes, I do mean,â said Emlyn Price. âJoannaâs had enough of that aunt of hers, bossing her around all the time.â

âThen you are not going in the coach either?â

âNo. Iâm staying on here for a couple of days. Iâm going to get around a bit and do a few excursions. Donât look so disapproving, Miss Marple. Youâre not really as disapproving as all that, are you?â

âWell,â said Miss Marple, âI have known such things happen in my own youth. The excuses may have been different, and I think we had less chance of getting away with things than you do now.â

Colonel and Mrs. Walker came up and shook Miss Marple warmly by the hand.

âSo nice to have known you and had all those delightful horticultural talks,â said the Colonel. âI believe the day after tomorrow weâre going to have a real treat, if nothing else happens. Really itâs too sad, this very unfortunate accident. I must say I think myself it is an accident. I really think the Coroner was going beyond everything in his feelings about this.â

âIt seems very odd,â said Miss Marple, âthat nobody has come forward, if they were up on top there, pushing about rocks and boulders and things, that they havenât come forward to say so.â

âThink theyâll be blamed, of course,â said Colonel Walker. âTheyâre going to keep jolly quiet, thatâs what theyâre going to do. Well, good-bye. Iâll send you a cutting of that magnolia highdownensis and one of the mahonia japonica too. Though Iâm not quite sure if it would do as well where you live.â

They in turn got into the coach. Miss Marple turned away. She turned to see Professor Wanstead waving to the departing coach. Mrs. Sandbourne came out, said good-bye to Miss Marple and got in the coach and Miss Marple took Professor Wanstead by the arm.

âI want you,â she said. âCan we go somewhere where we can talk?â

âYes. What about the place where we sat the other day?â

âRound here thereâs a very nice verandah place, I think.â

They walked round the corner of the hotel. There was some gay horn blowing, and the coach departed.

âI wish, in a way, you know,â said Professor Wanstead, âthat you werenât staying behind. Iâd rather have seen you safely on your way in the coach.â He looked at her sharply. âWhy are you staying here? Nervous exhaustion or something else?â

âSomething else,â said Miss Marple. âIâm not particularly exhausted, though it makes a perfectly natural excuse for somebody of my age.â

âI feel really I ought to stay here and keep an eye on you.â

âNo,â said Miss Marple, âthereâs no need to do that. There are other things you ought to be doing.â

âWhat things?â He looked at her. âHave you got ideas or knowledge?â

âI think I have knowledge, but Iâll have to verify it. There are certain things that I canât do myself. I think you will help to do them because youâre in touch with what I refer to as the authorities.â

âMeaning Scotland Yard, Chief Constables and the Governors of Her Majestyâs Prisons?â

âYes. One or other or all of them. You might have the Home Secretary in your pocket, too.â

âYou certainly do have ideas! Well, what do you want me to do?â

âFirst of all I want to give you this address.â

She took out a notebook and tore out one page and handed it to him.

âWhatâs this? Oh yes, well-known charity, isnât it?â

âOne of the better ones, I believe. They do a lot of good. You send them clothes,â said Miss Marple, âchildrenâs clothes and womenâs clothes. Coats. Pullovers, all those sort of things.â

âWell, do you want me to contribute to this?â

âNo, itâs an appeal for charity, itâs a bit of what belongs to what weâre doing. What you and I are doing.â

âIn what way?â

âI want you to make enquiries there about a parcel which was sent from here two days ago, posted from this post office.â

âWho posted itâdid you?â

âNo,â said Miss Marple. âNo. But I assumed responsibility for it.â

âWhat does that mean?â

âIt means,â said Miss Marple, smiling slightly, âthat I went into the post office here and I explained rather scattily andâwell, like the old pussy I amâthat I had very foolishly asked someone to take a parcel for me and post it, and I had put the wrong address on it. I was very upset by this. The postmistress very kindly said she remembered the parcel, but the address on it was not the one I was mentioning. It was this one, the one I have just given to you. I explained that I had been very foolish and written the wrong address on it, confusing it with another one I sometimes send things to. She told me it was too late to do anything about it now because the parcel, naturally, had gone off. I said it was quite all right, that I would send a letter to the particular charity to which the parcel had been sent, and explain that it had been addressed to them by mistake. Would they very kindly forward it on to the charity that I had meant to receive it.â

âIt seems rather a roundabout way.â

âWell,â said Miss Marple, âone has to say something. Iâm not going to do that at all. You are going to deal with the matter. Weâve got to know whatâs inside that parcel! I have no doubt you can get means.â

âWill there be anything inside the parcel to say who actually sent it?â

âI rather think not. It may have a slip of paper saying âfrom friendsâ or it may have a fictitious name and addressâsomething like Mrs. Pippin, 14 Westbourne Groveâand if anyone made enquiries there, thereâd be no person of such a name living there.â

âOh. Any other alternatives?â

âIt might possibly, most unlikely but possible, have a slip saying âFrom Miss Anthea Bradbury-Scottâââ

âDid sheâ?â

âShe took it to the post,â said Miss Marple.

âAnd you had asked her to take it there?â

âOh no,â said Miss Marple. âI hadnât asked anyone to post anything. The first I saw of the parcel was when Anthea passed the garden of the Golden Boar where you and I were sitting talking, carrying it.â

âBut you went to the post office and represented that the parcel was yours.â

âYes,â said Miss Marple, âwhich was quite untrue. But post offices are careful. And, you see, I wanted to find out where it had been sent.â

âYou wanted to find out if such a parcel had been sent, and if it had been sent by one of the Bradbury-Scottsâor especially Miss Anthea?â

âI knew it would be Anthea,â said Miss Marple, âbecause weâd seen her.â

âWell?â He took the paper from her hand. âYes, I can set this in motion. You think this parcel will be interesting?â

âI think the contents of it might be quite important.â

âYou like keeping your secrets, donât you?â said Professor Wanstead.

âNot exactly secrets,â said Miss Marple, âthey are only probabilities that I am exploring. One does not like to make definite assertions unless one has a little more definite knowledge.â

âAnything else?â

âI thinkâI think that whoeverâs in charge of these things, ought to be warned that there might be a second body to be found.â

âDo you mean a second body connected with the particular crime that we have been considering? A crime that took place ten years ago?â

âYes,â said Miss Marple. âIâm quite sure of it, as a matter of fact.â

âAnother body. Whose body?â

âWell,â said Miss Marple, âitâs only my idea so far.â

âAny idea where this body is?â

âOh! Yes,â said Miss Marple, âIâm quite sure I know where it is, but I have to have a little more time before I can tell you that.â

âWhat kind of a body? Manâs? Womanâs? Childâs? Girlâs?â

âThereâs another girl who is missing,â said Miss Marple. âA girl called Nora Broad. She disappeared from here and sheâs never been heard anymore of. I think her body might be in a particular place.â

Professor Wanstead looked at her.

âYou know, the more you say, the less I like leaving you here,â he said. âHaving all these ideasâand possibly doing something foolishâeitherââ He stopped.

âEither itâs all nonsense?ââ said Miss Marple.

âNo, no, I didnât mean that. But either you know too muchâwhich might be dangerous â¦ I think I am going to stay here to keep an eye on you.â

âNo, youâre not,â said Miss Marple. âYouâve got to go to London and set certain things moving.â

âYou spoke as though you knew a good deal now, Miss Marple.â

âI think I do know a good deal now. But I have got to be sure.â

âYes, but if you make sure, that may be the last thing you do make sure of! We donât want a third body. Yours.â

âOh, Iâm not expecting anything like that,â said Miss Marple.

âThere might be danger, you know, if any of your ideas are right. Have you suspicions of any one particular person?â

âI think I have certain knowledge as to one person. I have got to find outâI have got to stay here. You asked me once if I felt an atmosphere of evil. Well, that atmosphere is here all right, an atmosphere of evil, of danger if you likeâof great unhappiness, of fear â¦ Iâve got to do something about that. The best I can do. But an old woman like me canât do very much.â

Professor Wanstead counted under his breath. âOneâtwoâthreeâfourââ

âWhat are you counting?â asked Miss Marple.

âThe people who left in the coach. Presumably youâre not interested in them, since youâve let them go off and youâre staying here.â

âWhy should I be interested in them?â

âBecause you said Mr. Rafiel had sent you in the coach for a particular reason and sent you on this tour for a particular reason and sent you to The Old Manor House for a particular reason. Very well then. The death of Elizabeth Temple ties up with someone in the coach. Your remaining here ties up with The Old Manor House.â

âYouâre not quite right,â said Miss Marple. âThere are connections between the two. I want someone to tell me things.â

âDo you think you can make anyone tell you things?â

âI think I might. Youâll miss your train if you donât go soon.â

âTake care of yourself,â said Professor Wanstead.

âI mean to take care of myself.â

The door into the lounge opened and two people came out. Miss Cooke and Miss Barrow.

âHullo,â said Professor Wanstead, âI thought youâd gone off with the coach.â

âWell, we changed our minds at the last moment,â said Miss Cooke cheerfully. âYou know weâve just discovered that there are some very agreeable walks near here and there are one or two places Iâm very anxious to see. A church with a very unusual Saxon font. Only four or five miles away and quite easily reached by the local bus, I think. You see, itâs not only houses and gardens. Iâm very interested in church architecture.â

âSo am I,â said Miss Barrow. âThereâs also Finley Park which is a very fine piece of horticultural planting not far from here. We really thought that it would be much pleasanter to stay here for a day or two.â

âYouâre staying here at the Golden Boar?â

âYes. We were fortunate enough to be able to get a very nice double room. Really a better one than the one we have had for the last two days.â

âYou will miss your train,â said Miss Marple again.

âI wish,â said Professor Wanstead, âthat youââ

âI shall be quite all right,â said Miss Marple urgently. âSuch a kind man,â she said, as he disappeared round the side of the house, âwho really takes so much care of meâI might be a great-aunt of his or something like that.â

âItâs all been a great shock, hasnât it,â said Miss Cooke. âPerhaps you may like to come with us when we go to visit St. Martins in the Grove.â

âYouâre very kind,â said Miss Marple, âbut I donât think today I feel quite strong enough for expeditions. Perhaps tomorrow if there is anything interesting to see.â

âWell, we must leave you then.â

Miss Marple smiled at them both and went into the hotel.

Twenty

MISS MARPLE HAS IDEAS

Having had lunch in the dining room, Miss Marple went out on the terrace to drink her coffee. She was just sipping her second cup when a tall, thin figure came striding up the steps, and approached her, speaking rather breathlessly. She saw that it was Anthea Bradbury-Scott.

âOh, Miss Marple, weâve only just heard, you know, that you didnât go with the coach, after all. We thought you were going on with the tour. We had no idea you were staying on here. Both Clotilde and Lavinia sent me here to say we do so hope you will come back to The Old Manor House and stay with us. Iâm sure it will be nicer for you to be there. There are so many people coming and going here always, especially over a weekend and things like that. So weâd be very, very gladâwe really wouldâif you would come back to us.â

âOh, thatâs very kind of you,â said Miss Marple. âReally very kind, but Iâm sureâI mean, you know it was just a two-day visit. I meant originally to go off with the coach. I mean, after the two days. If it hadnât been for this very, very tragic accident butâwell, I really felt I couldnât go on any longer. I thought I must have at least, well at least one nightâs rest.â

âBut I mean it would be so much better if you came to us. Weâd try and make you comfortable.â

âOh, thereâs no question of that,â said Miss Marple. âI was extremely comfortable staying with you. Oh yes, I did enjoy it very much. Such a beautiful house. And all your things are so nice. You know, your china and glass and furniture. Itâs such a pleasure to be in a home and not a hotel.â

âThen you must come with me now. Yes, you really must. I could go and pack your things for you.â

âOhâwell, thatâs very kind of you. I can do that myself.â

âWell, shall I come and help you?â

âThat would be very kind,â said Miss Marple.

They repaired to her bedroom where Anthea, in a somewhat slapdash manner, packed Miss Marpleâs belongings together. Miss Marple, who had her own ways of folding things, had to bite her lip to keep an air of complacency on her face. Really, she thought, she canât fold anything properly.

Anthea got hold of a porter from the hotel and he carried the suitcase round the corner and down the street to The Old Manor House. Miss Marple tipped him adequately and, still uttering fussy little speeches of thanks and pleasure, rejoined the sisters.

âThe Three Sisters!â she was thinking, âhere we are again.â She sat down in the drawing room, and closed her eyes for a minute, breathing rather fast. She appeared to be somewhat out of breath. It was only natural, she felt at her age, and after all Anthea and the hotel porter had set a fast pace. But really she was trying to acquire through her closed eyes what the feeling was she had on coming into this house again. Was something in it sinister? No, not so much sinister as unhappy. Deep unhappiness. So much so it was almost frightening.

She opened her eyes again and looked at the two other occupants of the room. Mrs. Glynne had just come in from the kitchen, bearing an afternoon tea tray. She looked as she had looked all along. Comfortable, no particular emotions or feelings. Perhaps almost too devoid of them, Miss Marple thought. Had she accustomed herself, through perhaps a life of some stress and difficulty, to show nothing to the outer world, to keep a reserve and let no one know what her inner feelings were?

She looked from her to Clotilde. She had a Clytemnestra look, as she had thought before. She had certainly not murdered her husband for she had never had a husband to murder and it seemed unlikely that she had murdered the girl to whom she was said to have been extremely attached. That, Miss Marple was quite sure, was true. She had seen before how the tears had welled from Clotildeâs eyes when the death of Verity had been mentioned.

And what about Anthea? Anthea had taken that cardboard box to the post office. Anthea had come to fetch her. Antheaâshe was very doubtful about Anthea. Scatty? Too scatty for her age. Eyes that wandered and came back to you. Eyes that seemed to see things that other people might not see, over your shoulder. Sheâs frightened, thought Miss Marple. Frightened of something. What was she frightened of? Was she perhaps a mental case of some kind? Frightened perhaps of going back to some institution or establishment where she might have spent part of her life? Frightened of those two sisters of hers feeling that it was unwise for her to remain at liberty? Were they uncertain, those two, what their sister Anthea might do or say?

There was some atmosphere here. She wondered, as she sipped the last of her tea, what Miss Cooke and Miss Barrow were doing. Had they gone to visit that church or was that all talk, meaningless talk? It was odd. Odd the way they had come and looked at her at St. Mary Mead so as to know her again on the coach, but not to acknowledge that they had ever seen or met her before.

There were quite a lot of difficult things going on. Presently Mrs. Glynne removed the tea tray, Anthea went out into the garden and Miss Marple was left alone with Clotilde.

âI think,â said Miss Marple, âthat you know an Archdeacon Brabazon, do you not?â

âOh yes,â said Clotilde, âhe was in church yesterday at the service. Do you know him?â

âOh no,â said Miss Marple, âbut he did come to the Golden Boar and he came and spoke to me there. I gather he had been to the hospital and was enquiring about poor Miss Templeâs death. He wondered if Miss Temple had sent any message to him. I gather she was thinking of paying him a visit. But of course I told him that although I did go there in case I could do anything there was nothing that could be done except sit by poor Miss Templeâs bed. She was unconscious, you know. I could have done nothing to help her.â

âShe didnât sayâsay anythingâany explanation of what had happened?â asked Clotilde.

She asked without much interest. Miss Marple wondered if she felt more interest than she expressed, but on the whole she thought not. She thought Clotilde was busy with thoughts of something quite different.

âDo you think it was an accident?â Miss Marple asked, âOr do you think there is something in that story that Mrs. Riseley-Porterâs niece told? About seeing someone pushing a boulder.â

âWell, I suppose if those two said so, they must have seen it.â

âYes. They both said so, didnât they,â said Miss Marple, âthough not quite in the same terms. But perhaps thatâs quite natural.â

Clotilde looked at her curiously.

âYou seem to be intrigued by that.â

âWell, it seems so very unlikely,â said Miss Marple, âan unlikely story, unlessââ

âUnless what?â

âWell, I just wondered,â said Miss Marple.

Mrs. Glynne came into the room again.

âYou just wondered what?â she asked.

âWeâre talking about the accident, or the nonaccident,â said Clotilde.

âBut whoââ

âIt seems a very odd story that they told,â said Miss Marple again.

âThereâs something about this place,â said Clotilde suddenly. âSomething about this atmosphere. We never got over it here. Never. Never sinceâsince Verity died. Itâs years but it doesnât go away. A shadowâs here.â She looked at Miss Marple. âDonât you think so too? Donât you feel a shadow here?â

âWell, Iâm a stranger,â said Miss Marple. âItâs different for you and your sisters whoâve lived here and who knew the dead girl. She was, I gather, as Archdeacon Brabazon was sayingâa very charming and beautiful girl.â

âShe was a lovely girl. A dear child too,â said Clotilde.

âI wish Iâd known her better,â said Mrs. Glynne. âOf course I was living abroad at that time. My husband and I came home on leave once, but we were mostly in London. We didnât come down here often.â

Anthea came in from the garden. She was carrying in her hand a great bunch of lilies.

âFuneral flowers,â she said. âThatâs what we ought to have here today, isnât it? Iâll put them in a great jar. Funeral flowers,â and she laughed suddenly. A queer, hysterical little giggle.

âAnthea,â said Clotilde, âdonâtâdonât do that. Itâs notâitâs not right.â

âIâll go and put them in water,â said Anthea, cheerfully. She went out of the room.

âReally,â said Mrs. Glynne, âAnthea! I do think sheâsââ

âSheâs getting worse,â said Clotilde.

Miss Marple adopted an attitude of not listening or hearing. She picked up a small enamel box and looked at it with admiring eyes.

âSheâll probably break a vase now,â said Lavinia.

She went out of the room. Miss Marple said,

âYou are worried about your sister, about Anthea?â

âWell yes, sheâs always been rather unbalanced. Sheâs the youngest and she was rather delicate as a girl. But lately, I think, sheâs got definitely worse. She hasnât got any idea, I think, of the gravity of things. She has these silly fits of hysteria. Hysterical laughter at things one ought to be serious about. We donât want toâwell, to send her anywhere orâyou know. She ought to have treatment, I think, but I donât think she would like to go away from home. This is her home, after all. Though sometimes itâsâitâs very difficult.â

âAll life is difficult sometimes,â said Miss Marple.

âLavinia talks of going away,â said Clotilde. âShe talks of going to live abroad again. At Taormina, I think. She was there with her husband a lot and they were very happy. Sheâs been at home with us now for many years, but she seems to have this longing to get away and to travel. Sometimes I thinkâsometimes I think she doesnât like being in the same house as Anthea.â

âOh dear,â said Miss Marple. âYes, I have heard of cases like that where these difficulties do arise.â

âSheâs afraid of Anthea,â said Clotilde. âDefinitely afraid of her. And really, I keep telling her thereâs nothing to be afraid of. Antheaâs just rather silly at times. You know, has queer ideas and says queer things. But I donât think thereâs any danger of herâwell, I mean ofâoh, I donât know what I mean. Doing anything dangerous or strange or queer.â

âThereâs never been any trouble of that kind?â enquired Miss Marple.

âOh no. Thereâs never been anything. She gets nervous fits of temper sometimes and she takes rather sudden dislikes to people. Sheâs very jealous, you know, over things. Very jealous of a lot ofâwell, fuss being made over different people. I donât know. Sometimes I think weâd better sell this house and leave it altogether.â

âIt is sad for you, isnât it,â said Miss Marple. âI think I can understand that it must be very sad for you living here with the memory of the past.â

âYou understand that, do you? Yes, I can see that you do. One cannot help it. Oneâs mind goes back to that dear, lovable child. She was like a daughter to me. She was the daughter, anyway, of one of my best friends. She was very intelligent too. She was a clever girl. She was a good artist. She was doing very well with her art training and designing. She was taking up a good deal of designing. I was very proud of her. And thenâthis wretched attachment, this terrible mentally afflicted boy.â

âYou mean Mr. Rafielâs son, Michael Rafiel?â

âYes. If only heâd never come here. It just happened that he was staying in this part of the world and his father suggested he might look us up and he came and had a meal with us. He could be very charming, you know. But he always had been a sad delinquent, a bad record. Heâd been in prison twice, and a very bad history with girls. But I never thought that Verity â¦ just a case of infatuation. I suppose it happens to girls of that age. She was infatuated with him. Insisted that everything that had happened to him had not been his fault. You know the things girls say. âEveryone is against him,â thatâs what they always say. Everyoneâs against him. Nobody made allowances for him. Oh, one gets tired of hearing these things said. Canât one put a little sense into girls?â

âThey have not usually very much sense, I agree,â said Miss Marple.

âShe wouldnât listen. IâI tried to keep him away from the house. I told him he was not to come here any more. That of course was stupid. I realized that afterwards. It only meant that she went and met him outside the house. I donât know where. They had various meeting places. He used to call for her in his car at an agreed spot and bring her home late at night. Once or twice he didnât bring her home until the next day. I tried to tell them it must stop, that it must all cease, but they wouldnât listen. Verity wouldnât listen. I didnât expect him to, of course.â

âShe intended to marry him?â asked Miss Marple.

âWell, I donât think it ever got as far as that. I donât think he ever wanted to marry her or thought of such a thing.â

âI am very sorry for you,â said Miss Marple. âYou must have suffered a lot.â

âYes. The worst was having to go and identify the body. That was some time afterâafter sheâd disappeared from here. We thought of course that sheâd run away with him and we thought that weâd get news of them some time. I knew the police seemed to be taking it rather seriously. They asked Michael to go to the police station and help them with enquiries and his account of himself didnât seem to agree with what local people were saying.

âThen they found her. A long way from here. About thirty miles away. In a kind of ditchy hedgy spot down an unfrequented lane where anyone hardly ever went. Yes, I had to go and view the body in the mortuary. A terrible sight. The cruelty, the force that had been used. What did he want to do that to her for? Wasnât it enough that he strangled her? He strangled her with her own scarf. I canâtâI canât talk about it any more. I canât bear it, I canât bear it.â

Tears rained suddenly down her face.

âIâm sorry for you,â said Miss Marple. âIâm very, very sorry.â

âI believe you are.â Clotilde looked at her suddenly. âAnd even you donât know the worst of it.â

âIn what way?â

âI donât knowâI donât know about Anthea.â

âWhat do you mean about Anthea?â

âShe was so queer at that time. She wasâshe was very jealous. She suddenly seemed to turn against Verity. To look at her as though she hated her. Sometimes I thoughtâI thought perhapsâoh no, itâs an awful thing to think, you canât think that about your own sisterâshe did once attack someone. You know, she used to get these storms of rage. I wondered if it could have beenâoh, I mustnât say such things. Thereâs no question of any such thing. Please forget what Iâve said. Thereâs nothing in it, nothing at all. Butâbutâwell, sheâs not quite normal. Iâve got to face that. When she was quite young queer things happened once or twiceâwith animals. We had a parrot. A parrot that said things, silly things like parrots do say and she wrung its neck and Iâve never felt the same since. Iâve never felt that I could trust her. Iâve never felt sure. Iâve never feltâoh, goodness, Iâm getting hysterical, too.â

âCome, come,â said Miss Marple, âdonât think of these things.â

âNo. Itâs bad enough to knowâto know that Verity died. Died in that horrible way. At any rate, other girls are safe from that boy. Life sentence he got. Heâs still in prison. They wonât let him out to do anything to anyone else. Though why they couldnât bring it in as some mental troubleâdiminished responsibilityâone of these things they use nowadays. He ought to have gone to Broadmoor. Iâm sure he wasnât responsible for anything that he did.â

She got up and went out of the room. Mrs. Glynne had come back and passed her sister in the doorway.

âYou mustnât pay any attention to Clotilde,â she said. âSheâs never quite recovered from that ghastly business years ago. She loved Verity very much.â

âShe seems to be worried about your other sister.â

âAbout Anthea? Antheaâs all right. Sheâsâerâwell, sheâs scatty, you know. Sheâs a bitâhysterical. Apt to get worked up about things, and she has queer fancies, imagination sometimes. But I donât think thereâs any need for Clotilde to worry so much. Dear me, whoâs that passing the window?â

Two apologetic figures suddenly showed themselves in the french window.

âOh do excuse us,â said Miss Barrow, âwe were just walking round the house to see if we could find Miss Marple. We had heard sheâd come here with you and I wonderâoh, there you are, my dear Miss Marple. I wanted to tell you that we didnât get to that church after all this afternoon. Apparently itâs closed for cleaning, so I think we shall have to give up any other expedition today and go on one tomorrow. I do hope you donât mind us coming in this way. I did ring at the front doorbell but it didnât seem to be ringing.â

âIâm afraid it doesnât sometimes,â said Mrs. Glynne. âYou know, itâs rather temperamental. Sometimes it rings and sometimes it doesnât. But do sit down and talk to us a little. Iâd no idea that you hadnât gone with the coach.â

âNo, we thought we would do a little sightseeing round here, as we had got so far, and going with the coach would really be ratherâwell, rather painful after what has happened just a day or two ago.â

âYou must have some sherry,â said Mrs. Glynne.

She went out of the room and presently returned. Anthea was with her, quite calm now, bringing glasses and a decanter of sherry, and they sat down together.

âI canât help wanting to know,â said Mrs. Glynne, âwhat really is going to happen in this business. I mean of poor Miss Temple. I mean, it seems so very impossible to know what the police think. They still seem to be in charge, and I mean the inquest being adjourned, so obviously they are not satisfied. I donât know if thereâs anything in the nature of the wound.â

âI shouldnât think so,â said Miss Barrow. âI mean a blow on the head, bad concussionâwell, I mean that came from the boulder. The only point is, Miss Marple, if the boulder rolled itself down or somebody rolled it.â

âOh,â said Miss Cooke, âbut surely you canât think thatâwho on earth would want to roll a boulder down, do that sort of thing? I suppose there are always hooligans about. You know, some young foreigners or students. I really wonder, you know, whetherâwellââ

âYou mean,â said Miss Marple, âyou wondered if that someone was one of our fellow travellers.â

âWell, IâI didnât say that,â said Miss Cooke.

âBut surely,â said Miss Marple, âwe canât helpâwell, thinking about that sort of thing. I mean, there must be some explanation. If the police seem sure it wasnât an accident, well then it must have been done by somebody andâwell, I mean, Miss Temple was a stranger to this place here. It doesnât seem as if anyone could have done itâanyone local I mean. So it really comes back toâwell, I mean, to all of us who were in the coach, doesnât it?â

She gave a faint, rather whinnying old ladyâs laugh.

âOh surely!â

âNo, I suppose I ought not to say such things. But you know, really crimes are very interesting. Sometimes the most extraordinary things have happened.â

âHave you any definite feeling yourself, Miss Marple? I should be interested to hear,â said Clotilde.

âWell, one does think of possibilities.â

âMr. Caspar,â said Miss Cooke. âYou know, I didnât like the look of that man from the first. He looked to meâwell, I thought he might have something to do with espionage or something. You know, perhaps come to this country to look for atomic secrets or something.â

âI donât think weâve got any atomic secrets round here,â said Mrs. Glynne.

âOf course we havenât,â said Anthea. âPerhaps it was someone who was following her. Perhaps it was someone who was tracking her because she was a criminal of some kind.â

âNonsense,â said Clotilde. âShe was the Headmistress, retired, of a very well-known school, she was a very fine scholar. Why should anyone be trying to track her down?â

âOh, I donât know. She might have gone peculiar or something.â

âIâm sure,â said Mrs. Glynne, âthat Miss Marple has some ideas.â

âWell, I have some ideas,â said Miss Marple. âIt seems to me thatâwell, the only people that could be â¦ Oh dear, this is so difficult to say. But I mean there are two people who just spring into oneâs mind as possibilities logically. I mean, I donât think that itâs really so at all because Iâm sure theyâre both very nice people, but I mean thereâs nobody else really logically who could be suspected, should I say.â

âWho do you mean? This is very interesting.â

âWell, I donât think I ought to say such things. Itâs only aâsort of wild conjecture.â

âWho do you think might have rolled the boulder down? Who do you think could have been the person that Joanna and Emlyn Price saw?â

âWell, what I did think was thatâthat perhaps they hadnât seen anybody.â

âI donât quite understand,â said Anthea, âthey hadnât seen anybody?â

âWell, perhaps they might have made it all up.â

âWhatâabout seeing someone?â

âWell, itâs possible, isnât it.â

âDo you mean as a sort of joke or a sort of unkind idea? What do you mean?â

âWell, I supposeâone does hear of young people doing very extraordinary things nowadays,â said Miss Marple. âYou know, putting things in horsesâ eyes, smashing Legation windows and attacking people. Throwing stones, at people, and itâs usually being done by somebody young, isnât it? And they were the only young people, werenât they?â

âYou mean Emlyn Price and Joanna might have rolled over that boulder?â

âWell, theyâre the only sort of obvious people, arenât they?â said Miss Marple.

âFancy!â said Clotilde. âOh, I should never have thought of that. But I seeâyes, I just see that there could be something in what you say. Of course, I donât know what those two were like. I havenât been travelling with them.â

âOh, they were very nice,â said Miss Marple. âJoanna seemed to me a particularlyâyou know, capable girl.â

âCapable of doing anything?â asked Anthea.

âAnthea,â said Clotilde, âdo be quiet.â

âYes. Quite capable,â said Miss Marple. âAfter all, if youâre going to do what may result in murder, youâd have to be rather capable so as to manage not to be seen or anything.â

âThey must have been in it together, though,â suggested Miss Barrow.

âOh yes,â said Miss Marple. âThey were in it together and they told roughly the same story. They are theâwell, they are the obvious suspects, thatâs all I can say. They were out of sight of the others. All the other people were on the lower path. They could have gone up to the top of the hill, they could have rocked the boulder. Perhaps they didnât mean to kill Miss Temple specially. They may have meant it just as aâwell, just as a piece of anarchy or smashing something or someoneâanyone in fact. They rolled it over. And then of course they told the story of seeing someone there. Some rather peculiar costume or other which also sounds very unlikely andâwell, I oughtnât to say these things but I have been thinking about it.â

âIt seems to me a very interesting thought,â said Mrs. Glynne. âWhat do you think, Clotilde?â

âI think itâs a possibility. I shouldnât have thought of it myself.â

âWell,â said Miss Cooke, rising to her feet, âwe must be going back to the Golden Boar now. Are you coming with us, Miss Marple?â

âOh no,â said Miss Marple. âI suppose you donât know. Iâve forgotten to tell you. Miss Bradbury-Scott very kindly asked me to come back and stay another nightâor two nightsâhere.â

âOh, I see. Well, Iâm sure thatâll be very nice for you. Much more comfortable. They seem rather a noisy lot that have arrived at the Golden Boar this evening.â

âWonât you come round and have some coffee with us after dinner?â suggested Clotilde. âItâs quite a warm evening. We canât offer you dinner because Iâm afraid we havenât got enough in the house, but if youâll come in and have some coffee with usâ¦.â

âThat would be very nice,â said Miss Cooke. âYes, we will certainly avail ourselves of your hospitality.â

Twenty-one

THE CLOCK STRIKES THREE

I

Miss Cooke and Miss Barrow arrived very promptly at 8:45. One wore beige lace and the other one a shade of olive green. During dinner Anthea had asked Miss Marple about these two ladies.

âIt seems very funny of them,â she said, âto want to stay behind.â

âOh, I donât think so,â said Miss Marple. âI think it is really quite natural. They have a rather exact plan, I imagine.â

âWhat do you mean by a plan?â asked Mrs. Glynne.

âWell, I should think they are always prepared for various eventualities and have a plan for dealing with them.â

âDo you mean,â said Anthea, with some interest, âdo you mean that they had a plan for dealing with murder?â

âI wish,â said Mrs. Glynne, âthat you wouldnât talk of poor Miss Templeâs death as murder.â

âBut of course itâs murder,â said Anthea. âAll I wonder is who wanted to murder her? I should think probably some pupil of hers at the school who always hated her and had it in for her.â

âDo you think hate can last as long as that?â asked Miss Marple.

âOh, I should think so. I should think you could hate anyone for years.â

âNo,â said Miss Marple, âI think hate would die out. You could try and keep it up artificially, but I think you would fail. Itâs not as strong a force as love,â she added.

âDonât you think that Miss Cooke or Miss Barrow or both of them might have done the murder?â

âWhy should they?â said Mrs. Glynne. âReally, Anthea! They seemed very nice women to me.â

âI think thereâs something rather mysterious about them,â said Anthea. âDonât you, Clotilde?â

âI think perhaps youâre right,â said Clotilde. âThey seemed to me to be slightly artificial, if you know what I mean.â

âI think thereâs something very sinister about them,â said Anthea.

âYouâve got such an imagination always,â said Mrs. Glynne. âAnyway, they were walking along the bottom path, werenât they? You saw them there, didnât you?â she said to Miss Marple.

âI canât say that I noticed them particularly,â said Miss Marple. âIn fact, I had no opportunity of doing so.â

âYou meanâ?â

âShe wasnât there,â said Clotilde. âShe was here in our garden.â

âOh, of course. I forgot.â

âA very nice, peaceful day it was,â said Miss Marple. âI enjoyed it very much. Tomorrow morning I would like to go out and look again at that mass of white flowers coming into bloom at the end of the garden near that raised up mound. It was just beginning to come out the other day. It must be a mass of bloom now. I shall always remember that as part of my visit here, you know.â

âI hate it,â said Anthea. âI want it taken away. I want to build up a greenhouse again there. Surely if we save enough money we can do that, Clotilde?â

âWeâll leave that alone,â said Clotilde. âI donât want that touched. What use is a greenhouse to us now? It would be years before grapes would bear fruit again.â

âCome,â said Mrs. Glynne, âwe canât go on arguing over that. Let us go into the drawing room. Our guests will be coming shortly for coffee.â

It was then that the guests had arrived. Clotilde brought in the tray of coffee. She poured out the cups and distributed them. She placed one before each guest and then brought one to Miss Marple. Miss Cooke leaned forward.

âOh, do forgive me, Miss Marple, but really, do you know, I shouldnât drink that if I were you. Coffee, I mean, at this time of night. You wonât sleep properly.â

âOh, do you think so?â said Miss Marple. âI am quite used to coffee in the evening.â

âYes, but this is very strong, good coffee. I should advise you not to drink it.â

Miss Marple looked at Miss Cooke. Miss Cookeâs face was very earnest, her fair, unnatural-looking hair flopped over one eye. The other eye blinked slightly.

âI see what you mean,â said Miss Marple. âPerhaps you are right. You know something, I gather, about diet.â

âOh yes, I make quite a study of it. I had some training in nursing, you know, and one thing and another.â

âIndeed.â Miss Marple pushed the cup away slightly. âI suppose there is no photograph of this girl?â she asked. âVerity Hunt, or whatever her name was? The Archdeacon was talking about her. He seemed to have been very fond of her.â

âI think he was. He was fond of all young people,â said Clotilde.

She got up, went across the room and lifted the lid of a desk. From that she brought a photograph and brought it over for Miss Marple to see.

âThat was Verity,â she said.

âA beautiful face,â said Miss Marple. âYes, a very beautiful and unusual face. Poor child.â

âItâs dreadful nowadays,â said Anthea, âthese things seem to be happening the whole time. Girls going out with every kind of young man. Nobody taking any trouble to look after them.â

âThey have to look after themselves nowadays,â said Clotilde, âand theyâve no idea of how to do it, heaven help them!â

She stretched out a hand to take back the photograph from Miss Marple. As she did so her sleeve caught the coffee cup and knocked it to the floor.

âOh dear!â said Miss Marple. âWas that my fault? Did I jog your arm?â

âNo,â said Clotilde, âit was my sleeve. Itâs rather a floating sleeve. Perhaps you would like some hot milk, if you are afraid to take coffee?â

âThat would be very kind,â said Miss Marple. âA glass of hot milk when I go to bed would be very soothing indeed, and always gives one a good night.â

After a little more desultory conversation, Miss Cooke and Miss Barrow took their departure. A rather fussy departure in which first one and then the other came back to collect some article theyâd left behind. A scarf, a handbag and a pocket handkerchief.

âFuss, fuss, fuss,â said Anthea, when they had departed.

âSomehow,â said Mrs. Glynne, âI agree with Clotilde that those two donât seem real, if you know what I mean,â she said to Miss Marple.

âYes,â said Miss Marple, âI do rather agree with you. They donât seem very real. I have wondered about them a good deal. Wondered, I mean, why they came on this tour and if they were really enjoying it. And what was their reason for coming.â

âAnd have you discovered the answers to all those things?â asked Clotilde.

âI think so,â said Miss Marple. She sighed. âIâve discovered the answers to a lot of things,â she said.

âUp to now I hope youâve enjoyed yourself,â said Clotilde.

âI am glad to have left the tour now,â said Miss Marple. âI donât think I should have enjoyed much more of it.â

âNo. I can quite understand that.â

Clotilde fetched a glass of hot milk from the kitchen and accompanied Miss Marple up to her room.

âIs there anything else I can get you?â she asked. âAnything at all?â

âNo, thank you,â said Miss Marple. âI have everything I want. I have my little night bag here, you see, so I need not do anymore unpacking. Thank you,â she said, âit is very kind of you and your sisters to put me up again tonight.â

âWell, we couldnât do much less, having had Mr. Rafielâs letter. He was a very thoughtful man.â

âYes,â said Miss Marple, âthe kind of man whoâwell, thinks of everything. A good brain, I should think.â

âI believe he was a very noted financier.â

âFinancially and otherwise, he thought of a lot of things,â said Miss Marple. âOh well, I shall be glad to get to bed. Good night, Miss Bradbury-Scott.â

âShall I send you breakfast up in the morning, youâd like to have it in bed?â

âNo, no, I wouldnât put you out for the world. No, no, I would rather come down. A cup of tea, perhaps, would be very nice, but I want to go out in the garden. I particularly want to see that mound all covered with white flowers, so beautiful and so triumphantââ

âGood night,â said Clotilde, âsleep well.â

II

In the hall of The Old Manor House the grandfather clock at the bottom of the stairs struck two oâclock. The clocks in the house did not all strike in unison and some of them, indeed, did not strike at all. To keep a house full of antique clocks in working order was not easy. At three oâclock the clock on the first floor landing struck a soft-chimed three oâclock. A faint chink of light showed through the hinge of the door.

Miss Marple sat up in bed and put her fingers on the switch of the electric lamp by her bed. The door opened very softly. There was no light outside now but the soft footstep came through the door into the room. Miss Marple switched the light on.

âOh,â she said, âitâs you, Miss Bradbury-Scott. Is there anything special?â

âI just came to see if you wanted anything,â said Miss Bradbury-Scott.

Miss Marple looked at her. Clotilde had on a long purple robe. What a handsome woman she was, thought Miss Marple. Her hair framing her forehead, a tragic figure, a figure of drama. Again Miss Marple thought of Greek plays. Clytemnestra again.

âYouâre sure there is nothing I can bring you?â

âNo, thank you,â said Miss Marple. âIâm afraid,â she said apologetically, âthat I have not drunk my milk.â

âOh dear, why not?â

âI did not think it would be very good for me,â said Miss Marple.

Clotilde stood there, at the foot of the bed, looking at her.

âNot wholesome, you know,â said Miss Marple.

âJust what do you mean by that?â Clotildeâs voice was harsh now.

âI think you know what I mean,â said Miss Marple. âI think youâve known all the evening. Perhaps before that.â

âI have no idea what you are talking about.â

âNo?â There was a faint satirical note to the questioning monosyllable.

âI am afraid the milk is cold now. I will take it away and get you some hot.â

Clotilde stretched out a hand and took the glass of milk from the bedside.

âDonât trouble yourself,â said Miss Marple. âEven if you brought it me, I should not drink it.â

âI really cannot understand the point of what youâre saying. Really,â said Clotilde, looking at her. âWhat a very extraordinary person you are. What sort of a woman are you? Why are you talking like this? Who are you?â

Miss Marple pulled down the mass of pink wool that encircled her head, a pink wool scarf of the same kind that she had once worn in the West Indies.

âOne of my names,â she said, âis Nemesis.â

âNemesis? And what does that mean?â

âI think you know,â said Miss Marple. âYou are a very well educated woman. Nemesis is long delayed sometimes, but it comes in the end.â

âWhat are you talking about?â

âAbout a very beautiful girl whom you killed,â said Miss Marple.

âWhom I killed? What do you mean?â

âI mean the girl Verity.â

âAnd why should I kill her?â

âBecause you loved her,â said Miss Marple.

âOf course I loved her. I was devoted to her. And she loved me.â

âSomebody said to me not very long ago that love was a very frightening word. It is a frightening word. You loved Verity too much. She meant everything in the world to you. She was devoted to you until something else came into her life. A different kind of love came into her life. She fell in love with a boy, a young man. Not a very suitable one, not a very good specimen, not anyone with a good record, but she loved him and he loved her and she wanted to escape. To escape from the burden of the bondage of love she was living in with you. She wanted a normal womanâs life. To live with the man of her choice, to have children by him. She wanted marriage and the happiness of normality.â

Clotilde moved. She came to a chair and sat down in it, staring at Miss Marple.

âSo,â she said, âyou seem to understand very well.â

âYes, I do understand.â

âWhat you say is quite true. I shanât deny it. It doesnât matter if I do or do not deny it.â

âNo,â said Miss Marple, âyou are quite right there. It will not matter.â

âDo you know at allâcan you imagineâhow I have suffered?â

âYes,â said Miss Marple, âI can imagine it. Iâve always been able to imagine things.â

âDid you imagine the agony, the agony of thinking, of knowing you are going to lose the thing you love best in the world. And I was losing it to a miserable, depraved delinquent. A man unworthy of my beautiful, splendid girl. I had to stop it. I had toâI had to.â

âYes,â said Miss Marple. âSooner than let the girl go, you killed her. Because you loved her, you killed her.â

âDo you think I could ever do a thing like that? Do you think I could strangle the girl I loved? Do you think I could bash her face in, crush her head to a pulp? Nothing but a vicious, depraved man would do a thing like that.â

âNo,â said Miss Marple, âyou wouldnât do that. You loved her and you would not be able to do that.â

âWell then, you see, you are talking nonsense.â

âYou didnât do that to her. The girl that happened to was not the girl you loved. Verityâs here still, isnât she? Sheâs here in the garden. I donât think you strangled her. I think you gave her a drink of coffee or of milk, you gave her a painless overdose of sleeping stuff. And then when she was dead, you took her out into the garden, you pulled aside the fallen bricks of the greenhouse, and you made a vault for her there, under the floor with the bricks, and covered it over. And then the polygonum was planted there and has flowered ever since, growing bigger and stronger every year. Verity has remained here with you. You never let her go.â

âYou fool! You crazy old fool! Do you think you are ever going to get away to tell this story?â

âI think so,â said Miss Marple. âIâm not quite sure of it. You are a strong woman, a great deal stronger than I am.â

âIâm glad you appreciate that.â

âAnd you wouldnât have any scruples,â said Miss Marple. âYou know one doesnât stop at one murder. I have noticed that in the course of my life and in what I have observed of crime. You killed two girls, didnât you? You killed the girl you loved and you killed a different girl.â

âI killed a silly little tramp, an adolescent tart. Nora Broad. How did you know about her?â

âI wondered,â said Miss Marple. âI didnât think from what I saw of you that you could have borne to strangle and disfigure the girl you loved. But another girl disappeared also about that time, a girl whose body has never been found. But I thought the body had been found, only they hadnât known that the body was Nora Broadâs. It was dressed in Verityâs clothes, it was identified as Verity by the person who would be the first applied to, the person who knew her better than anyone else. You had to go and say if the body found was the body of Verity. You recognized it. You said that that dead body was Verityâs.â

âAnd why should I do that?â

âBecause you wanted the boy who had taken Verity away from you, the boy whom Verity had loved and who had loved Verity, you wanted him tried for murder. And so you hid that second body in a place where it would not be too easily discovered. When that was discovered, it would be thought to be the wrong girl. You would make sure that it was identified in the way you wanted. You dressed it in Verityâs clothes, put her handbag there; a letter or two, a bangle, a little cross on a chainâyou disfigured her face.

âA week ago you committed a third murder, the murder of Elizabeth Temple. You killed her because she was coming to this part of the world, and you were afraid of what she might have known, from what Verity might have written to her or told her, and you thought that if Elizabeth Temple got together with Archdeacon Brabazon, they might with what they both knew come at some appraisal of the truth. Elizabeth Temple must not be allowed to meet the Archdeacon. You are a very powerful woman. You could have rolled that boulder down the hillside. It must have taken some doing, but you are a very strong woman.â

âStrong enough to deal with you,â said Clotilde.

âI donât think,â said Miss Marple, âthat you will be allowed to do that.â

âWhat do you mean, you miserable, shrivelled up old woman?â

âYes,â said Miss Marple, âIâm an elderly pussy and I have very little strength in my arms or my legs. Very little strength anywhere. But I am in my own way an emissary of justice.â

Clotilde laughed, âAnd whoâll stop me from putting an end to you?â

âI think,â said Miss Marple, âmy guardian angel.â

âTrusting to your guardian angel, are you?â said Clotilde, and laughed again.

She advanced towards the bed.

âPossibly two guardian angels,â said Miss Marple. âMr. Rafiel always did things on a lavish scale.â

Her hand slipped under the pillow and out again. In it was a whistle which she put to her lips. It was something of a sensation in whistles. It had the shrill fury which would attract a policeman from the end of a street. Two things happened almost simultaneously. The door of the room opened. Clotilde turned. Miss Barrow was standing in the doorway. At the same moment the large wardrobe hanging cupboard opened and Miss Cooke stepped out of it. There was a grim air of professionalism about them both which was very noticeable, in contrast to their pleasant social behaviour a little earlier in the evening.

âTwo guardian angels,â said Miss Marple happily. âMr. Rafiel has done me very proud! as one used to say.â

Twenty-two

MISS MARPLE TELLS HER STORY

âWhen did you find out,â asked Professor Wanstead, âthat those two women were private agents accompanying you for your protection?â

He leaned forward in his chair looking thoughtfully at the white-haired old lady who sat in an upright position in the chair opposite him. They were in an official Government building in London, and there were four other persons present.

An official from the Public Prosecutorâs Office; the Assistant Commissioner of Scotland Yard, Sir James Lloyd, the Governor of Manstone Prison, Sir Andrew McNeil. The fourth person was the Home Secretary.

âNot until the last evening,â said Miss Marple. âI wasnât actually sure until then. Miss Cooke had come to St. Mary Mead and I found out fairly quickly that she was not what she represented herself to be, which was a woman knowledgeable in gardening who had come there to help a friend with her garden. So I was left with the choice of deciding what her real object had been, once she had acquainted herself with my appearance, which was obviously the only thing she could have come for. When I recognized her again, on the coach, I had to make up my mind if she was accompanying the tour in the rÃ´le of guardianship, or whether those two women were enemies enlisted by what I might call the other side.

âI was only really sure that last evening when Miss Cooke prevented me, by very distinct words of warning, from drinking the cup of coffee that Clotilde Bradbury-Scott had just set down in front of me. She phrased it very cleverly, but the warning was clearly there. Later, when I was wishing those two good night, one of them took my hand in both of hers giving me a particularly friendly and affectionate handshake. And in doing so she passed something into my hand, which, when I examined it later, I found to be a high-powered whistle. I took it to bed with me, accepted the glass of milk which was urged upon me by my hostess, and wished her good night, being careful not to change my simple and friendly attitude.â

âYou didnât drink the milk?â

âOf course not,â said Miss Marple. âWhat do you take me for?â

âI beg your pardon,â said Professor Wanstead. âIt surprises me that you didnât lock your door.â

âThat would have been quite the wrong thing to do,â said Miss Marple. âI wanted Clotilde Bradbury-Scott to come in. I wanted to see what she would say or do. I thought it was almost certain that she would come in when sufficient time had elapsed, to make sure that I had drunk the milk, and was in an unconscious sleep from which presumably I would not have woken up again.â

âDid you help Miss Cooke to conceal herself in the wardrobe?â

âNo. It was a complete surprise when she came out of that suddenly. I suppose,â said Miss Marple thoughtfully, thinking it over, âI suppose she slipped in there just when I had gone down the passage to theâerâto the bathroom.â

âYou knew the two women were in the house?â

âI thought they would be at hand somewhere after theyâd given me the whistle. I do not think it was a difficult house to which to gain access, there were no shuttered windows or burglar alarms or anything of that kind. One of them came back on the pretext of having left a handbag and a scarf. Between them they probably managed to leave a window unfastened, and I should imagine they came back into the house almost as soon as they left it, while the inhabitants inside were going up to bed.â

âYou took a big risk, Miss Marple.â

âI hoped for the best,â said Miss Marple. âOne cannot go through life without attracting certain risks if they are necessary.â

âYour tip about the parcel dispatched to that charity, by the way, was entirely successful. It contained a brand new brightly coloured manâs polo-necked jumper in scarlet and black checks. Most noticeable. What made you think of that?â

âWell,â said Miss Marple, âthat was really very simple. The description that Emlyn and Joanna gave of the figure they had seen made it seem almost certain that these very bright coloured and noticeable clothes were meant to be noticed, and that therefore it would be very important that they should not be hidden locally or kept among the personâs own belongings. They must be got out of the way as soon as could be. And really there is only one way successfully of disposing of something. That is through the general post. Anything in the nature of clothes can be very easily dispatched to charities. Think how pleased the people who collect winter garments for Unemployed Mothers, or whatever the name of the charity, would be to find a nearly brand new woollen jumper. All I had to do was to find out the address where it had been sent.â

âAnd you asked them that at the post office?â The Home Secretary looked slightly shocked.

âNot directly, of course. I mean, I had to be a little flustered and explain how Iâd put the wrong address on some clothes that I was sending to a charity and could they by any chance tell me if the parcel one of my kind hostesses had brought up there, had been sent off. And a very nice woman there did her best and remembered that it was not the address I was hoping it had been sent to, and she gave me the address that she had noted. She had no suspicion, I think, that I had any wish for the information apart from beingâwell, rather muddleheaded, elderly, and very worried about where my parcel of worn clothes had gone.â

âAh,â said Professor Wanstead, âI see you are an actress, Miss Marple, as well as an avenger.â Then he said, âWhen did you first begin to discover what had happened ten years ago?â

âTo begin with,â said Miss Marple, âI found things very difficult, almost impossible. In my mind I was blaming Mr. Rafiel for not having made things clear to me. But I see now that heâd been very wise not to do so. Really, you know, he was extraordinary clever. I can see why he was such a big financier and made so much money so easily. He laid his plans so well. He gave me just enough information in small packets each time. I was, as it were, directed. First my guardian angels were alerted to note what I looked like. Then I was directed on the tour and to the people on it.â

âDid you suspect, if I may use that word, anyone on the tour at first?â

âOnly as possibilities.â

âNo feeling of evil?â

âAh, you have remembered that. No, I did not think there was any definite atmosphere of evil. I was not told who my contact was there, but she made herself known to me.â

âElizabeth Temple?â

âYes. It was like a searchlight,â said Miss Marple, âilluminating things on a dark night. So far, you see, I had been in the dark. There were certain things that must be, must logically be, I mean, because of what Mr. Rafiel had indicated. There must be somewhere a victim and somewhere a murderer. Yes, a killer was indicated because that was the only liaison that had existed between Mr. Rafiel and myself. There had been a murder in the West Indies. Both he and I had been involved in it and all he knew of me was my connection with that. So it could not be any other type of crime. And it could not, either, be a casual crime. It must be, and show itself definitely to be, the handiwork of someone who had accepted evil. Evil instead of good. There seemed to be two victims indicated. There must be someone who had been killed and there must be clearly a victim of injustice. A victim who had been accused of a crime he or she had not committed. So now, while I pondered these things, I had no light upon them until I talked to Miss Temple. She was very intense, very compelling. There came the first link which I had with Mr. Rafiel. She spoke of a girl she had known, a girl who had once been engaged to Mr. Rafielâs son. Here then was my first ray of light. Presently she also told me that the girl had not married him. I asked why not and she said âbecause she died.â I asked then how she died, what had killed her, and she said very strongly, very compellinglyâI can hear her voice still, it was like the sound of a deep bellâshe said Love. And she said after that âthe most frightening word there can be is Love.â I did not know then exactly what she meant. In fact the first idea that came to me was that the girl had committed suicide as a result of an unhappy love affair. It can happen often enough, and a very sad tragedy it is when it does happen. That was the most I knew then. That and the fact that the journey she herself was engaged upon was no mere pleasure tour. She was going, she told me, on a pilgrimage. She was going to some place or to some person. I did not learn then who the person was, that only came later.â

âArchdeacon Brabazon?â

âYes. I had no idea then of his existence. But from then on I felt that the chief charactersâthe chief actorsâin the drama, whichever way you like to put it, were not on the tour. They were not members of the coach party. I hesitated just for a short time, hesitated over some particular persons. I hesitated, considering Joanna Crawford and Emlyn Price.â

âWhy fix on them?â

âBecause of their youth,â said Miss Marple. âBecause youth is so often associated with suicide, with violence, with intense jealousy and tragic love. A man kills his girlâit happens. Yes, my mind went to them but it did not seem to me there was any association there. No shadow of evil, of despair, of misery. I used the idea of them later as a kind of false pointer when we were drinking sherry at The Old Manor House that last evening. I pointed out how they could be the most easy suspects in the death of Elizabeth Temple. When I see them again,â said Miss Marple, punctiliously, âI shall apologize to them for having used them as useful characters to distract attention from my real ideas.â

âAnd the next thing was the death of Elizabeth Temple?â

âNo,â said Miss Marple. âActually the next thing was my arrival at The Old Manor House. The kindness of my reception and taking up my stay there under their hospitable roof. That again had been arranged by Mr. Rafiel. So I knew that I must go there, but not for what reason I was to go there. It might be merely a place where more information would come to me to lead me onwards in my quest. I am sorry,â Miss Marple said, suddenly becoming her normal apologetic and slightly fussy self, âI am talking at much too great a length. I really must not inflict on you all that I thought andâ¦.â

âPlease go on,â said Professor Wanstead. âYou may not know it but what you are telling me is particularly interesting to me. It ties up with so much I have known and seen in the work I do. Go on giving me what you felt.â

âYes, go on,â said Sir Andrew McNeil.

âIt was feeling,â said Miss Marple. âIt wasnât really, you know, logical deduction. It was based on a kind of emotional reaction or susceptibility toâwell, I can only call it atmosphere.â

âYes,â said Wanstead, âthere is atmosphere. Atmosphere in houses, atmosphere in places, in the garden, in the forest, in a public house, in a cottage.â

âThe three sisters. That is what I thought and felt and said to myself when I went into The Old Manor House. I was so kindly received by Lavinia Glynne. Thereâs something about the phraseâthe three sistersâthat springs up in your mind as sinister. It combines with the three sisters in Russian literature, the three witches on Macbethâs heath. It seemed to me that there was an atmosphere there of sorrow, of deep felt unhappiness, also an atmosphere of fear and a kind of struggling different atmosphere which I can only describe as an atmosphere of normality.â

âYour last word interests me,â said Wanstead.

âIt was due, I think, to Mrs. Glynne. She was the one who came to meet me when the coach arrived and explained the invitation. She was an entirely normal and pleasant woman, a widow. She was not very happy, but when I say she was not very happy it was nothing to do with sorrow or deep unhappiness, it was just that she had the wrong atmosphere for her own character. She took me back with her and I met the other two sisters. The next morning I was to hear from an aged housemaid who brought my early morning tea, a story of past tragedy, of a girl who had been killed by her boyfriend. Of several other girls in the neighbourhood whoâd fallen victims to violence, or sexual assault. I had to make my second appraisal. I had dismissed the people in the coach as not being personally concerned in my search. Somewhere still there was a killer. I had to ask myself if one of the killers could be here. Here in this house where I had been sent, Clotilde, Lavinia, Anthea. Three names of three weird sisters, three happyâunhappyâsufferingâfrightenedâwhat were they? My attention was caught first by Clotilde. A tall, handsome woman. A personality. Just as Elizabeth Temple had been a personality. I felt that here where the field was limited, I must at least sum up what I could about the three sisters. Three Fates. Who could be a killer? What kind of a killer? What kind of a killing? I could feel then rising up rather slowly, rather slowly like a miasma does, an atmosphere. I donât think there is any other word that expresses it except evil. Not necessarily that any of these three was evil, but they were certainly living in an atmosphere where evil had happened, had left its shadow or was still threatening them. Clotilde, the eldest, was the first one I considered. She was handsome, she was strong, she was, I thought, a woman of intense emotional feeling. I saw her, I will admit, as a possible Clytemnestra. I had recently,â Miss Marple dropped into her everyday tones, âbeen taken very kindly to a Greek play performed at a well-known boysâ public school not far from my home. I had been very, very impressed by the acting of the Agamemnon and particularly the performance of the boy who had played Clytemnestra. A very remarkable performance. It seemed to me that in Clotilde I could imagine a woman who could plan and carry out the killing of a husband in his bath.â

For a moment Professor Wanstead had all he could do to repress a laugh. It was the seriousness of Miss Marpleâs tone. She gave him a slight twinkle from her eyes.

âYes, it sounds rather silly, does it not, said like that? But I could see her that way, playing that part, that is to say. Very unfortunately, she had no husband. She had never had a husband, and therefore did not kill a husband. Then I considered my guide to the house. Lavinia Glynne. She seemed an extremely nice, wholesome and pleasant woman. But alas, certain people who have killed have produced much that effect on the world round them. They have been charming people. Many murderers have been delightful and pleasant men and people have been astonished. They are what I call the respectable killers. The ones who would commit murder from entirely utilitarian motives. Without emotion, but to gain a required end. I didnât think it was very likely and I should be highly surprised if it was so, but I could not leave out Mrs. Glynne. She had had a husband. She was a widow and had been a widow for some years. It could be. I left it at that. And then I came to the third sister. Anthea. She was a disquieting personality. Badly coordinated, it seemed to me, scatterbrained, and in a condition of some emotion which I thought on the whole was fear. She was frightened of something. Intensely frightened of something. Well, that could fit in too. If she had committed a crime of some kind, a crime which she had thought was finished with and past, there might have been some recrudescence, some raising up of old problems, something perhaps connected with the Elizabeth Temple enquiries; she might have felt fear that an old crime would be revived or discovered. She had a curious way of looking at you, and then looking sharply from side to side over one shoulder as though she saw something standing behind her. Something that made her afraid. So she too was a possible answer. A possibly slightly mentally unhinged killer who could have killed because she considered herself persecuted. Because she was afraid. These were only ideas. They were only a rather more pronounced assessment of possibilities that I had already gone through on the coach. But the atmosphere of the house was on me more than ever. The next day I walked in the garden with Anthea. At the end of the principal grass path was a mound. A mound created by the falling down of a former greenhouse. Owing to a lack of repairs and of gardeners at the end of the war it had fallen into disuse, come to pieces, bricks had been piled up surmounted with earth and turf, and had been planted with a certain creeper. A creeper well known when you want to hide or cover some rather ugly pieces of building in your garden. Polygonum it is called. One of the quickest flowering shrubs which swallows and kills and dries up and gets rid of everything it grows over. It grows over everything. It is in a way a rather frightening plant. It has beautiful white flowers, it can look very lovely. It was not yet in bloom but it was going to be. I stood there with Anthea, and she seemed to be desperately unhappy over the loss of the greenhouse. She said it had had such lovely grapes, it seemed to be the thing she remembered most about the garden when she had been a child there. And she wanted, she wanted desperately to have enough money so as to dig up the mound, level the ground and rebuild the greenhouse and stock it with muscat grapes and peaches as the old greenhouse had been. It was a terrible nostalgia for the past she was feeling. It was more than that. Again, very clearly, I felt an atmosphere of fear. Something about the mound made her frightened. I couldnât then think what it was. You know the next thing that happened. It was Elizabeth Templeâs death and there was no doubt from the story told by Emlyn Price and Joanna Crawford that there could be only one conclusion. It was not accident. It was deliberate murder.

âI think it was from then on,â said Miss Marple, âthat I knew. I came to the conclusion there had been three killings. I heard the full story of Mr. Rafielâs son, the delinquent boy, the exjailbird and I thought that he was all those things, but none of them showed him as being a killer or likely to be a killer. All the evidence was against him. There was no doubt in anyoneâs mind that he had killed the girl whose name I had now learned as being Verity Hunt. But Archdeacon Brabazon put the final crown on the business, as it were. He had known those two young people. They had come to him with their story of wanting to get married and he had taken it upon himself to decide that they should get married. He thought that it was not perhaps a wise marriage, but it was a marriage that was justified by the fact that they both loved each other. The girl loved the boy with what he called a true love. A love as true as her name. And he thought that the boy, for all his bad sexual reputation, had truly loved the girl and had every intention of being faithful to her and trying to reform some of his evil tendencies. The Archdeacon was not optimistic. He did not, I think, believe it would be a thoroughly happy marriage, but it was to his mind what he called a necessary marriage. Necessary because if you love enough you will pay the price, even if the price is disappointment and a certain amount of unhappiness. But one thing I was quite sure of. That disfigured face, that battered-in head could not have been the action of a boy who really loved the girl. This was not a story of sexual assault. I was ready to take the Archdeaconâs word for that. But I knew, too, that Iâd got the right clue, the clue that was given me by Elizabeth Temple. She had said that the cause of Verityâs death was Loveâone of the most frightening words there is.

âIt was quite clear then,â said Miss Marple. âI think Iâd known for some time really. It was just the small things that hadnât fitted in, but now they did. They fitted in with what Elizabeth Temple had said. The cause of Verityâs death. She had said first the one word âLoveâ and then that âLove could be the most frightening word there was.â It was all mapped out so plainly then. The overwhelming love that Clotilde had had for this girl. The girlâs hero worship of her, dependency on her, and then as she grew a little older, her normal instincts came into play. She wanted Love. She wanted to be free to love, to marry, to have children. And along came the boy that she could love. She knew that he was unreliable, she knew he was what was technically called a bad lot, but that,â said Miss Marple, in a more ordinary tone of voice, âis not what puts any girl off a boy. No. Young women like bad lots. They always have. They fall in love with bad lots. They are quite sure they can change them. And the nice, kind, steady, reliable husbands got the answer, in my young days, that one would be âa sister to them,â which never satisfied them at all. Verity fell in love with Michael Rafiel, and Michael Rafiel was prepared to turn over a new leaf and marry this girl and was sure he would never wish to look at another girl again. I donât say this would have been a happy-ever-after thing, but it was, as the Archdeacon said quite surely, it was real love. And so they planned to get married. And I think Verity wrote to Elizabeth and told her that she was going to marry Michael Rafiel. It was arranged in secret because I think Verity did realize that what she was doing was essentially an escape. She was escaping from a life that she didnât want to live any longer, from someone whom she loved very much but not in the way she loved Michael. And she would not be allowed to do so. Permission would not be willingly given, every obstacle would be put in their way. So, like other young people, they were going to elope. There was no need for them to fly off to Gretna Green, they were of sufficiently mature age to marry. So she appealed to Archdeacon Brabazon, her old friend who had confirmed herâwho was a real friend. And the wedding was arranged, the day, the time, probably even she bought secretly some garment in which to be married. They were to meet somewhere, no doubt. They were to come to the rendezvous separately. I think he came there, but she did not come. He waited perhaps. Waited and then tried to find out, perhaps, why she didnât come. I think then a message may have been given him, even a letter sent him, possibly in her forged handwriting, saying she had changed her mind. It was all over and she was going away for a time to get over it. I donât know. But I donât think he ever dreamt of the real reason of why she hadnât come, of why she had sent no word. He hadnât thought for one moment that she had been deliberately, cruelly, almost madly perhaps, destroyed. Clotilde was not going to lose the person she loved. She was not going to let her escape, she was not going to let her go to the young man whom she herself hated and loathed. She would keep Verity, keep her in her own way. But what I could not believe wasâI did not believe that sheâd strangled the girl and had then disfigured her face. I donât think she could have borne to do that. I think that she had rearranged the bricks of the fallen greenhouse and piled up earth and turf over most of it. The girl had already been given a drink, an overdose of sleeping draught probably. Grecian, as it were, in tradition. One cup of hemlockâeven if it wasnât hemlock. And she buried the girl there in the garden, piled the bricks over her and the earth and the turfââ

âDid neither of the other sisters suspect it?â

âMrs. Glynne was not there then. Her husband had not died and she was still abroad. But Anthea was there. I think Anthea did know something of what went on. I donât know that she suspected death at first, but she knew that Clotilde had been occupying herself with the raising up of a mound at the end of the garden to be covered with flowering shrubs, to be a place of beauty. I think perhaps the truth came to her little by little. And then Clotilde, having accepted evil, done evil, surrendered to evil, had no qualms about what she would do next. I think she enjoyed planning it. She had a certain amount of influence over a sly, sexy little village girl who came to her cadging for benefits now and then. I think it was easy for her to arrange one day to take the girl on a picnic or an expedition a good long way away. Thirty or forty miles. Sheâd chosen the place beforehand, I think. She strangled the girl, disfigured her, hid her under turned earth, leaves and branches. Why should anyone ever suspect her of doing any such thing? She put Verityâs handbag there and a little chain Verity used to wear round her neck and possibly dressed her in clothes belonging to Verity. She hoped the crime would not be found out for some time but in the meantime she spread abroad rumours of Nora Broad having been seen about in Michaelâs car, going about with Michael. Possibly she spread a story that Verity had broken off the engagement to be married because of his infidelity with this girl. She may have said anything and I think everything she said she enjoyed, poor lost soul.â

âWhy do you say âpoor lost soul,â Miss Marple?â

âBecause,â said Miss Marple, âI donât suppose there can be any agony so great as what Clotilde has suffered all this timeâten years nowâliving in eternal sorrow. Living, you see, with the thing she had to live with. She had kept Verity, kept her there at The Old Manor House, in the garden, kept her there for ever. She didnât realize at first what that meant. Her passionate longing for the girl to be alive again. I donât think she ever suffered from remorse. I donât think she had even that consolation. She just sufferedâwent on suffering year after year. And I know now what Elizabeth Temple meant. Better perhaps than she herself did. Love is a very terrible thing. It is alive to evil, it can be one of the most evil things there can be. And she had to live with that day after day, year after year. I think, you know, that Anthea was frightened of that. I think she knew more clearly the whole time what Clotilde had done and she thought that Clotilde knew that she knew. And she was afraid of what Clotilde might do. Clotilde gave that parcel to Anthea to post, the one with the pullover. She said things to me about Anthea, that she was mentally disturbed, that if she suffered from persecution or jealousy Anthea might do anything. I thinkâyesâthat in the not so distant futureâsomething might have happened to Antheaâan arranged suicide because of a guilty conscienceââ

âAnd yet you are sorry for that woman?â asked Sir Andrew. âMalignant evil is like cancerâa malignant tumour. It brings suffering.â

âOf course,â said Miss Marple.

âI suppose you have been told what happened that night,â said Professor Wanstead, âafter your guardian angels had removed you?â

âYou mean Clotilde? She had picked up my glass of milk, I remember. She was still holding it when Miss Cooke took me out of the room. I suppose sheâdrank it, did she?â

âYes. Did you know that might happen?â

âI didnât think of it, no, not at the moment. I suppose I could have known it if Iâd thought about it.â

âNobody could have stopped her. She was so quick about it, and nobody quite realized there was anything wrong in the milk.â

âSo she drank it.â

âDoes that surprise you?â

âNo, it would have seemed to her the natural thing to do, one canât really wonder. It had come by this time that she wanted to escapeâfrom all the things she was having to live with. Just as Verity had wanted to escape from the life that she was living there. Very odd, isnât it, that the retribution one brings on oneself fits so closely with what has caused it.â

âYou sound sorrier for her than you were for the girl who died.â

âNo,â said Miss Marple, âitâs a different kind of being sorry. Iâm sorry for Verity because of all that she missed, all that she was so near to obtaining. A life of love and devotion and service to the man she had chosen, and whom she truly loved. Truly and in all verity. She missed all that and nothing can give that back to her. Iâm sorry for her because of what she didnât have. But she escaped what Clotilde had to suffer. Sorrow, misery, fear and a growing cultivation and imbibing of evil. Clotilde had to live with all those. Sorrow, frustrated love which she could never get back, she had to live with the two sisters who suspected, who were afraid of her, and she had to live with the girl she had kept there.â

âYou mean Verity?â

âYes. Buried in the garden, buried in the tomb that Clotilde had prepared. She was there in The Old Manor House and I think Clotilde knew she was there. It might be that she even saw her or thought she saw her, sometimes when she went to pick a spray of polygonum blossom. She must have felt very close to Verity then. Nothing worse could happen to her, could it, than that? Nothing worseâ¦.â

Twenty-three

END PIECES

I

âThat old lady gives me the creeps,â said Sir Andrew McNeil, when he had said good-bye and thanks to Miss Marple.

âSo gentleâand so ruthless,â said the Assistant Commissioner.

Professor Wanstead took Miss Marple down to his car which was waiting, and then returned for a few final words.

âWhat do you think of her, Edmund?â

âThe most frightening woman I ever met,â said the Home Secretary.

âRuthless?â asked Professor Wanstead.

âNo, no, I donât mean that butâwell, a very frightening woman.â

âNemesis,â said Professor Wanstead thoughtfully.

âThose two women,â said the P.P.D. man, âyou know, the security agents who were looking after her, they gave a most extraordinary description of her that night. They got into the house quite easily, hid themselves in a small downstairs room until everyone went upstairs, then one went into the bedroom and into the wardrobe and the other stayed outside the room to watch. The one in the bedroom said that when she threw open the door of the wardrobe and came out, there was the old lady sitting up in bed with a pink fluffy shawl round her neck and a perfectly placid face, twittering away and talking like an elderly school marm. They said she gave them quite a turn.â

âA pink fluffy shawl,â said Professor Wanstead. âYes, yes, I do rememberâ.â

âWhat do you remember?â

âOld Rafiel. He told me about her, you know, and then he laughed. He said one thing heâd never forget in all his life. He said it was when one of the funniest scatterbrained old pussies heâd ever met came marching into his bedroom out in the West Indies, with a fluffy pink scarf round her neck, telling him he was to get up and do something to prevent a murder. And he said, âWhat on earth do you think youâre doing?â And she said she was Nemesis. Nemesis! He could not imagine anything less like it, he said. I like the touch of the pink woolly scarf,â said Professor Wanstead, thoughtfully, âI like that, very much.â

II

âMichael,â said Professor Wanstead, âI want to introduce you to Miss Jane Marple, whoâs been very active on your behalf.â

The young man of thirty-two looked at the white-haired, rather dicky old lady with a slightly doubtful expression.

âOhâerââ he said, âwell, I guess I have heard about it. Thanks very much.â

He looked at Wanstead.

âItâs true, is it, theyâre going to give me a free pardon or something silly like that?â

âYes. A release will be put through quite soon. Youâll be a free man in a very short time.â

âOh.â Michael sounded slightly doubtful.

âIt will take a little getting used to, I expect,â said Miss Marple kindly.

She looked at him thoughtfully. Seeing him in retrospect as he might have been ten years or so ago. Still quite attractiveâthough he showed all the signs of strain. Attractive, yes. Very attractive, she thought he would have been once. A gaiety about him then, there would have been, and a charm. Heâd lost that now, but it would come back perhaps. A weak mouth and attractively shaped eyes that could look you straight in the face, and probably had been always extremely useful for telling lies that you really wanted to believe. Very likeâwho was it?âshe dived into past memoriesâJonathan Birkin, of course. He had sung in the choir. A really delightful baritone voice. And how fond the girls had been of him! Quite a good job heâd had as a clerk in Messrs. Gabrielâs firm. A pity there had been that little matter of the cheques.

âOh,â said Michael. He said, with even more embarrassment, âItâs been very kind of you, Iâm sure, to take so much trouble.â

âIâve enjoyed it,â said Miss Marple. âWell, Iâm glad to have met you. Good-bye. I hope youâve got a very good time coming to you. Our country is in rather a bad way just now, but youâll probably find some job or other that you might quite enjoy doing.â

âOh yes. Thanks, thanks very much. IâI really am very grateful, you know.â

His tone sounded still extremely unsure about it.

âItâs not me you ought to be grateful to,â said Miss Marple, âyou ought to be grateful to your father.â

âDad? Dad never thought much of me.â

âYour father, when he was a dying man, was determined to see that you got justice.â

âJustice.â Michael Rafiel considered it.

âYes, your father thought Justice was important. He was, I think, a very just man himself. In the letter he wrote me asking me to undertake this proposition, he directed me to a quotation:

âLet Justice roll down like waters

And Righteousness like an everlasting stream.ââ

âOh! Whatâs it mean? Shakespeare?â

âNo, the Bibleâone has to think about itâI had to.â

Miss Marple unwrapped a parcel she had been carrying.

âThey gave me this,â she said. âThey thought I might like to have itâbecause I had helped to find out the truth of what had really happened. I think, though, that you are the person who should have first claim on itâthat is if you really want it. But maybe you do not want itââ

She handed him the photograph of Verity Hunt that Clotilde Bradbury-Scott had shown her once in the drawing room of The Old Manor House.

He took itâand stood with it, staring down on it â¦ His face changed, the lines of it softened, then hardened. Miss Marple watched him without speaking. The silence went on for some little time. Professor Wanstead also watchedâhe watched them both, the old lady and the boy.

It came to him that this was in some way a crisisâa moment that might affect a whole new way of life.

Michael Rafiel sighedâhe stretched out and gave the photograph back to Miss Marple.

âNo, you are right, I do not want it. All that life is goneâsheâs goneâI canât keep her with me. Anything I do now has got to be newâgoing forward. Youââ he hesitated, looking at herââYou understand?â

âYes,â said Miss MarpleââI understandâI think you are right. I wish you good luck in the life you are now going to begin.â

He said good-bye and went out.

âWell,â said Professor Wanstead, ânot an enthusiastic young man. He could have thanked you a bit more enthusiastically for what you did for him.â

âOh, thatâs quite all right,â said Miss Marple. âI didnât expect him to do so. It would have embarrassed him even more. It is, you know,â she added, âvery embarrassing when one has to thank people and start life again and see everything from a different angle and all that. I think he might do well. Heâs not bitter. Thatâs the great thing. I understand quite well why that girl loved himââ

âWell, perhaps heâll go straight this time.â

âOne rather doubts that,â said Miss Marple. âI donât know that heâd be able to help himself unlessâof course,â she said, âthe great thing to hope for is that heâll meet a really nice girl.â

âWhat I like about you,â said Professor Wanstead, âis your delightfully practical mind.â

III

âSheâll be here presently,â said Mr. Broadribb to Mr. Schuster.

âYes. The whole thingâs pretty extraordinary, isnât it?â

âI couldnât believe it at first,â said Broadribb. âYou know, when poor old Rafiel was dying, I thought this whole thing wasâwell, senility or something. Not that he was old enough for that.â

The buzzer went. Mr. Schuster picked up the phone.

âOh, sheâs here, is she? Bring her up,â he said. âSheâs come,â he said. âI wonder now. You know, itâs the oddest thing I ever heard in my life. Getting an old lady to go racketing round the countryside looking for she doesnât know what. The police think, you know, that that woman committed not just one murder but three. Three! I ask you! Verity Huntâs body was under the mound in the garden, just as the old lady said it was. She hadnât been strangled and the face was not disfigured.â

âI wonder the old lady herself didnât get done in,â said Mr. Broadribb. âFar too old to be able to take care of herself.â

âShe had a couple of detectives, apparently, looking after her.â

âWhat, two of them?â

âYes, I didnât know that.â

Miss Marple was ushered into their room.

âCongratulations, Miss Marple,â said Mr. Broadribb, rising to greet her.

âVery best wishes. Splendid job,â said Mr. Schuster, shaking hands.

Miss Marple sat down composedly on the other side of the desk.

âAs I told you in my letter,â she said, âI think I have fulfilled the terms of the proposition that was made to me. I have succeeded in what I was asked to do.â

âOh I know. Yes, weâve heard already. Weâve heard from Professor Wanstead and from the legal department and from the police authorities. Yes, itâs been a splendid job, Miss Marple. We congratulate you.â

âI was afraid,â said Miss Marple, âthat I would not be able to do what was required of me. It seemed so very difficult, almost impossible at first.â

âYes indeed. It seems quite impossible to me. I donât know how you did it, Miss Marple.â

âOh well,â said Miss Marple, âitâs just perseverance, isnât it, that leads to things.â

âNow about the sum of money we are holding. Itâs at your disposal at any time now. I donât know whether you would like us to pay it into your bank or whether you would like to consult us possibly as to the investment of it? Itâs quite a large sum.â

âTwenty thousand pounds,â said Miss Marple. âYes, it is a very large sum by my way of thinking. Quite extraordinary,â she added.

âIf you would like an introduction to our brokers, they could give you possibly some ideas about investing.â

âOh, I donât want to invest any of it.â

âBut surely it would beââ

âThereâs no point in saving at my age,â said Miss Marple. âI mean the point of this moneyâIâm sure Mr. Rafiel meant it that wayâis to enjoy a few things that one thought one never would have the money to enjoy.â

âWell, I see your point of view,â said Mr. Broadribb. âThen your instructions would be that we pay this sum of money into your bank?â

âMiddletonâs Bank, 132 High Street, St. Mary Mead,â said Miss Marple.

âYou have a deposit account, I expect. We will place it to your deposit account?â

âCertainly not,â said Miss Marple. âPut it into my current account.â

âYou donât thinkââ

âI do think,â said Miss Marple. âI want it in my current account.â

She got up and shook hands.

âYou could ask your bank managerâs advice, you know, Miss Marple. It really isâone never knows when one wants something for a rainy day.â

âThe only thing I shall want for a rainy day will be my umbrella,â said Miss Marple.

She shook hands with them both again.

âThank you so much, Mr. Broadribb. And you too, Mr. Schuster. Youâve been so kind to me, giving me all the information I needed.â

âYou really want that money put into your current account?â

âYes,â said Miss Marple. âIâm going to spend it, you know. Iâm going to have some fun with it.â

She looked back from the door and she laughed. Just for one moment Mr. Schuster, who was a man of more imagination than Mr. Broadribb, had a vague impression of a young and pretty girl shaking hands with the vicar at a garden party in the country. It was, as he realized a moment later, a recollection of his own youth. But Miss Marple had, for a minute, reminded him of that particular girl, young, happy, going to enjoy herself.

âMr. Rafiel would have liked me to have fun,â said Miss Marple.

She went out of the door.

âNemesis,â said Mr. Broadribb. âThatâs what Rafiel called her. Nemesis. Never seen anybody less like Nemesis, have you?â

Mr. Schuster shook his head.

âIt must have been another of Mr. Rafielâs little jokes,â said Mr. Broadribb.

The Agatha Christie Collection

THE HERCULE POIROT MYSTERIES

Match your wits with the famous Belgian detective.

The Mysterious Affair at Styles

The Murder on the Links

Poirot Investigates

The Murder of Roger Ackroyd

The Big Four

The Mystery of the Blue Train

Peril at End House

Lord Edgware Dies

Murder on the Orient Express

Three Act Tragedy

Death in the Clouds

The A.B.C. Murders

Murder in Mesopotamia

Cards on the Table

Murder in the Mews and Other Stories

Dumb Witness

Death on the Nile

Appointment with Death

Hercule Poirotâ€™s Christmas

Sad Cypress

One, Two, Buckle My Shoe

Evil Under the Sun

Five Little Pigs

The Hollow

The Labors of Hercules

Taken at the Flood

The Underdog and Other Stories

Mrs. McGintyâ€™s Dead

After the Funeral

Hickory Dickory Dock

Dead Manâ€™s Folly

Cat Among the Pigeons

The Clocks

Third Girl

Halloweâ€™en Party

Elephants Can Remember

Curtain: Poirotâ€™s Last Case

Explore more at www.AgathaChristie.com

The Agatha Christie Collection

THE MISS MARPLE MYSTERIES

Join the legendary spinster sleuth from
St. Mary Mead in solving murders far and wide.

The Murder at the Vicarage

The Body in the Library

The Moving Finger

A Murder Is Announced

They Do It with Mirrors

A Pocket Full of Rye

4:50 From Paddington

The Mirror Crackâ€™d from Side to Side

A Caribbean Mystery

At Bertramâ€™s Hotel

Nemesis

Sleeping Murder

Miss Marple: The Complete Short Stories

THE TOMMY AND TUPPENCE
MYSTERIES

Jump on board with the entertaining crime-solving
couple from Young Adventurers Ltd.

The Secret Adversary

Partners in Crime

N or M?

By the Pricking of My Thumbs

Postern of Fate

Explore more at www.AgathaChristie.com

The Agatha Christie Collection

Donâ€™t miss a single one of Agatha Christieâ€™s stand-alone novels and short-story collections.

The Man in the Brown Suit

The Secret of Chimneys

The Seven Dials Mystery

The Mysterious Mr. Quin

The Sittaford Mystery

Parker Pyne Investigates

Why Didnâ€™t They Ask Evans?

Murder Is Easy

The Regatta Mystery and Other Stories

And Then There Were None

Towards Zero

Death Comes as the End

Sparkling Cyanide

The Witness for the Prosecution and Other Stories

Crooked House

Three Blind Mice and Other Stories

They Came to Baghdad

Destination Unknown

Ordeal by Innocence

Double Sin and Other Stories

The Pale Horse

Star over Bethlehem: Poems and Holiday Stories

Endless Night

Passenger to Frankfurt

The Golden Ball and Other Stories

The Mousetrap and Other Plays

The Harlequin Tea Set

Explore more at www.AgathaChristie.com

About the Author

Agatha Christie is the most widely published author of all time and in any language, outsold only by the Bible and Shakespeare. Her books have sold more than a billion copies in English and another billion in a hundred foreign languages. She is the author of eighty crime novels and short-story collections, nineteen plays, two memoirs, and six novels written under the name Mary Westmacott.

She first tried her hand at detective fiction while working in a hospital dispensary during World War I, creating the now legendary Hercule Poirot with her debut novel The Mysterious Affair at Styles. With The Murder in the Vicarage, published in 1930, she introduced another beloved sleuth, Miss Jane Marple. Additional series characters include the husband-and-wife crime-fighting team of Tommy and Tuppence Beresford, private investigator Parker Pyne, and Scotland Yard detectives Superintendent Battle and Inspector Japp.

Many of Christieâ€™s novels and short stories were adapted into plays, films, and television series. The Mousetrap, her most famous play of all, opened in 1952 and is the longest-running play in history. Among her best-known film adaptations are Murder on the Orient Express (1974) and Death on the Nile (1978), with Albert Finney and Peter Ustinov playing Hercule Poirot, respectively. On the small screen Poirot has been most memorably portrayed by David Suchet, and Miss Marple by Joan Hickson and subsequently Geraldine McEwan and Julia McKenzie.

Christie was first married to Archibald Christie and then to archaeologist Sir Max Mallowan, whom she accompanied on expeditions to countries that would also serve as the settings for many of her novels. In 1971 she achieved one of Britainâ€™s highest honors when she was made a Dame of the British Empire. She died in 1976 at the age of eighty-five. Her one hundred and twentieth anniversary was celebrated around the world in 2010.

www.AgathaChristie.com

Visit www.AuthorTracker.com for exclusive information on your favorite HarperCollins authors.

THE AGATHA CHRISTIE COLLECTION

The Man in the Brown Suit

The Secret of Chimneys

The Seven Dials Mystery

The Mysterious Mr. Quin

The Sittaford Mystery

Parker Pyne Investigates

Why Didnâ€™t They Ask Evans?

Murder Is Easy

The Regatta Mystery and Other Stories

And Then There Were None

Towards Zero

Death Comes as the End

Sparkling Cyanide

The Witness for the Prosecution and
Â Â Â  Other Stories

Crooked House

Three Blind Mice and Other Stories

They Came to Baghdad

Destination Unknown

Ordeal by Innocence

Double Sin and Other Stories

The Pale Horse

Star over Bethlehem: Poems and
Â Â Â  Holiday Stories

Endless Night

Passenger to Frankfurt

The Golden Ball and Other Stories

The Mousetrap and Other Plays

The Harlequin Tea Set

The Hercule Poirot Mysteries

The Mysterious Affair at Styles

The Murder on the Links

Poirot Investigates

The Murder of Roger Ackroyd

The Big Four

The Mystery of the Blue Train

Peril at End House

Lord Edgware Dies

Murder on the Orient Express

Three Act Tragedy

Death in the Clouds

The A.B.C. Murders

Murder in Mesopotamia

Cards on the Table

Murder in the Mews and Other Stories

Dumb Witness

Death on the Nile

Appointment with Death

Hercule Poirotâ€™s Christmas

Sad Cypress

One, Two, Buckle My Shoe

Evil Under the Sun

Five Little Pigs

The Hollow

The Labors of Hercules

Taken at the Flood

The Underdog and Other Stories

Mrs. McGintyâ€™s Dead

After the Funeral

Hickory Dickory Dock

Dead Manâ€™s Folly

Cat Among the Pigeons

The Clocks

Third Girl

Halloweâ€™en Party

Elephants Can Remember

Curtain: Poirotâ€™s Last Case

The Miss Marple Mysteries

The Murder at the Vicarage

The Body in the Library

The Moving Finger

A Murder Is Announced

They Do It with Mirrors

A Pocket Full of Rye

4:50 from Paddington

The Mirror Crackâ€™d from Side to Side

A Caribbean Mystery

At Bertramâ€™s Hotel

Nemesis

Sleeping Murder

Miss Marple: The Complete
Â Â Â  Short Stories

The Tommy and Tuppence Mysteries

The Secret Adversary

Partners in Crime

N or M?

By the Pricking of My Thumbs

Postern of Fate

Credits

Cover illustration and design by Sara Wood

Copyright

This book is a work of fiction. The characters, incidents, and dialogue are drawn from the authorâ€™s imagination and are not to be construed as real. Any resemblance to actual events or persons, living or dead, is entirely coincidental.

AGATHA CHRISTIEÂ® MARPLEÂ® MISS MARPLEÂ® NEMESISâ„¢. Copyright Â© 2011 Agatha Christie Limited (a Chorion company). All rights reserved. Nemesis was first published in 1971.

NEMESIS Â© 1971. Published by permission of G.P. Putnamâ€™s Sons, a member of Penguin Group (USA) Inc. All rights reserved under International and Pan-American Copyright Conventions. By payment of the required fees, you have been granted the nonexclusive, nontransferable right to access and read the text of this e-book on-screen. No part of this text may be reproduced, transmitted, downloaded, decompiled, reverse-engineered, or stored in or introduced into any information storage and retrieval system, in any form or by any means, whether electronic or mechanical, now known or hereinafter invented, without the express written permission of HarperCollins e-books.

Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data is available upon request.

ISBN 978-0-06-207370-9

EPub Edition Â© MAY 2011 ISBN: 978-0-06-175383-1

11 12 13 14 15

About the Publisher

Australia

HarperCollins Publishers (Australia) Pty. Ltd.

25 Ryde Road (P.O. Box 321)

Pymble, NSW 2073, Australia

www.harpercollins.com.au/ebooks

Canada

HarperCollins Canada

2 Bloor Street East - 20th Floor

Toronto, ON, M4W, 1A8, Canada

http://www.harpercollins.ca

New Zealand

HarperCollins Publishers (New Zealand) Limited

P.O. Box 1

Auckland, New Zealand

http://www.harpercollins.co.nz

United Kingdom

HarperCollins Publishers Ltd.

77-85 Fulham Palace Road

London, W6 8JB, UK

http://www.harpercollins.co.uk

United States

HarperCollins Publishers Inc.

10 East 53rd Street

New York, NY 10022

http://www.harpercollins.com